News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by jarvuschris on Sunday November 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#10570222)
Sounds like this will block hosted analytics solutions like Google Analytics, but the same data is available to the first party site if they roll their own analytics. In this case you're not really adding any protection for the user, just disadvantaging smaller publishers in understanding how their site is being used
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by pdkl95 on Sunday November 15, 2015 @02:53PM (#10570881)
> block hosted analytics solutions like Google Analytics

That's the goal. The pattern-of-life[1] analysis that GA enables is an incredible long-term risk.

Allowing one entity to log almost all of your internet activities into one aggregated database creates a massive amount of potential-social-power. Even if Google isn't currently converting that potential-power into an abusive form, the very existence of that data in one location creates a huge temptation for thieves and governments with national security letters.

> roll their own analytics

Server logs only give you a view of the traffic to one website. There is a huge difference between one business knowing you use their service and a 3rd party carefully logging your entire daily schedule.

[1] I highly recommend reading http://labs.rs/en/metadata/ which unfortunately didn't get much attention when it was recently posted to HN. I suspect most people are still thinking way too small when judging what is possible from "just metadata".

Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by throwaway2048 on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:06PM (#10570390)
Google takes data from other sites/sources into account when it delivers data via google analytics, it is unquestionably tracking users from site to site.

It adds plenty of protection for the user to block it.

I have no idea how people can look at the demographic information GA delivers and then conclude it isn't tracking users around the web...

Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by rbaud on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:12PM (#10570421)
I use browser plugins to block ads and third-party trackers on all of my devices. I'm also a web developer, and I regularly set up Google Analytics accounts for my clients.

I agree that the proliferation of tracker blocking could be an issue for smaller publishers and businesses in the near future. But as a privacy-conscious internet user, I'm excited about the vacuum this might leave for better self-hosted options.

Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by JupiterMoon on Sunday November 15, 2015 @12:37PM (#10570288)
I don't understand. You are complaining that this blocks third party tracking right? This is what it is meant to do.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by StavrosK on Sunday November 15, 2015 @12:38PM (#10570293)
Google Analytics uses first-party cookies, though, not third-party.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by JupiterMoon on Monday November 16, 2015 @03:32AM (#10573278)
I said nothing about cookies. I said "third-party tracking". If I don't visit google's website and if they are tracking me on someone else's website then they are a third party. And I will block them if I can.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by throwaway2048 on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:09PM (#10570409)
that's meerly a technical detail. It fundamentally represents cross site tracking harvested by google.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by StavrosK on Sunday November 15, 2015 @01:15PM (#10570430)
How is it cross-site if the cookie is first-party?
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by kuschku on Sunday November 15, 2015 @05:10PM (#10571454)
Something can be third-party, but not cross-site. Google Analytics is one of those.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by StavrosK on Sunday November 15, 2015 @05:26PM (#10571510)
A third party cookie has a specific meaning. Google Analytics issues first party cookies.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by JupiterMoon on Monday November 16, 2015 @03:29AM (#10573263)
The issue that many of us are worried about is being tracked across the entire internet by a single entity who's site some of us don't even visit (definition of third party there). We don't care if this is done by what you call first party cookies, or what your call third party cookies, or measuring our mouse movements, or finger printing our browser, or just by watching us through our webcams/sending someone to our house to take notes we don't want it period. And we will block whatever means we can that these entities use to track us.
Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by michaelt on Sunday November 15, 2015 @06:20PM (#10571702)
Nobody has mentioned third party cookies except you.

Google analytics loads scripts from and sends results to Google. Those requests inevitably include IP address and referrer. That's more than enough.

Re:How Tracking Protection Works in Firefox by huhtenberg on Sunday November 15, 2015 @02:03PM (#10570630)
Uhm, no. You are completely missing the point.

What this does is it shows middle finger to Google, which is the tracking entity in the vast majority of cases.