Re:Ask HN: Are HN comments automatically downvoted by algori...
by dang on Friday November 13, 2015 @06:16AM
(#10559194)
That comment was killed by a spam filter. Those generate false positives sometimes. We've fixed that and also unkilled the comment.
In the future, please do what the HN guidelines ask and email such questions to us at [email protected]. I only saw this thread by accident.
Re:Ask HN: Are HN comments automatically downvoted by algori...
by lgieron on Friday November 13, 2015 @06:49AM
(#10559304)
I'm sure you can see that the post linking to the (simplifying) anti-YC blog being accidentally killed by spam filter can raise questions about whether it was really an accident. I'm not saying it was not - I'm just saying the bayesian probability of this being an accident doesn't look that great to me.
Re:Ask HN: Are HN comments automatically downvoted by algori...
by SamReidHughes on Friday November 13, 2015 @10:05PM
(#10564234)
Imagine making a scoring system for domains that that takes into account flags and votes on comments that include said domain. Also, your post had a word written in ALL CAPS, arguably two. You can see other comments linking to the same domain at around the same time [1] that aren't marked as spam.
I'd love to hear a non-malicious explanation for that.