News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by forgotpwtomain on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @03:49PM (#10583850)
I think it's very clear to everyone not tuning into to the mass-media narrative that the true goal of all the governments and agencies involved is not "preventing the next terror threat" but a power-play for the control of information.

Not only is there no pertinent evidence to demonstrate that surveillance has ever paid off; There is much more so, extremely pertinent evidence that demonstrates the past 30 years of foreign policy have directly contributed to past and current day terrorist threats: Financing the Taliban and Bin-laden to fight the soviets in the 80's, invading and destabilizing Iraq, financing Syrian rebels (in part ISIS supporters and/or sympthathizers) while destabilizing Syria, etc, etc..- Yet somehow none of this is part of the main-stream narrative and a couple months later Obama will be asking congress for more funds to fight Assad and the NSA will be asking for broader surveillance powers.

I'm very sorry for the people that have lost their family members and loved ones in the course of these things but the answer is not and cannot be "more drone strikes" and "everyone forfeit your privacy".

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by jacobolus on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:22PM (#10584039)
30 years is a pretty short time horizon to look at. Western meddling as a driver of chaos and authoritarianism in the Middle East stretches back at least a century or two.

If Europeans hadn’t drawn completely arbitrary national borders all over the region after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, if Palestine had been left to its Arab inhabitants instead of displacing them in favor of European Jews, if the British and Americans hadn’t put so much emphasis on securing the Suez Canal via support for friendly dictatorships nearby, if the US hadn’t toppled the Iranian democracy under Mosaddegh in 1953 to reinstall the Shah, if Western European, Russian, and American guns hadn’t been handed out on all sides like candy, etc., the region would certainly be far different from now.

But it’s impossible to guess exactly what the effects of some counterfactual foreign policy over the past century would be.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by forgotpwtomain on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:50PM (#10584221)
> But it’s impossible to guess exactly what the effects of some counterfactual foreign policy over the past century would be.

It's true we can only speculate as to what the results of a different foreign policy might have been - but after years of disastrous foreign policies with all of the same destructive elements - Maybe it's time to build some schools and hospitals instead of bombing another city, sending more guns or eroding more human rights?

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mc32 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:38PM (#10584140)
Arbitrary borders doesn't explain it all. Africa has just as many arbitrary borders and lots of wars and insurrection happened and continue to happen, but except for north Africa, sub-Saharan Africa doesn't suffer the same kind of chaos and terrorism except for where isil AQ, etc have operatives. So, Africa seems to indicate that terrorism requires a foreign religious aspect in order to take root.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by exelius on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:28PM (#10584461)
Arbitrary borders + tribal politics describes pretty much all of it. I mean, we talk about Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq like they are countries, but they're really more like negative space.

Africa absolutely suffers the same kind of chaos and terrorism -- we just don't hear about it because it's less densely populated and the people there have darker skin. But Boko Haram is still a huge problem in Nigeria and Islamic fundamentalism in Somalia is a way bigger problem than you would think given the total lack of news coverage (the US launches almost as many drone strikes on eastern Africa as it does in the middle east).

Much of sub-saharan Africa is still under de-facto apartheid. Wealthy (often white) land owners are in bed with corrupt government officials who, while black, are more than happy to continue the status quo as long as they get paid. It's very hard to have a cohesive ideology behind your insurgency when there are for-profit death squads operating in the area. But you're right; there is also no great unifying force for the people in the area like there is in the middle east and north Africa.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mc32 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:55PM (#10585412)
Bokoharam and alshahab are extensions of the problems in north Africa, they are not indigenous to subsaharan Africa. You don't see the dame problems in Mozambique or Angola or Botswana. These places have had their problems but they don't export them and don't fancy taking the rest of the world down with them.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by lukeschlather on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:58PM (#10584287)
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mc32 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:04PM (#10584326)
Oh, I understand that, I thought it was understood it was about taking these causes abroad to lands unrelated using previous historical injustice as a cause to wreak havoc on unrelated innocents. Say after the us civil war the south went down to Mexico and set off bombs and declared war till all were dixified or dead.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by msbarnett on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:33PM (#10585930)
The Klan? The fedayeen?

