News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by imron on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:28AM (#10559982)
From taxes, which although complex, are still well publicized and listed and it's easy to know how much you need to pay and when. You also (generally) pay these based on your income level.

That's completely different from have arbitrary amounts of cash confiscated from you at arbitrary times.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by ndespres on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:32AM (#10559998)
I think you're responding to an anti-government troll who is being deliberately obtuse about the difference between civil asset forfeiture vs tax collection. Unfortunately statements like theirs muddy the waters between something that most sane people find acceptable (government tax collection) vs something that most sane people find abhorrent once they know about it.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by entropyneur on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:38AM (#10560026)
> something that most sane people find abhorrent once they know about it

Does it mean the lawmakers and higher-ups in the executive branch are not sane people?

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by imron on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:17AM (#10560588)
No, it just means the priorities and incentives of their jobs are completely misaligned towards solving the problem.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by talmand on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:20AM (#10560264)
In many cases, no they are not.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by purespark2 on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:37AM (#10560024)
I think the question is legitimate. Why are sane people okay with having their property rights violated by taxation but not by confiscation?
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by hyperpape on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:19AM (#10560255)
Knock yourself out:

http://www.amazon.com/Anarchy-State-Utopia-Robert-Nozick/dp/...

http://www.amazon.com/A-Theory-Justice-John-Rawls/dp/0674000...

(Seriously, what kind of response are you expecting? There are so many assumptions built in to your question that you're basically asking for a summary of political philosophy).

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by joshuacc on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:02AM (#10560143)
> Why are sane people okay with having their property rights violated by taxation

Most people don't regard taxation as a violation of property rights.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by distances on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:37AM (#10560361)
"Property rights" aren't any natural rights. It's a societal agreement, and that agreement comes with strings attached. In your case you pay taxes, and your society holds everyone up to this bunch of collective agreements, including not taking away your property just willy-nilly (confiscation).
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by jnbiche on Friday November 13, 2015 @01:29PM (#10561429)
> In your case you pay taxes, and your society holds everyone up to this bunch of collective agreements, including not taking away your property just willy-nilly (confiscation).

Except that's...not happening, in one of the largest, and without doubt the most powerful, "democracies" in the world. Police do take away your property willy-nilly in the USA without trial.

Does this mean we get to stop paying taxes?

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by _ak on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:33AM (#10560340)
> Why are sane people okay with having their property rights violated by taxation but not by confiscation?

Because these people are not egotistical, anti-social assholes, but contribute their share to society instead.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by merpnderp on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:41AM (#10560391)
Taxation in a democracy is inherently legitimate. And the reasoning behind it is explained clearly in Rousseau's Social Contract, although the idea goes back centuries. Simply stated, if you decide to continue living in a society, then you implicitly agree to abide by its rules. In most countries, the agreement means paying taxes set by elected representatives.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by bmelton on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:27AM (#10560649)
Rousseau's social contract, while a fine piece of work, would almost certainly advocate a monarchy for a state the size of America. Its use here seems to be an appeal to authority, which seems odd as there are no mentions to it anywhere within our governing documents, upon which a less spurious legitimacy is bestowed.

Beyond that, categorizing anything as "inherently legitimate" is fraught with peril. One could perhaps surmise that all things are legitimate within a democracy, but so long as the favors of the majority come at the expense of the minority, that claim is disputable.

Beyond that, I don't really know that Rousseau's contract would invalidate a North Korean government as it exists, and North Korean citizenship precludes the option of defection.

The biggest flaw I see with the assertion that "if you want to live here, you agree to pay taxes" is that there's no opt-out policy in America as it is. If you object to the taxation, and wish to opt out, your only path is expatriation, with its associated expatriation taxes.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by merpnderp on Friday November 13, 2015 @03:31PM (#10562220)
I'd say that the tautology of what the system agrees is legitimate is what is legitimate (no less useful than gravity pulls things together because it pulls things together). Laws promoting racism were broken in the US, and the law-breakers were quickly recognized as legitimate. Perhaps some types of tax dodgers might be considered legitimate. The beauty of a democracy is that if you can convince enough people that something should be legitimate/illegitimate, they can make it so.

