News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by dang on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @03:08PM (#10583603)
Please don't do this here.

I understand the sport in extracting the most uncharitable interpretation of a thing and distilling it into the most concentrated snark that you can, but amusing as that can be, you harm the community by posting it here.

Snark always gets many upvotes, perhaps because we enjoy the dopamine rush of briefly feeling superior to others. Such comments rise to the top, become emblematic, and pretty soon we're all in the habit of looking for clever ways to put others down instead of learning and asking questions together.

This is an existential risk to HN, since if we lose the open-minded exploratory quality of the threads (never secure to begin with, and always under pressure from stronger forces), successive waves of thoughtful users will exit, putting the community into a fatal feedback loop.

Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by timrpeterson on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @03:39PM (#10583795)
I think sanitizing the community possibly puts it at even greater risk. Look at stackoverflow whose contributors are dwindling due to overmodding. There is learning in this comment. You are the one layering on the interpretation of the need to feel superior. That wasn't how I read it.
Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by tomhoward on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:03PM (#10583928)
Encouraging civility and kindness is no risk to a community that is at its best when people are civil and kind. The campaign to promote civility and eradicate meanness has been waged publicly by Dang for over 18 months and more quietly by PG and other mods for long before that. The overall volume of contributions hasn't gone down and the volume of thoughtful and substantive contributions had gone up, and for me it feels like a more safe and welcoming place in which to post thoughtful comments.

The point of the comment could have been made in a civil and thoughtful way if the commenter chose to do so, and when people do that, there is far more "learning" to be had and we all benefit.

Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by dang on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:03PM (#10583930)
> You are the one layering on the interpretation

That may be. I replaced "probably" with "perhaps".

I don't think "sanitizing" is an accurate description of what we do or call for, though I get that it's a rhetorical way of saying not to take things too far. Overmodding is definitely not the goal—undermodding is. The dream is to get it asymptotically approaching zero. That requires a self-regulating community, which requires a self-sustaining culture. Most of what we do, when not posting "please stop" and whatnot, involves figuring out how to get there.

Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by s73v3r on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @04:24PM (#10584051)
I refuse to believe that encouraging people to not be assholes to each other, and to not shit on people sharing their stories is "sanitizing".
Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by timrpeterson on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @05:32PM (#10584482)
So how would have been an acceptable way for the commenter to make his point? Saying they sh*t on the other person is IMHO really dramatic.
Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by dang on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @03:30AM (#10586627)
> So how would have been an acceptable way for the commenter to make his point?

If by "acceptable" you mean better for HN, it's not hard to imagine a thoughtful comment about the difference between making money from an app product vs. an app-building shop. Also it would be easy not to belittle the OP's achievement (as "empower others to fail", for example, does).

Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by CyrilBoh on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#10585561)
I would start by not using the the Step 1, Step 2 format.

To me saying they sh*t on the other person is accurate because to me he is not trying to offer anything constructive. I understand your opinion may differ.

Re:How I Quit My Job and Built My First App by chillwaves on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:51PM (#10585978)
Is accusing someone of shitting on another person, shitting on that person?