I'm not really sure your criteria even fits ISIS, really. "Historic injustice" isn't their motivation.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mleonhard on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:14PM (#10584713)
West Africa is full of fighting and has been for thousands of years. The transition to democracy (and stability) is made more difficult by the arbitrary borders drawn by Europeans. For example, Ghana has 71 languages and three major cultural divisions. It should probably be at least 3 countries (including parts of neighboring Ivory Coast and Togo). The square borders do not match where the people live. For example, the Adele people live on the border between Ghana and Togo. They enjoy half the political representation they deserve in both countries.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by api on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:40PM (#10584150)
I'm sure the fact that the Middle East sits on the world's largest deposits of cheap-to-extract high-EROEI and therefore maximally profitable oil has absolutely nothing to do with it. :)

The amount of oil in the ground in places like Canada might indeed rival the Middle East, but it's lower-EROEI more expensive oil. The amount of money in the ground is higher in the Middle East than anywhere else. Sub-Saharan Africa does have quite a bit of resource wealth but it doesn't have anywhere near as fat and juicy a prize as the ME does.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mc32 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:51PM (#10584226)
So how does that explain Yemen, or the troubles in the Philippines? Are they overflowing with rich resources? Contrast Mindanao with the rest of the PH.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by api on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:56PM (#10584269)
My impression is that at least some of those are satellite conflicts driven by propaganda and actual groups from the Middle East like ISIS. Control of the Middle East and its oil wealth seems like the overall objective behind the various proxy armies and constant "regime change" in the region.

I'm not sure why this is such a terribly controversial idea. You have trillions of dollars in assets sitting in the ground under a politically unstable region, so why is it so bizarre to suggest that people are fighting over it? There are people who will shoot you for your wallet, so what will they do for access to world-remaking levels of wealth?

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by Phlarp on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:16PM (#10584401)
You think middle eastern politics are the driving factors for unrest in the Philippines?

Maybe we should start with remedial geography.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by Laforet on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:21PM (#10584756)
Why not? Saudi money (not the Saudi government, but they are indirectly responsible) enables and sustains political Islam worldwide. Muslims in South East Asia have been practicising a pretty laid back version of Islam for centuries: No pork, no veils and mingling of opposite gender over a few bottles of booze may be looked down upon, but never a cardinal sin. All of this is changing for the worse because ME has been aggressively exporting their Medina theology for the last two or three decades[0].

[0]: http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/11/09/islam-is-a-religion-of-v...

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by Qwertious on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:48PM (#10584587)
Hey, where do I sign up? None of my geography classes talked about middle-eastern politics or sources of unrest.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by jdc on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:59PM (#10585828)
Not the only factor, but the Saudis have funneled a great deal of oil money into spreading Wahhabism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_propagation_of_c...

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by arca_vorago on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:47PM (#10584203)
"true goal of all the governments and agencies is...a power-play for the control of information."

You sir, are very close to the truth. The reality is that it isn't about control of the information per se, but what can be accomplished with said information. In this case, the "information" we are referring to is the massive amount of metadata we generate, not to mention the content thereof, and I would posit that the true goal is the control of the people, through ownership of the information. The distinction is a small but important one. It is about control, not security, and anybody saying otherwise is generally ill-informed or ignorant.

From an intelligence side of things, it used to take so much effort to do dirty tricks on people. You had to black bag their place of residence, you had to tail them for days, weeks, sometimes months.

These days, you just PRISM/ECHELON your way into their data, pull all the dirt you need out, and approach them with your demands as you will.

This is only one of the most palpable dangers of the surveillance age, in that the intel agencies and potential moles/infiltrators can potentially have vast amounts of power over institutions they shouldn't, for example, congress. It's essentially setting us up for a coup d'etat of the oligarchy. (people need to remember that the OSS/CIA came straight out of London/WallStreet! I think people should also be made aware of the often at odds nature of the different intel agencies. I think military intelligence is rightly suspicious of the Company.)