And yes "inherently legitimate" was a poor phrase to choose.

And I believe many founders leaned heavily on Rousseau's work. Hamilton and Madison particularly in the Federalist Papers.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by bmelton on Friday November 13, 2015 @03:41PM (#10562272)
> I'd say that the tautology of what the system agrees is legitimate is what is legitimate

And which is inherently fallacious, even going against Rousseau. Slavery as an institution was systemically agreed upon by the institution. There is no inherent legitimacy in violating the liberties of others, and while I agree that any such comparison is flawed, agreeing on slavery as an institution is no more or less legitimate due to populist demand than the insistence of taking some people's money and giving it to others.

Are there benefits? Undoubtedly; but even something mathematically proven as "good" (as if we could do such a thing) is not necessarily legitimate, however well founded the idea or the intent. That said, this is all philosophical, to be sure, but since we're waxing, may as well get fully waxed. (Don't ask me what that means, cause I have no idea.)

> And I believe many founders leaned heavily on Rousseau's work

No argument there.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by geggam on Friday November 13, 2015 @12:37PM (#10561090)
The US is a Republic not a Democracy.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by the_why_of_y on Friday November 13, 2015 @02:11PM (#10561776)
The constitution says the US is both a Republic and a Democracy.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by geggam on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:59AM (#10582369)
Declaration of Independence and our constitution do not even mentioned the word "democracy".
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by the_why_of_y on Sunday November 22, 2015 @11:29AM (#10610511)
Let's see... neither the Constitution nor the Declaration of Independence explicitly use the word "republic" for the United States as a whole, so you should perhaps reconsider that argument.

Constitution, Article 1, Section 2, and Section 3, in their first paragraphs clearly define the legislative branch as a representative democracy.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by merpnderp on Friday November 13, 2015 @03:23PM (#10562181)
The US Republic is a type of Democracy, but does not have direct democracy in that representatives are elected to represent the public.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by vacri on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:38AM (#10560713)
"property rights" is an abstract concept that doesn't exist without government in the first place.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by logfromblammo on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:49AM (#10560433)
Indeed. Logical consistency would dictate that you should either be for both or against both, but not for one and against the other.

But humans are notorious for allowing emotional concerns, religious beliefs, and simple self-interest override logic.

Maybe they just don't like the reverse-lottery aspect of funding the government. Rather than a lucky person getting a windfall from the government, an unlucky person loses everything to it. You can avoid the lottery by not buying tickets, but the only way to avoid the anti-lottery is by not having anything to steal. For most people, that would be a pretty miserable existence.

People want to believe that their government exists to serve their interests. They may be more upset that the government is spoiling the illusion of fairness--that the government is doing all this publicly--than the fact that the government is doing it at all. Because as bad as they might have it now, if there is a rebellion, the new boss might, in fact, be worse than the old boss.

Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by entropyneur on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:35AM (#10560012)
Would you be therefore fine with it if a local police department decided it's underfunded and went confiscating money in the neighborhood according to a pre-published plan and taking into account one's income level?
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by bluedino on Friday November 13, 2015 @09:36AM (#10560015)
You also get to vote on increasing/decreasing police funding.
Re:Stop-And-Seize Turns Police into Self-Funding Gangs by logfromblammo on Friday November 13, 2015 @11:00AM (#10560485)
Though you should bear in mind that if you do vote to decrease police funding, they may respond by increasing forfeitures and enforcement of revenue-generating ordinances.

So now, instead of being able to drive 60 mph in a 55 mph zone without being molested, they swap out the signs for 45 mph, you get pulled over for driving 46 mph, the officer "smells marijuana" when you open your window, and you lose your car. You get the ticket thrown out because the limit was still 55, despite the change of signage, but the judge rules that the cops still have reasonable cause to stop you, search your car, and seize it, because you were still driving faster than what the signs said.

Of course, the same could happen if you vote to increase funding.

The police are servants of the legislature, not the citizenry. You can't fire or demote someone who doesn't work for you.