The main argument for vapes is that hey don't produce tar, which is one of the worst parts of cigarettes.
Are they as bad a normal cigs? Probably not. Are they completely, 100% safe? No.
On the other, an application of the precautionary principle that may well be just as applicable to the acrylamide on french fries.
How does this make sense as a vector for backlash?
I can say the same thing about those having backyard firepits [1] whose output affects FAR more people than a single (e)cigarette. To my knowledge no one is campaigning against big campfire though.
Edit:
> These users often say "it's only water vapor", which is absurdly false.
Yes, but does second-hand e-cigarette smoke cause significant harm? For example second-hand cigarette smoke increases the chance of lung cancer by 20% when living with a smoker [2]. Contrast that with inhaling a puff of e-cigarette second-hand-smoke in a public place once in a while.
I understand that you may find e-cigarette smoke annoying but that's not a sufficient reason to ban something in a free society.
[1] http://www.ehhi.org/woodsmoke/health_effects.shtml
[2] http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/reports/secondhandsmok...
You don't get the right to harm other people's health (even in a "free society"), even if there are already other unhealthy things present.
What about the effects of pollution emitted when you drive a car?
You are making really good arguments for banning/regulating other harmful things - You are not making good arguments for allowing a known harmful thing to continue unregulated.
AlexandrB was dismissing one argument because he found a bigger issue.
In contrast, everyone in society benefits from the mobility and economic activity facilitated by transportation. Even if you never drive a car, take a bus, or even leave your house, you are better off because of cars, busses, trains, and airplanes because of the increased economic growth they facilitate. The benefit and the harm are both fully socialized.
You must not be from the bay area. Lookup "Spare the Air".
Of course it is! We ban a lot of things that are annoying. We have noise ordinances and various other public nuisance laws, as do all other free societies.
Also there is debate in the community about respect. I have more friends that step out for a vape, just like they would for cig, so they don't bother non smokers, than puff away like its nothing. But that's purely anecdotal.
To use an analogy: Lots of people on public transportation annoy me by playing music out of their phone's speaker. At no point do I think, "Phones should be banned." I just ask them to turn off their music or use headphones.
On the other hand, acrylamide is a single, testable molecule. Taking a mix of chemicals, heating them up to high temperatures, enough to evaporate them, and hoping that they don't break down into anything dangerous is much harder to test. Arbitrary organic compounds can decompose before water boils, or they can sustain high heats. Its really a case by case basis. And the solution for vapes may be similar, but the flavoring solutes vary.
Some of the backlash is of course the smell, from people insisting on using them indoors or generally in close quarters.
What chemicals are in the liquid is mysterious and vaguely unregulated so who knows. Its not as regulated as food and drink or pharmaceuticals. Its not unrealistic to assume its just different cancer causing materials, not no cancer causing materials at all. Its basically at the patent medicine level of regulation.
Mostly everybody distrusts the companies involved. I suspect there is also some PR by tobacco since these liquids don't require the tobacco industrial complex.
E-cigarettes do seem to be "better" for you than standard cigarettes.
However, you probably still don't want adolescents using them. We have mounting evidence that habitual use of nicotine, alcohol, marijuana, etc. all have negative effects on a developing brain that they don't have later on an adult.
In addition, I really don't want to be breathing a miasma of stuff somebody exhales.
However, I'm still torn on bans. Cigarette bans seem to kill local music scenes--which I like very much. I don't know if the ban is the cause, though--it could just be that bans only follow an influx of boring, rich people who displace the artists.
I think that a lot of the heavy-handed anti-smoking measures are based on neo-puritanism about "toxins" and bodily purity and not on actual health facts. Otherwise you would see a lot more people talking about exposure to camp fire smoke [1].
Tobacco companies are absolutely evil and should have been sued out of existence for lying to the public. But after years of advocacy and anti-smoking campaigns nearly everyone is aware of the risks and some are continuing to smoke anyways. Bans will just create a new black market for tobacco products.
In terms of individual, probably.
