News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by cnvogel on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:19AM (#10552267)
More specifically, THIS voltmeter, which is a little bit "under-spec'ed", to say the least: Radio Shack (22-223) https://www.google.de/search?q=radio-shack+22-223&tbm=isch It's set to the 10V-AC range. I'd expect a VC backed company to invest in a little more elaborate measurement equipment than that.

On the other hand, given a a good RMS meter operated in a frequency range where it's spec'ed to work and a known circuit impedance will give you a very good measurement of the power: P=Vrms²/R. And analog meters make for rather pretty demos, to be honest.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:39AM (#10552349)
Actually, that makes it more believable, not less. Let me explain why: A voltmeter can't just measure volts, it has to make a tiny current flow through a resistor. The value of that resistor will be lower for cheaper volt meters because the cheaper volt meters need more energy extracted from the circuit under test to function. A more expensive one has a very high internal resistance, and so loads the circuit under test far less.

In this case being able to supply 8 volts into a meter with a low internal resistance is actually a plus ;)

That said, the current is still tiny, even a crappy volt meter will pull no more than a few hundred micro-amps from the circuit that it is measuring. So let's be generous and say that it pulls a whopping 10 mA (very likely on the high side (edit: it turned out to be 37 uA)), in that case the power generated would be 0.08 W. Not enough to charge your phone by a long shot, but enough for a pretty demo with a moving needle.

Finally, these cheap meters tend to output complete nonsense values when presented with high frequency AC, one would expect that they would at a minimum measure power transfered using a dummy load and some kind of dedicated power meter.

All in all this does not make things look any better for uBeam. I'd really like to know who did their technical due diligence.

What's really bad to me - but I'm a nitpicker - is that in the video the lady refers to the volt meter as a power meter, which it definitely is not. It measures potential, not power, any power that it takes from the circuit can be chalked up to imperfect design and the laws of physics. Maybe the person doing the demo was not knowledgeable about the physics behind the equipment but that's betraying a complete mis-understanding of the basic concepts involved.

The transducers used appear to be of the piezo-electric type, those have a fairly high internal resistance and the voltages produced by those devices would be relatively high, the currents correspondingly tiny.

What gets me about this whole saga is that uBeam makes it seem as if they invented wireless power transfer using ultra-sonics, but any sound is wireless power transfer and that includes ultra-sound. The whole crux is how much power can be generated and whether or not there is a practical way to overcome all the obstacles.

To transfer some power doesn't prove a thing, when I whisper in your ear I'm transferring power using soundwaves...

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by cnvogel on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:43AM (#10552563)
As I had remarked, a good RMS meter on a known impedance, on a frequency it's spec'ed for. The setup shown is neither.

Also: For low-level AC measurements you invariably need active rectification. So your meter will never be directly connected (or through a series resistor) to the source.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:44AM (#10552566)
Agreed.

The guts of that meter register 37uA for full scale (I found some specs), at 10V that's an internal resistance of 270K so probably it really is driving the meter directly.

For 8 V that translates into 0.25 mW of power produced, which I don't think will be charging any cell-phones.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by raverbashing on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:31AM (#10552980)
Even the cheapest digital voltmeters have 1MOhm input impedance

The one the parent mentioned has 10kOhm/Volt sensitivity, so for 10V range it gives 100kOhms

http://support.radioshack.com/support_meters/doc73/73794.pdf

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:37AM (#10553014)
Yes, but even cheap digital voltmeters (this one is analog) would not work well for high frequencies and does not measure power, a volt meter is simply the wrong tool for the job.
Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by raverbashing on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:45AM (#10553058)
> would not work well for high frequencies

Correct, but it is going to measure something (it most likely rectifies and sends it to the meter, should work fine in the 100khz range)

> a volt meter is simply the wrong tool for the job

I don't disagree with this

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:52AM (#10553089)
It very much depends on the guts of the meter what it will indicate. "Something" is not a very scientific measure :)

The biggest factor are the ways in which the sample is taken and what kind of algorithm (if any...) is used to determine RMS. Simple meters simply rectify the AC current, add a small capacitor and a resistor to drain it and measure the DC voltage across the resistor. More advanced meters will use an isolation stage with a pre-amp driven from the auto ranger that will present the wave-form in one piece and suitably scaled to a DA stage where the sampling will take place. This allows for pretty good determination of the actual voltage (which in the case of AC has been agreed upon as root-mean-square, whereas, if the circuitry is bunk could easily become 'peak' or even 'nonsense').

Anyway, we're all in violent agreement that this measurement is bogus and since that is all the quantitative info there is I'll let it go here.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by cnvogel on Thursday November 12, 2015 @09:43AM (#10553367)
No need to digitize. There are analog multiplier and squaring circuits.

http://www.analog.com/en/products/linear-products/rms-to-dc-...

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by hatsunearu on Thursday November 12, 2015 @09:27AM (#10553267)
A better "instrument" would have been LED(s). Real power, more blinky blinky.

You could even attach a ultra lower power microcontroller dev board to it[1] and show the less technical audience "look! computer powered by spooky magic!"

1: like this: https://www.silabs.com/products/mcu/lowpower/Pages/efm32gg-s... super low power microcontroller demo board that runs off of all sorts of energy harvesting rigs like tiny solar cells, thermoelectric piles, and so on.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by avian on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:11AM (#10552864)
> The transducers used appear to be of the piezo-electric type, those have a fairly high internal resistance and the voltages produced by those devices would be relatively high, the currents correspondingly tiny.

Exactly. These transducers look just like low-cost piezos used for ultrasonic ranging in air (e.g. car parking sensors, alarms, etc.). I have not seen any in that package that would be made for any significant amount of power. High power transducers look quite different.

Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by ykl on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:55AM (#10552393)
I could be wrong, but I think the demonstrator in the video is the CEO.
Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:02AM (#10552412)
In that case we might hope for an accidental slip or a deliberate simplification for the audience but she certainly should know better than to call that thing a power meter.
Re:Experts Still Think UBeam’s Through-The-Air Charging Tech... by saintgimp on Thursday November 12, 2015 @02:03PM (#10555340)
That's the point. It's likely that at the time, she honestly didn't know the difference (or didn't understand the difference well enough to realize that it would be obvious to other people). She did a Ted Talk where she bragged about how she didn't know anything about engineering when she started uBeam.