News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by dang on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @02:37PM (#10583439)
This comment and the ensuing subthread cross the line into generic religious flamewar. Please don't do that on HN.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by alvarosm on Monday November 23, 2015 @12:56PM (#10615997)
The censorship on HN is outright disgusting.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:59AM (#10581882)
You are entitled to your opinion. As a Muslim, I feel sorry for those who don't get Islam's message yet believe they do when all they're seeing is the surface.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by jules on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:17AM (#10582009)
I'm an atheist as well, but I realize that this may be just out of ignorance since I don't really know why somebody believes. Would you be willing to have a conversation about your faith so that I can understand the perspective of somebody who does believe?
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:44AM (#10582238)
Of course! Keep in mind that I'm just an average Muslim, so I might not be able to address all of your questions.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by jules on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @12:00PM (#10582374)
That's great, because one of the things I wonder most is what faith is like in day to day experience. I'll send you an email :)
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by utku_karatas2 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @07:39PM (#10585119)
You could also check out r/islam and post there for a wider audience.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by redial on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:25AM (#10582065)
When the message starts with a private 'revelation', not to me but to others, that I have to unquestionably accept giving some other mammal total control over my mind or be tortured forever, I don't need to be told anymore. It's insulting, childish, it belongs in the infancy of our species and it needs to be outgrown, never mind how 'good' it makes you feel inside.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:42AM (#10582217)
What private revelation? Go to your nearest bookstore and pick up the Quran. Problem solved.

"Other mammal" here refers to what exactly? As for punishment, that happens when you intentionally deny the existence of the Creator, even when given the access to His word and religion. Islam teaches us that human beings are born pure and good by default, unlike other religions.

Suppose you lived your life on a remote island, never knowing about Islam or the Quran. In that case, you will be treated as if you lived your whole life as a Muslim in the hereafter. Why? Because you did not actively and intentionally deny it, and were not aware of its existence.

If you think religion is childish, OK. I don't.

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by redial on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @12:03PM (#10582403)
Other mammals as in the ones who use religious texts to get 'power' in the real world. Politicians, military leaders, jihadists, and sadly even teachers and parents.

And was the Quran not a revelation from 'God' only to Muhammad? If he wants to believe it, fine, why should anybody else? Oh yes, eternal torture. It is childish to be told a story and believe it true only because they threaten you.

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @01:03PM (#10582827)
Oh yes, I agree. Unfortunately, we live in an imperfect world where not all followers of a religion follow its true message. You might say "well OK, so get rid of religion". People will still seek power, but in other ways. In other words, there are people who always seek the easiest way to gain more power and influence.

Yes, the Quran was revealed directly to Muhammad. He told his wife first, and she believed him. It just spread from there. I'd argue that the absolutely miracolous rate at which Islam spread throughout the region is a plus in favor of Islam :)

As for your point about eternal torture, let's say a guy comes up to you in the street nowadays and tells you he's a Prophet sent by God to save humanity. He tells you about this book called Mojimbi which is the word of God. At this point, you have complete freedom to accept of reject his claim. Unless he can convince you that what he's saying is true, you wouldn't believe him and he'd be on his way.

Muhammad however was able to convince people with two things.

One, he was known in his community to be an extremely honest person; never once did anyone hear of him lying. He was a trader, so he dealt with a lot of people. So when he said that he was visited by an angel etc, some people just believed him on the spot. Of course, many others called him crazy, so it wasn't a fool-proof plan.

Two, he had the Quran. Some background first. The community Muhammad lived in was very well-versed in the Arabic language. Most mastered the language and its intricacies by the age of 10, and were known as experts in poetry. Look it up, Arabic is extremely complex.

So he recites some verses from the Quran to people and claims that these are words from Allah (keep in mind he was illiterate). They were amazed, absolutely awestruck by the words coming out of his mouth. The structure and linguistic nature of the verses was perfect, and this was coming from experts in the language! One of the Prophet's biggest critics (and a great poet no less) at the time was almost going to join Islam just because of this.

Now, let's go back to the example. You're a professor of English language at Standford, and a guy you've dealt with a lot and who you know is an extremely honest person in all aspects tells you the same message. He also recites some verses that are so elegant and beautiful in structure that they make Shakespeare look like a pre-schooler's work, and tells you these are the words of God. Wouldn't that make things different?

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by terrn on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @01:59PM (#10583202)
Sigh...there are a lot of problems with your statement. The first is that you are reciting anecdotes from 1400 years ago; there is absolutely no proof of anything you said. Even if we accept that the Quran was given to Mohammed by God, we have to at least acknowledge the possibility that a lot of what you've learned has been added in by various persons over the course of many hundreds of years i.e. we cannot be so sure about anything that is written down, by anyone, at any time, especially from something as old as the Quran. And to be clear, that applies to all writing, the Bible, etc.

The second is that no, believing ANYBODY about ANYTHING, no matter how eloquently put, is foolish to say the least. It doesn't make a difference if they are my parent or not, never mind some professor or total stranger. The only person who can decide if something is right or not is YOU. Belief should not be based on how charismatic anyone is, that is irrelevant. Unfortunately, you have total responsibility for your actions and opinions and it is inexcusable to believe anyone or anything without first exploring your doubt. And even then it is up to you to walk the line of what should be believed and what should be questioned.

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @02:26PM (#10583375)
No, there is proof that that's how it started. These "anecdotes" were passed down by narration initially, then they were recorded by two scholars: Al Bukhari and Muslim. The methods they used for verification were amazing, which is why we believe most of what they deemed valid. If you'd like to know more about how they did this, I can elaborate.

As for the Quran, it has been passed down by rote memorization. This is the difference between it and other books: people memorized it AND wrote it down. No other book in history has been memorized by so many people at once. Even now the record stands. Of course, the Quran could be falsely memorized in a localized instance, but not in all places at once. Many attempts were made to falsify the Quran systematically, but they failed due to the sheer number of people who had it committed to memory.

I simply don't agree with your opinion on belief.

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Nursie on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:04AM (#10588441)
>> These "anecdotes" were passed down by narration initially

You've heard of "Chinese Whispers" right?

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:33AM (#10595274)
Yes, I have.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by redial on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @02:13PM (#10583294)
No, it doesn't make any difference at all.

The apparent beauty of the text says nothing about the truth of the text. Otherwise the King James Bible, considered by most English scholars to be one of the most, if not the most beautiful work of english literature would be entirely true.

I have no opinion on the honesty of Muhammad, it is irrelevant. He might have heard voices, or seen angels and visions on his head that were so real to him as the voice and sight of his own wife. His honesty makes no difference on the truth. Otherwise the visions and revelations of the most honest and righteous Buddhist monks would all be true.

The rate at which an idea spreads has no connection with the truth of the idea. Otherwise Christianity, Mormonism, Hinduism, Buddhism, and even Scientology would all be true.

The truth must stand on its own, in any language, spoken by any or no man. If an idea requires fear and intimidation to make itself true, then it needs no further examination.

Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Cyph0n on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @02:27PM (#10583383)
No difference at all? OK.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by Nursie on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @02:27PM (#10583384)
No, not one iota.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by sammydavis on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @01:13PM (#10582897)
What you are describing as a private revelation from god is not different than the ones in christianity, such as seeing that burning bush.
Re:VLC contributor living in Aleppo writing about the Paris ... by redial on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @01:34PM (#10583041)
Of course, that is why most religions are wrong in the same way.