However, the smoking bans were "nominally" put in place to protect the people working in places like bars, restaurants, etc.
It was something that "the market" was never going to correct. People who smoke are simply WAY more profitable to restaurants and bars.
And, in flu season, I tend to cut back on group gatherings as much as possible because, exactly, they ARE exhaling toxic junk.
It's not a good reason to make it illegal, as I think harm should be proven before making something illegal, but I like that people are exercising some skepticism and concern over the unknown unknowns for a new technology, especially one that involves smoking.
In the short term it appears fairly hard to get killed by glycerin. Long term it doesn't sound very good at all. In that way, it reminds me of benzene or PCBs where in the short term theres zero risk if you can avoid drowning, but the long term effects are pretty awful.
Its definitely not as safe as water. Of course the "real" problem is likely whatever else is in the fluid. Who knows whats in there.
Second-hand smoke is generally accepted as a bad thing, as is wood smoke, unsurprisingly. I've seen suggestions that wood smoke may be even worse simply on the merit that a great volume of nasty compounds are released, and the particulate material is substantially smaller (due to the higher combustion temperatures) and can enter more deeply into the lungs[3]. If it's a choice between cigarettes and someone sucking down glycerin vapors, I think I'd be much happier to accept the latter.
[1] http://www.sciencelab.com/msds.php?msdsId=9927350
Plus I hear it has dihydrogen monoxide in it which can kill you in numerous ways.
There's a famous study from '97 in direct opposition based on nicotine gums and patches and I quote:
"Clinical trials of NRT in patients with underlying, stable coronary disease suggest that nicotine does not increase cardiovascular risk"
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9180099
On the other hand there's something in e-cig fluid aside from nicotine that seems to be a cancer risk
"E-cigarette vapor, both with and without nicotine, is cytotoxic to epithelial cell lines and is a DNA strand break-inducing agent. Further assessment of the potential carcinogenic effects of e-cigarette vapor is urgently needed."
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26547127
To some extent its like arguing with people about a paleo diet. Twinkies may or may not be good or bad for you, none the less removing twinkies from your diet totally utterly freaks some people out. Likewise it seems highly likely that not using ecigs will have no negative health effects, but people will freak out if you suggest not vapeing.
In terms of recreational activities, its probably not as bad as numerous activities like being exposed to fumes from drying paint, stripping and refinishing of furniture, etc. On the other hand its likely far more dangerous than watching TV or reading HN articles.
If this were a nicotine patch, it wouldn't be such an issue.
[1] http://www.medicaldaily.com/secondhand-smoke-goes-electronic...
[2] http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/281762.php
[3] http://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/news/20140903/e-cigar...
The thread is right there for everyone to see. Someone said nicotine has CVD impact. I said, so does caffeine. You responded that e-cigs impact bystanders. Well, they don't impact bystanders with CVD impact from nicotine, which is what the thread's about.
You then say, "they do", and provide 3 links, none of which support that argument with evidence. I point that out. You then flee to the abstraction of whether e-cigs are "safe".
The thread began with someone making a claim that nicotine usage is linked to CVD. You brought up that so is caffeine (which is a distraction from the core argument). To which I countered with the glaring difference between nicotine and caffeine consumption. You then attempted to make an argument that e-cigs somehow don't effect bystanders (nicotine et al), which is absurd as shown in the links provided.
> Please don't call me names.
I admit, that was a little too far. I meant to say your single sentence arguments are deliberately obtuse and misleading.
Here is how my thinking goes: 1) nicotine is essentially another caffeine and not a public health risk, 2) the cancer from smoking is from the literal act of burning things, which emits cancerous material and then by inhalation deposits it in your lungs and finally, 3) e-cigarettes don't emit the same cancerous materials since they only vaporize a nicotine-liquid, and are hence safe.
I feel like I can make the conclusion in 3) with just basic understanding of why cigarettes are bad (and e-cigarettes safe), yet it seems no one in the press is prepared to make the small logical leap. Am I overestimating my knowledge here?