I spent a long time trying to understand this machine because I was an action arm of it at one time (and perhaps if called upon, may one day again be), and my conclusions are not hopeful, pretty, and often are considered conspiracy theory. What I have said above only scratches the surface.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by heroh on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:33PM (#10585744)
>What I have said above only scratches the surface.

keep going.

be aware the analytical & technically savy are also considered threats to the establishment: "NSA: Linux Journal is an "extremist forum" and its readers get flagged for extra surveillance"

http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/nsa-linux-journal-extrem...

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by arca_vorago on Thursday November 19, 2015 @06:12AM (#10594100)
Well, that leaves it pretty open, but heres a quick rundown:

We found out about continuity of government during Iran contra, but were misled into thinking it went away. The people mostly responsible for it were the same neocons who manipulated GW Bush (eg: Wolfowitz, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Bremer) The best writing about this is from former diplomat Peter Dale Scott. I think it's possible that CoG is in effect and the Constitution has been secretly superseded by secret law. (Originally designed for nuclear attack, it was later expanded to be overly broad so as to potentially apply to almost any "national emergency". By the way, we have officially been in a state of "national emergency" since 2001, with renewal every year by all presidents since.

Beyond that, resource wars are incoming, which includes a reduction of the power of the petrodollar, which is the core reason behind expansion into the Middle East, Africa and the Russian border (Georgia 08, Ukraine).

Add to that the fact that since 2010 Citizens United, corruption of our electoral process is almost unilateral, that we are haemorrhaging jobs to overseas (which will increase once the TPP TTIP inevitably passes), and even if the horribly destructive so called "free-trade" systems don't do it, we are on the verge of an automation age which will remove many jobs from the market, and the oligarchy are increasingly done extracting wealth from third world countries and have turned inward and are now eating their own people so to say.

With the surveillance engine already in place, the inevitable unrest will be put down harshly (for national security of course), and the internet will be balkanised and the real world model of law will be applied to the internet... you know, the one were everything is illegal and everyone commits at least three felonies a day, so then you can arbitrarily enforce the law in order to stifle dissent.

All three branches of the government are compromised, and the fourth estate is in the gutter, along with the education system.

So basically we are returning to some strange form of neo-fuedalism, but this time it will be high-tech and global.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:18PM (#10584408)
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by arca_vorago on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:20PM (#10584422)
Thank you for the correction, mental note added and comment edited.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by exelius on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:48PM (#10584585)
So I am of two minds with regards to foreign intervention by the US.

On one hand, I'm horrified at the things the US does. We kill innocents, we send our own citizens to die for really very little reason, and we spend an epic fuck ton of money with very little to show in terms of tactical results. We stick our nose in situations that don't involve us just because we can, and I'm tired of the US always being the world's police force.

On the other hand, global power politics aren't about playing nice. As far as hegemonist world powers throughout history go, the US is relatively benevolent (wiretaps and extrajudicial renditions are nothing compared to the genocides perpetrated by nearly every preceding global power). In the absence of a dominant global power, you would have multiple equally-matched regional powers vying for supremacy -- a situation that would almost certainly end in war and the emergence of a new, potentially less benevolent global power. A lot of innocent people likely die in this scenario too.

The world is undoubtedly a safer place because the US does horrible things to bad people (and yes, at times to good people too). The fact that there is a single superpower that can and will defeat anyone, anywhere deters a lot of large-scale bad behavior -- the last 70 years since WWII have been some of the most peaceful in human history. Casualty counts from armed conflict measure in the thousands to tens of thousands; not the hundreds of thousands or millions that you'd see in a major war.

But that still doesn't make what the US does in regards to surveillance right. Can there be world peace without a dominant military power to keep everyone in check? I don't know, but we should at least try to find out.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by ihsw on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:11PM (#10583982)
Indeed, the elephant in the room is Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Both have a significant interest in the removal of the Ba'athist government from Syria, and they have both expended significant resources in achieving this goal (officially or otherwise).

