News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Writing English as a Second Language by dkarl on Friday January 15, 2010 @03:53PM (#1055866)
I share his stylistic preferences, but Zinsser is a prick. (How's that for simple and forceful?) He's a prick suffering from a bad case of déformation professionnelle. (Ha! That isn't even English!) To further express my disdain for his advice, I have made my response extremely long.

Consider his first example:

“Dear member: The board of governors has spent the past year considering proactive efforts that will continue to professionalize the club and to introduce efficiencies that we will be implementing throughout 2009.” That means they’re going to try to make the club run better.

His translation is incomplete. "Better" isn't a synonym for "more professionally and efficiently." "Better" could mean all kinds of things. Perhaps it would be plainer to say they're trying to cut down on waste and sloppiness, but that may not be accurate either. Waste and sloppiness are relative to a person's awareness and capabilities. Perhaps raising their their awareness and capabilities to the point where they recognized waste and sloppiness in their operation was part of the process. That would be rather complicated to explain, but if they refer to "waste and sloppiness" then the reader is likely to get the impression that the waste and sloppiness have long been evident.

He also didn't communicate the time frame: they've spent a year discussing what to do, and now they're going to spend a year (or whatever remains of 2009) doing it. Whatever. He doesn't care. Their version communicates that they've done a lot of careful work to plan the improvements; he prefers a version that implies they don't know what they're doing. How easy it is to be concise when you want your readers to lose confidence in you.

Could he really write what they wanted to say more concisely? Probably so. There are some obvious improvements to make. But he refuses to try or even to offer any useful advice, because he doesn't give a shit about what they wanted to say, or what they were trying to accomplish by sending the letter. He has contempt for the task they are faced with. Contempt for what they do and what they're trying to say.

It's the same story with the next example:

“As I walk around the Academy,” she writes, “and see so many gifted students interacting with accomplished, dedicated adults” [that means boys and girls talking to teachers] and consider the opportunities for learning that such interpersonal exchanges will yield…” Interpersonal exchanges! Pure garbage. Her letter is meant to assure us alumni that the school is in good hands. I’m not assured.

She conjures an image and interprets the image. He would strip out the interpretation and leave only the concrete image of students talking to teachers. Why? Her interpretation is a sentimental, idealistic sales pitch. "Pure garbage." Well, yes, but it's her job to provide a sentimental and idealistic sales pitch. He has contempt for her writing because he has contempt for her job.

Perhaps he could do a better job in these situations, but he obviously isn't interested. In neither case does he suggest a useful alternative. Instead, he suggests they should use language that is utterly inadequate for their purpose, and then presumably start looking for a less distasteful profession.

The words derived from Latin are the enemy—they will strangle and suffocate everything you write.... Those nouns express a vague concept or an abstract idea, not a specific action that we can picture—somebody doing something.

Pity anyone who needs to communicate concepts and abstract ideas and who isn't free to use fiction or anecdote to do so. Clearly their writing skills are inferior to such people as

Joan Didion, who grew up in California and wrote brilliant magazine pieces about its trashy lifestyle in the 1960s. No anthropologist caught it better.

Should we really declare one approach to a subject "better" because it results in punchier prose? I enjoy simple, readable writing as much as anybody, and outside my own field I read it almost exclusively, but I wouldn't want to live in a world where all the anthropologists, economists, historians, doctors, lawyers, and bureaucrats gave up words such as communication, conversion, reconciliation, enhancement, and verification. I'd hate to read a shareholder report written in concrete images. (Perhaps each segment of a pie chart would be labeled with a vivid, engaging anecdote?)

All those nasty Latin words have "infected" our language because they're useful. "Approximation" cannot be used interchangeably with the nice, robust Anglo-Saxon "guess." (Or "stab" -- so much more vivid!) "Communicate" cannot be used interchangeably with "say," since often what is communicated is exactly the opposite of what is said.

You’ll be interviewing the men and women who are trying to solve those problems—school principals, social workers, health-care workers, hospital officials, criminal justice officials, union officials, church officials, police officers, judges, clerks in city and state agencies—and when you ask them a question, they will answer you in nouns: Latin noun clusters that are the working vocabulary of their field. They’ll talk about “facilitation intervention” and “affordable housing” and “minimum-density zoning,” and you will dutifully copy those phrases down and write a sentence that says: “A major immigrant concern is the affordable housing situation.” But I can’t picture the affordable housing situation. Who exactly are those immigrants? Where do they live? What kind of housing is affordable? To whom? As readers, we want to be able to picture specific people like ourselves, in a specific part of the city, doing things we might also do. We want a sentence that says something like “New Dominican families on Tremont Avenue in the Bronx can’t pay the rent that landlords ask.” I can picture that; we’ve all had trouble paying the landlord.

Now he's just being lazy. He laments that people talk using "the working vocabulary of their field." Why shouldn't they? It's his job as a writer to produce the working vocabulary of his field, which is punchy writing that keeps readers engaged. Doesn't he realize how frustrated other people must be with his insistence on dealing in nothing but vivid concrete images, not to mention his disdain for people who, because they face different tasks, must resort to different tools? Does he realize how frustrating it must be to talk to a writer who claims to be interested in the affordable housing situation but has no interest in the concepts and legal tools being used to address it, because they don't fit his professional mindset?

