This falls into the area of "jury argument" ;-)
However, i will point out "if you can't figure out whether it's safe, you generally have a duty to remove it or warn people it's possibly not safe".
(Whether i like the law or thing it just generates tons of warning labels, that is the law).
Should I have judged my test as 'inability to figure out if it was safe'?
Nothing short of a destructive test will tell you exactly what load a swing like this will support, but common sense will tell you to be careful with tree swings regardless of whether or not someone tells you that it is safe. It's a non-engineered project probably made on a budget (even though in this particular case the tree swing had chains rather than rope so it was constructed fairly well) and it ended up being the tree trunk that snapped rather than the branch the chains were attached to.
You can do a simple impedance test on the tree. If the tree had rot then electricity will go through the core faster due to additional water content. And they give you a nice graph to prove whether the tree is safe or dangerous.
If you as an individual want to own trees, and especially if you want to let others use your property, I don't see any reason why you should be held to a lesser standard of care than any municipality across the country. If you can't afford to keep your trees safe then you can't afford the trees and/or the property.
But yeah, this definitely isn't anything beyond what you'd learn in a plant pathology 101 class in college or a basic arborist certification.
1. Handling it like that might mean more cut down trees, which is probably not something the town/city has an interest in. (Maybe they should send professionals to check out all the trees?)
2. Properties can change hands much quicker than cut down trees can be regrown.
I am not sure what the point of point 2 is, when you have point 1. You don't really have to cut down all the untested trees on your property, but if you're not doing testing/maintenance on the trees for ANY reason(ignorance, cost), don't be surprised when one kills someone and you're held liable for it. You should consider this before buying a property with trees. It's similar to owning a dog. If you own a dog, and it runs out and bites someone, you will likely be held liable, and the dog will likely be put down. If the dog tests positive for rabies before even biting anyone, it will be put down, similar to a dead tree being cut down.
It will give my family the money they need to bury me. It will give my dependents a bit of the money I would have given them across the rest of my life.
> If you want to use an old tree-swing the onus is on you, the user to make sure that it is safe because if it isn't you pay the price.
Not if someone has charged me for access to the swing. It's the commercial activity that has caused the extra attention here.
> Liability insurance won't save your life if you get hit by a few hundred pounds of tree. It will just move money around.
By this argument you seem to be claiming that there's no liability in cases where people die. Just because you could have stayed alive by not doing something doesn't mean there is automatically no liability.
Obviously we agree that it would be better to not sing and be alive than to swing, die, and get a payout. I'm also not sure whether there is liability here legally, or even whether I think morally there was reasonable expectation that the swing was safe.
But surely the question of liability doesn't factor in whether or not the payout brings someone back to life, and this part of your comment obscures your point a bit.
No, that's not what I'm claiming. There are many cases in which there is clear liability when people die.
No, liability insurance moves money from the insurance company to the next of kin of the person who died from having a chunk of tree crack their head open like it was an egg. It does not protect you from this sort of thing.
Is anybody actually arguing that a property being covered by liability insurance makes the property safer? I suppose that is the case in more commercial/industrial settings where the insurance company has a list of requirements on the policy.
Change the scenario. Is it reasonable for the renter to assume that the floorboards in the building are sound? This really only differs in degree from that.
It's also code to have bedroom electric outlets protected by an AFCI.
I guess my point is that even though my reaction to your posts about fire is that it seems paranoid, those accommodations are supposed to be the default where I live.
Remove the swing? If you have the foresight to say that the swing is so dangerous, then why not the person who actually owns the thing?
I am aware that there's some risk involved in swings - don't walk in front of one when it's being used, don't use it when I'm drunk, don't do handstands on it, but I also know that using it normally is pretty safe.
Either the homeowner needs to see a huge disclaimer and accept liability when they place a property, or the consumer needs to see a huge disclaimer and accept liability when they rent a place, or AirBnB needs to assume responsibility and liability for both. You can't just leave it a grey area where it automatically defaults to the consumer being liable for everything, so that the homeowner and AirBnB can maximize profit while assuming zero risk.
Held to a different standard by whom? Definitely not by courts.
