News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by jgrahamc on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:02AM (#10552214)
Some headline numbers: I've been on Hacker News for well over 5 years (I joined on July 2, 2007)

Ha! when I wrote that it was 5 years... now it's > 8 years. I think the same conclusion still applies: "So, to answer my original question about how I ended up with that much karma: slowly, consistently, over years by submitting things that people like."

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:17AM (#10552262)
HN Karma functions much like the odometer on a car.

Use the car more frequently and for longer distances and the odometer will advance more rapidly.

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by KineticLensman on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:00AM (#10552810)
Someone downstream said "A good trick is to post a solid counterpoint as a reply to the currently topmost comment: people are more likely to vote on comments near the top"

So I'm looking for a counterpoint except that this is actually quite a good analogy (ignoring the quibble that a good driver can move to a new car with a fresh odometer but retain a good driving record. Or that there is no legal odometer equivalent to being downvoted)

Edit: grammar

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by ksherlock on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:15AM (#10552894)
Counterpoint: The Cuckoo's Calling, by Robert Galbraith, sold 500 copies. The Cuckoo's Calling, by JK Rowling, sold a 100,000+ copies.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by joosters on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:40AM (#10552352)
Sooooo tempted to downvote you just to try and prove you wrong :)
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by DanBC on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:48AM (#10552376)
I suspect your single downvote would be have been countered by several people supplying corrective upvotes, so they could have ended up with more upvotes than they would have done without the initial downvote.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:09AM (#10552440)
Unless we all decide to take part in this prank :). Coordination isn't that hard, right? ;).
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by JupiterMoon on Thursday November 12, 2015 @07:07AM (#10552635)
That's called a voting ring and the mods with come down like a ton of soft fluffy teddy bears.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by jacquesm on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:11AM (#10552443)
Didn't you post a nice link about that recently?
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:14AM (#10552457)
I did. But isn't science about trying to prove yourself wrong? :).
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by lifeisstillgood on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:13AM (#10552879)
What strikes me is I hardly ever submit. I mostly comment (outside the tent pissing in). When I do submit I often get surprisingly nice amounts of karma. I just rarely discover something not already been submitted.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by solaris999 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:16AM (#10552259)
Nothing groundbreaking, but good analysis rarely is.

I'd be interested to see the relationship between comment karma and age of post though - do earlier comments always get more attention?

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by steveklabnik on Thursday November 12, 2015 @09:17AM (#10553213)
I distinctly remember saying "I'm not going to post any more when I hit 2000 karma." Then it was 3000.

I even set noprocrast to something like 100 years, and quit cold turkey for a while... And then got pg to reset it for me.

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by coderdude on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:23AM (#10552283)
A hundred people are looking at this like "ok."

"How did I succeed? I just followed the rules."

First hand, everyone sees that as bullshit. I like your contributions to this community. Don't be ashamed to say, "cuz I'm awesome like that."

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by jgrahamc on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:27AM (#10552292)
You'd be amazed how powerful compound interest is.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by coderdude on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:07AM (#10552430)
You've got 10 times my karma. You win. :)
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by austenallred on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:40AM (#10552353)
Holy shit, 55,000 HN karma? And I thought I had a problem.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by jgrahamc on Thursday November 12, 2015 @05:41AM (#10552365)
Me? A problem? It's tptacek you should be worried about... he's got 226,754 karma.
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by baby on Thursday November 12, 2015 @07:45AM (#10552752)
I'm really wondering how you can reach such a number... Thomas?
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by patio11 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:53AM (#10553092)
I will take the liberty of answering for Thomas here.

Most importantly, write a lot of comments, over years. Karma is primarily an odometer. I get 2X the karma per comment, but Thomas writes 4X the comments.

Develop a beat on which you are known as a source of expert, reliable knowledge. There are other security people on HN, but Thomas is fairly reliably stapled to the top of any thread about security. That is not not justified.

Write well. Have a voice. You can pick out most of Thomas' comments, and virtually all of his value-adding comments, immediately by his writing style. He's one of the five best writers on the site, without question. (Honest opinion rather than playing praise-my-friend-and-cofounder. It's not a close call.) You could ask him "Thomas, I am going to name one item in your kitchen. Write about it for two minutes. Ready? Parsnip, go." and it would be one of the ~10 best written comments on HN that day.

There exists an observation I can make here about choosing which threads to participate in, which would have the effect of increasing one's karma but which is not necessarily something HN wants to encourage. I have 100% confidence that "Boosting my karma score" is not the reason why Thomas chooses threads to engage in, but be that as it may, I'll add it for completeness: the high-heat low-light threads about nerd politics result in getting lots of upvotes for fairly little effort, regardless of whether you conform with HN's community norms or whether you are the designated contrary voice. (Designated contrary voice is worth a lot of upvotes if you do it well.)

Not related, but worth mentioning in case it isn't obvious: he really, really doesn't care about his karma score. Profoundly does not care. It happens to reward him for being "message board nerd" (his favored phrasing for this psychograph) but Thomas would play message board nerd for free and, indeed, at substantial cost.

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by tptacek on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:25PM (#10554546)
The leaderboard stopped showing karma scores because I asked PG and then 'dang to do that. I'd be much happier if they eliminated accumulated karma altogether --- keep karma, keep showing comment karma to authors, but don't show accumulated karma to anyone.

I've made a bunch of friends from HN, but among my real-world friends, the HN karma thing is an embarrassment; I'm needled over it constantly.

The most under-appreciated writer on HN is 'tzs, for what it's worth.

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by dennisgorelik on Thursday November 12, 2015 @08:34PM (#10557475)
I do not agree with your recommendation to hide score information. Especially individual comments score.

Individual comments score helps me to decide what comment to pay more attention to.

Of course they system could be improved by counting comment wait based on my past preferences.

(E.g. if my upvotes correlate with patio11 upvotes, then patio11 upvote is more valuable to me than average user's upvotes).

But even without upvote score calcualtion improvement - it is better to have existing "averaged" score, than no score at all.

Finally, if vanity is not your thing - just do not pay attention to your own score. Upvotes score information is valuable for other reasons.

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by austenallred on Thursday November 12, 2015 @06:13AM (#10552450)
He's in his own league
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by z3t4 on Thursday November 12, 2015 @03:56PM (#10556045)
> consistency over a long period

That's the secret to all success!

Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by atrust on Thursday November 12, 2015 @11:58AM (#10554342)
what is your most upvoted comment?
Re:How I ended up with so much Hacker News karma (2012) by DanBC on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:56PM (#10554803)