And that's why I say he suffers from déformation professionnelle. He judges everyone's prose as if they wrote for the same reasons he does. He says he wants to help people write, but he really just wants to make people write to a certain standard, the standard appropriate to one particular kind of writing, regardless of why and for whom they actually write. If they try to adapt their style to their actual circumstances, they cannot expect any help from him, only contempt.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by lmkg on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:07PM (#1056009)
> His translation is incomplete. "Better" isn't a synonym for "more professionally and efficiently." "Better" could mean all kinds of things.

But really, "to professionalize... and to introduce efficiencies" could mean all kinds of things as well. The big long fluffy phrase is so generic and crammed with platitudes that it's only marginally more specific than "run better." There's a whole lot of phrasing there that doesn't say anything. While you can argue that the big words used have semantic content, their combination nevertheless manages not to tell me anything.

Look at some of the examples he gives of good writing. They're long and complicated, but they're saying something. Unlike the buzzword bingo game above, there isn't anything you can cut that wouldn't change the content. Simpler expression makes it easier to understand complicated content.

I don't entirely disagree with everything you wrote. For example, I agree that field-specific jargon is useful and even necessary for concise communication. However, I felt that one point needed a comment, because it misses the core of his point: the words may mean something on their own, but they still don't add any meaning to the sentence that wasn't there already, and that's why they ought not to be there in the first place.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by pvg on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:34PM (#1056073)
You are, in the winged words of Lrr, confused and infuriated. For one thing, this is a talk - not a detailed essay or a class. It's meant to be brief and engaging rather than a technical deconstruction of others writing. He isn't going to offer detailed alternatives or examples because he wants his audience to stay awake.

He has contempt for her writing because he has contempt for her job.

He never said such a thing. He does, rightfully, have contempt for her writing because it is bad. It is bad as writing and it is also bad as a 'sentimental, idealistic sales pitch'. Are you saying a sales pitch must be written badly?

Should we really declare one approach to a subject "better" because it results in punchier prose?

Not punchier, but better, more evocative, more accessible to a wide audience. The sort of prose a journalist should write and Zissner is, after all, speaking to future journalists. You insist on interpreting 'better' in a strangely literal, obtuse way - it's a fairly common little flourish (yes, English has them too) - and makes sense in the context. We say things like that -'the artist conveys the sense of grief/longing/joy/whatever better than any neurobiologist/psychologist/etc' all the time. It obviously doesn't mean poetry can replace the sciences.

Now he's just being lazy. He laments that people talk using "the working vocabulary of their field." Why shouldn't they? It's his job as a writer to produce the working vocabulary of his field

He's being lazy? How is he being lazy? He's telling his students that they will encounter this kind of speech and it is, indeed, their job to translate it to something better.

His whole talk is very much patterned after the stylistic advice given by Orwell in Politics and the English Language. Read it if you haven't. You might find Orwell a bit of a prick too. Or at least prickly. He's also right.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by petewarden on Friday January 15, 2010 @04:52PM (#1055974)
> He judges everyone's prose as if they wrote for the same reasons he does

I don't entirely disagree, but the examples he uses fail in their own terms. They don't do the job the writers want them to do.

It's technically true that the timeframes are missing from the club-owners letter, but 'in the past year' is irrelevant to the audience. Do you really think it's exactly twelve months since they started 'considering'? Why should any recipient care?

You're correct that the phrase is there because the writers want to persuade the reader that they've been hard at work on their behalf. It's just such a lazy cliche that it doesn't succeed! How about "Bob, Sue and Mike spent the last three days interviewing staff about how to improve the way we run things." It's far more concrete, and so much more convincing. It's also part of a story, which is a great way to keep people reading.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by GeoffWozniak on Friday January 15, 2010 @04:14PM (#1055896)
The article says that this was a talk so perhaps it should be considered as a mild form of entertainment. I've read "On Writing Well" and (as I recall) it's considerably less abrasive than this article.

This talk was, to me, an entertaining rant to get a point across, not a serious critique of others' writing.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by godDLL on Saturday January 16, 2010 @06:24AM (#1056799)
The russian language has a special term set aside for this kind of round-about linguistic constructionism – "fish language". It's like the English "legalese", but with no relation to lawyers specifically.

The idea is that a fishes mouth opens and closes all the time, but all that comes out is air-bubbles.

I'm with master George Carlin on this one, "simple, direct language" is appropriate everywhere there isn't a justified need for domain-specific terminology to be used.

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by vlisivka on Saturday January 16, 2010 @07:40AM (#1056854)
> The russian language has a special term set aside for this kind of round-about linguistic constructionism – "fish language". It's like the English "legalese", but with no relation to lawyers specifically.

You talking about "Канцелярит" (kantceliaryt?). "Канцелярия" means "office". Suffix "ит" here means language or disease. So "канцелярит" means "official language/disease". See http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%86%D0%B5%... http://zhivoeslovo.ru/content/view/85/143/

"Fish" (рыба) - is template or form: you need just to fill gaps between prewritten sentences. It looks like "fish bones".

Re:Writing English as a Second Language by godDLL on Monday January 18, 2010 @06:50PM (#1061096)
Нет, я про "рыбий язык". "Канцелярит" мне что-то из иврита уже навевает, наверное, все же.

(No.)