Maybe common sense isn't such a good guide, though.
It looks like a win because it's cheaper, but that's only true until something goes badly wrong.
Oversight and regulation aren't always a bad thing. Sometimes they prevent avoidable accidents.
Yes.
> It looks like a win because it's cheaper, but that's only true until something goes badly wrong.
It isn't a win in my opinion, for many reasons. It violates all kinds of social contracts.
> Oversight and regulation aren't always a bad thing.
Agreed.
> Sometimes they prevent avoidable accidents.
That's a tricky one. I suspect this particular tree-swing would have killed someone, it's a coincidence that it had to be an AirBNB guest so even if this particular person may not have died the accident itself would have probably happened anyway sooner or later. Which is sort of the root of my whole argument about this being a tragedy rather than an issue of liability.
Now, that doesn't mean you're wrong about what people usually think. It's just an argument that people are not being sensible about it.
This is theoretically true in all of life, so it's kind of a vacuous and IMHO not very useful point.
IE if someone doesn't stop when you have the right of way, it doesn't make you any less dead when they run you over.
Realize the reason the law exists is precisely to force the burden back onto homeowners, and that is in fact, the likely outcome.
This is not the brakes of your car services by some competent mechanic in which case I can easily see a liability issue but in the case of old stuff hanging from trees different rules apply.
For that matter, when visiting a friend who has two young children and a nice swing in their garden I spent the better part of a day re-inforcing the swing and its foundation because I thought the whole thing was an accident waiting to happen.
If you stay in someone else's apartment and it does not have a CO alarm and a stove that may or may not vent into the apartment then you should at a minimum sleep with a window open.
Tree-swings are not usually installed by licensed engineers, they are typically installed by people with a tree with a suitable profile, a rope and an old tire, any of which may fail at unpredictable times, but most likely when being used (and even more likely: when being used by an adult).
In this case I'm not sure how anyone could defend the homeowner or AirBnB when the house had a picture of the swing on the website. Granted AirBnB isn't filtering those pictures looking for potential problems (hrm, image recognition problem here that could be interesting) but the owner sure could have if he/she were trained or asked to do so. Right now they aren't -- it is just a "host your home for free and get people to give you money" without thinking about the consequences.
I can see why the homeowner might not have all the insurance or knowledged needed to make it a safe(r) place. That's why they are homeowners and not hotel or apartment owners -- they aren't that sophisticated. But is it right for AirBnB to profit off of that?
I agree with everything else you're saying, but as for the example of states' rights vs. city rights, - while this may appear to be inconsistent, it isn't necessarily. It appears to be a contradiction if you interpret states' rights to be an affirmation of delegation to smaller forms of government on pure principle, but that's not what it is.
Advocates of states' rights base their argument on the Constitution, which specifically affords states (and the people) all rights that aren't provided to the federal government[0]. States reserve this power because the federal government actually draws its power from the states, not the other way around[1].
This isn't an argument that generalizes to the sub-state level, because incorporated cities and towns draw their authority from the state, just as the federal government draws its power from the federation of states that form the union.
You may or may not agree with the extension of this argument to advocate for the various things that states' rights advocates promote, but I'm just pointing out that this isn't actually a paradox.
[0] The tenth amendment is the most notable example of this, but there are other parts of the constitution in which states are treated as having far more sovereignty than any other subdivision of government: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenth_Amendment_to_the_United_...
[1] Historically, this is obvious: the states had to ratify the Constitution before it ever even came into effect!
For all we know the owner of the swing tried it the day before but weighed 10 kg less than the guest and he/she never noticed a problem. For every tree-swing there is a point in its life where it will fail and a load that will cause it to fail right now.
Trees are natural items, not engineered, ridiculously strong, most of the times and unpredictable when it comes to failure modes. Even perfectly healthy trees can lose branches. Sometimes accidents are just that: accidents.
What could the owner have done to ensure that this did not happen? For all we know he tried the swing himself the day before and it was fine. At least at the time of making the advert it was still fine and short of 'destructive testing' to figure out how much load it supports there is no way to know what it will handle except for trying to see if it supports your weight.