Resources which Isil has benefited from handsomely, and in fact the only reason Turkey and the KSA are currently engaging Isil directly is because of the domestic threat posed by homegrown Isil cells. While the West is equally guilty of this abject laziness and callousness, Turkey and the KSA have contributed far more to the global jihadi movement than any other organization since Isil announced independence in June 2014.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by forgotpwtomain on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:15PM (#10584005)
From my understanding Turkey had a basically "hear no evil, see no evil" policy for anti-Assad rebels and arms-shipments across their border and the US encouraged this(!).

As for Saudi Arabia, their government is just about as bad as Assad on human rights - which of course doesn't prevent the US and US politicians from being very cozy with them as long as it serves their geo-political agenda.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by ihsw on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:27PM (#10584065)
Honestly, regarding Saudi Arabia, I think their strategy is to buy as much equipment as possible so that the West has no choice but to prop up the House of Saud.

Why do they have no choice? Well, if the House of Saud falls then the weapons would reach the hands of jihadist terrorists before you can say "9/11," and the Royal Saudi Army has a very large stockpile of all of the best hardware you can buy with petrodollars.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:00PM (#10584642)
An airforce able to rival the Marines does not "fall into the hands of terrorists". Saudi Arabia wants to be a regional power and wants to back that up with force. Oh and suppress domestic unrest.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by jqm on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:21PM (#10584757)
"As for Saudi Arabia, their government is just about as bad as Assad on human rights"

They are a whole lot worse.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:18PM (#10585274)
It's hard to be worse than mustard gas...
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by jqm on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:06PM (#10585657)
Did Assad actually use mustard gas? Is stockpiling mustard gas better or worse than stockpiling nuclear missiles? Just things to think about.

As for human rights... KSA is considerably worse than Assad.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by merpnderp on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:42PM (#10584175)
Wikileaks shows that the US and allies have been financing and working towards instability in Syria since 2007. Maybe working with Russia to temper Assad would have been a better solution, or perhaps some other avenue. But overthrowing Assad has been an epic disaster and more surveillance isn't the answer.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:20PM (#10585278)
"Maybe working with Russia to temper Assad would have been a better solution"

I believe the word you're searching for is "banana republic"

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by merpnderp on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @01:16PM (#10589600)
Japan, S. Korea, and Taiwan were at some point in their current governments, little more than puppet governments of the US. A corrupt puppet of a US+Turkey+Saudi/Russian+Chinese+Iranian coalition that at least offered stability would be far preferable to the murderous chaos that exists now.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by rtl49 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:19PM (#10584022)
Possibly so, though if you believe this, presumably the powers that be would not be above fabricating such evidence.

Bear in mind that the data used in this article are from arrest records. In fact, many of the arrests supposedly resulting from online activity could just as easily have occurred because of reports by concerned citizens. Would you put it past the authorities to seize a suspected terrorist identified through dragnet surveillance without creating a record of arrest? I think it is not inconceivable.

If you are opposed to mass surveillance, I think the best argument is that its social costs surpass the benefit of reducing terrorism. But perhaps this is not such a palatable argument after two well-publicized tragedies.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by brlewis on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:26PM (#10584060)
You speak of "the benefit of reducing terrorism" as if it's a given rather than a hypothetical possibility.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by rtl49 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:42PM (#10584171)
No I don't. There I grant the opposition their belief as a stipulation for the purpose of making a more salient point: terrorism is not so destructive as people tend to think, and regulating the flow of information is more destructive than people tend to think. Thus we avoid the challenge of quantifying mass surveillance's efficacy in reducing terrorism.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by privacy101 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @07:33PM (#10585087)
Economic and political espionage are probably the main goals if this mass spying.
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by happyscrappy on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:46PM (#10584567)
>the true goal of all the governments and agencies involved is not "preventing the next terror threat" but a power-play for the control of information.

This is a laughable statement but typically upvoted on HN. Politicians have to appear to have done everything possible to prevent these attacks. They are not dictators, if the public feels they were soft on terror they are gone, no pentaverate necessary.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by indrax on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @07:16PM (#10584993)
>appear >public feels

You did not make a counterargument.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by sampo on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:17PM (#10584405)
> Financing the Taliban and Bin-laden to fight the soviets in the 80's

Can anyone make guesses how Afghanistan would have turned out if the Soviets had been let to freely occupy Afghanistan? Would the country have turned into another North Korea, or perhaps something like Afghanistan's northern neighbors, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, are today?

