News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by Animats on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:14PM (#10550092)
Another useless article about "consciousness".

"We share a conviction that no philosopher or scientist living today has the foggiest notion of how consciousness, and its inseparable companion free will, emerge, as they surely do, from a material brain."

That's reasonable enough. Nobody seems to have a clue about how "consciousness", whatever it is, really works. If someone did, it would have been implemented in a computer by now.

"We mysterians are persuaded that no computer of the sort we know how to build—that is, one made with wires and switches—will ever cross a threshold to become aware of what it is doing."

Nah. Now he's just mouthing off. There's a long history of this sort of thing from philosophers. Aristotle claimed humans were special because they could do arithmetic. Now we know that arithmetic is simple, in the sense that it takes a very small parts count. Hubert Dreyfus, in 1972, said computers couldn't play even a decent amateur game of chess. Now, any laptop PC can trounce grand masters.

What AI isn't doing well yet is predicting the consequences of actions: "what will happen next", and "what will happen next if this decision is made". Basically, the technology to get through the next 15 seconds of life. This is the beginning of common sense, and really ought to be worked on more. We have the tools now to go at that problem. Self-driving cars have to do some of this, and answers may come out of that technology. This is an essential technology for robots which operate in an unstructured world.

Once that problem has been solved, we might be in a position to talk about "consciousness" from a non-clueless perspective. Higher level thinking is mostly a strategy module for the "next 15 seconds" control system.

At least the article doesn't use the world "quantum".

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by JackFr on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:48PM (#10550282)
You didn't read it very closely:

>Penrose, for example, thinks the mystery may yield to a deeper understanding of quantum mechanics.

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by Animats on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:00PM (#10550342)
Oh, crap; I missed that.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:33PM (#10550185)
> Nobody seems to have a clue about how "consciousness", whatever it is, really works.

OK.

> Higher level thinking is mostly a strategy module for the "next 15 seconds" control system.

I'm not convinced we have even that much of a clue about consciousness.

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by auvrw on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:25PM (#10550692)
> What AI isn't doing well yet

isn't this guy's bias. he's, in part, interested in how the AI works, because he's interested in understanding how people think.

i'm also totally sick of the buzzword.

to reveal my bias, here's another thing AI doesn't do but we do all the time: have feelings.

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by dkarapetyan on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @06:19PM (#10550120)
Higher level thinking is model building from sensory input. I have not seen any system out there that learns to reason about 3D space by just going around touching/feeling things and then incorporating that feedback with other senses. Everything starts with a model built-in and then tweaks parameters through some kind of optimization mechanism. Which is fine but that's not really intelligence in the sense of coming up with novel models and incorporating it into pre-existing models.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by vectorjohn on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:46PM (#10550532)
Absolutely not. You can, in your house, build a robot that uses sensory input to construct a map of its surroundings and then navigate that map.

Check out various algorithms to do so, such as [1]. Model building from sensory input is very simple, and in my opinion only tangentially related to consciousness.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D*

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by dkarapetyan on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:00PM (#10550592)
Oh ok. In that case ya we got all this figured out. I mean there is D*. Thanks for clearing up all the confusion. /sarcasm
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by vectorjohn on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:09PM (#10550631)
Well, your whole argument is that we couldn't do it, while plainly we can. So, answer with /sarcasm all you want, but it isn't a good argument.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:09PM (#10550633)
Humans don't really do that either.

For humans, the model is bound externally in parental memory, media influences, and impersonal record systems.

But it's very much there as external programming. Baby humans don't very well when it's missing.

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by wyager on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:01PM (#10550600)
> model building from sensory input

This is one of the basic activities AI researchers have been solving for years.

In many cases, this is not even a hard problem.

Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:39PM (#10550500)
Are you trying to express the difference between supervised and unsupervised learning?
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by dkarapetyan on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @08:05PM (#10550614)
I'm expressing the difference from going from 2D Euclidean geometry to 3D Euclidean geometry to Non-Euclidean geometries as in the development of all of those models and theories throughout the history of mathematics. That's what I mean by model building. There currently is no such artificial system that can go through the process of developing and evolving such models and systems. So reasoning/thinking/consciousness or whatever people want to call it must account for such model building. All current research is basically just tweaking something until it fits good enough in a very limited domain. There is no explanatory power in any of the current research.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:37PM (#10551152)
Eh, before saying that, go ahead and read some recent research. http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~rgrosse/phd-thesis.pdf, for example.
Re:Do Loops Explain Consciousness? Review of 'I Am a Strange... by dkarapetyan on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @02:45PM (#10590204)
Nope, still comes with a theory of probability built in and can't generalize it.