Or would the secular socialistic and religious elements have gone into civil war anyway, even without the US supporting the religious side?

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by chimeracoder on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:27PM (#10584450)
Honestly? Afghanistan's a really difficult region to unify politically; it's only happened a handful of times in history. On top of that, the global trend in the last ~100 years has been towards nationalism and away from consolidated, sprawling empires. Due to the geography and ethnic composition of Afghanistan, it's highly unlikely that the Soviets would have been able to do exercise much control over it in the long-run with any semblance of stability[0]. So I'd be very skeptical of the idea that it would have turned into anything resembling North Korea.

In all honesty, it would probably look relatively similar to what it does today. In that alternate universe, it wouldn't necessarily be the Taliban itself that came to power, but the group that occupied that role would be similar in ideology and effect to the Taliban that exists in this universe.

[0] ignoring the pending collapse of the USSR, of course, but since this is all speculation anyway, we can take some liberties.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by sampo on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:07PM (#10584672)
> it would probably look relatively similar to what it does today.

So, speculatively, even without the US supporting the mujahideen in the 80s, the Soviets would have eventually left, Taliban or something similar would have kind-of-won the civil war, and Afghanistan would be about the same chaos as it is now. So why is US blamed for "destabilizing Afghanistan" and "unintended consequences", if the area would probably be similarly unstable even in this alternate timeline? And if bin Laden and such are anti-American in our universe, even after having received American support in the 80s, they surely would be anti-American in the alternate timeline, too?

So if the US meddling didn't change anything for the worse, why all the blame?

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by chimeracoder on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @06:14PM (#10584712)
> why is US blamed for "destabilizing Afghanistan" and "unintended consequences", if the area would probably be similarly unstable even in this alternate timeline? if the US meddling didn't change anything for the worse, why all the blame?

Well, first, I didn't say that the US "didn't change anything for the worse". I just said that it wouldn't have resulted in a more stable regime, ceteris paribus. Stability is not the only axis on which to evaluate whether the result would have been better or worse[0].

And we're just talking about the US's actions. The US and the USSR are both responsible for the current situation; the "blame" doesn't have to be assigned unilaterally to one single entity.

[0] I'm also deliberately not defining "stability", because that's already an incredibly hefty topic when discussing middle eastern history and politics.

Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by mahyarm on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:43PM (#10584554)
Would a balkanized afghanistan be politically stable eventually then?
Re:U.S. Mass Surveillance Has No Record of Thwarting Large T... by chimeracoder on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:57PM (#10584630)
We're talking about a country that's been used essentially as a pawn by the major imperial powers of each era for the last 200+ years. (This situation is not unique to Afghanistan - which is why many other countries have similar problems - but Afghanistan's geography compounds the effect).

The British, Russians, US, Ottomans, Mughals, Safavids - all of them have spent significant time and effort (not to mention military power) trying to secure the region for "their" side. All of them struggled with it, to the point where it's debatable whether any of them ever succeeded.

This situation continues on today - so no, I don't think Afghanistan can ever be politically stable as long as it continues to hold this role in global geopolitics[0]. Perhaps circumstances will change and we'll start to see a more stable regime emerge there, but it's kind of hard to force that when one of the major causes for instability in the last two centuries has been external influence in the first place.

EDIT: Unrelated to the answer, but I find the use of the word 'balkanized' particularly amusing given the etymology (it refers to the fragmentation of parts of the former Ottoman empire into many states that compete with each other for regional influence). Afghanistan is not part of the Balkan peninsula, but it did have its own fascinating power struggle with the Ottoman empire, and the breakup of the Ottoman empire in the early 20th century was a major turning point that influenced the current state of Afghanistan today.

[0] I'm not sure any country really could be, for what it's worth, but we're talking about Afghanistan.