News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by baldfat on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:56AM (#10547247)
I immediately thought of a quote from the movie Amadaus (About Mozart)

EMPEROR: Of course I do. It's very good. Of course now and then - just now and then - it gets a touch elaborate.

MOZART: What do you mean, Sire?

EMPEROR: Well, I mean occasionally it seems to have, how shall one say? [he stops in difficulty; turning to Orsini-Rosenberg] How shall one say, Director?

ORSINI-ROSENBERG: Too many notes, Your Majesty?

EMPEROR: Exactly. Very well put. Too many notes.

MOZART: I don't understand. There are just as many notes, Majesty, as are required. Neither more nor less.

EMPEROR: My dear fellow, there are in fact only so many notes the ear can hear in the course of an evening. I think I'm right in saying that, aren't I, Court Composer?

SALIERI: Yes! yes! er, on the whole, yes, Majesty.

MOZART: But this is absurd!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCud8H7z7vU

This certainly is an interesting area to explorer musically. Want can we do with a piano if we had more than ten notes to play at a time. Right now it is HOW many can we play and still sound musical from the samples I saw.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by idlewords on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:44AM (#10547173)
There's another nice Mozart connection to unplayable music in the story of the bet between Mozart and Haydn, where the former bet the latter he could write a piece of music Haydn't couldn't play. It required striking a single note in the middle of the keyboard when the hands were very far apart.

Haydn tried it and failed. Mozart struck the key with his nose.

http://byronreese.com/mozart-haydn/

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by Intermernet on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @07:50AM (#10546383)
Followed by the brilliant:

EMPEROR: My dear, young man, don't take it too hard. Your work is ingenious. It's quality work. And there are simply too many notes, that's all. Cut a few and it will be perfect.

MOZART: Which few did you have in mind, Majesty?

I always loved that exchange!

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by baldfat on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:55AM (#10547244)
I was so sad to read the history of Mozart and that most of the movie was just factually wrong. I still love the movie though.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by fossuser on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:09AM (#10547321)
Yeah - the ones I've heard that actually don't sound like a cacophony of notes usually don't optimize on note count.

Circus Galop: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DekTSh1QmvY

Death Waltz: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tds0qoxWVss

Both get a little carried away, but the main melody is clear and pretty interesting.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:25AM (#10547418)
Well, they both sound like someone just combined the lead/solo and rhythm/background section into one piece played on one instrument, which is neat, but not some mindblowing display of the limitations of current music theory and instrumentation.

I imagine our hard limit is human attention. We can focus on the lead and to a lesser extent listen to the background stuff but probably not listen to much more. I don't think we can really focus on some large complexity. That just ends up sounding like a discordant cacophony to us. If anything, we're made to enjoy fairly simple musical relationships. Chords can only get so complex before they sound off to us.

It seems to be a happy little coincidence that ten fingers is enough to make complex music without hitting too many practical limits. Just because that limit exist doesn't mean its wrong and that we need to overcome it. The same way a third leg won't let us run faster, fight better, or climb better.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by david-given on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:41PM (#10549119)
It's interesting to compare that version with this one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMHNrRaQB4Q

Audio's not good, alas, but it's actually being played by a human. It sounds like it's got all the complexity of the machine-played one, which of course it doesn't --- which does suggest that the extra complexity wasn't adding anything in the first place...

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by duskwuff on Thursday November 12, 2015 @12:32AM (#10551470)
That's a piano cover of "U. N. Owen Was Her?", which is the musical piece (from one of the Touhou video games!) which inspired "Death Waltz".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by fossuser on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:50PM (#10549174)
Somewhat unrelated, but I was pretty impressed by Hiromi Uehara: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-HcKrd3K8_A&list=RD-HcKrd3K8...
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by silverhydra on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:14PM (#10548968)
Rather than sounding like it, that's actually what they are. I'm inclined to agree with the rest of your post, although there's certainly room for people to expand their knowledge. Death Waltz is an interesting exercise but definitely overplays its hand in a few parts and adds too much to the song, when Zun's compositions already err on the side of doing too much to begin with.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by lispit on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:54PM (#10548838)
>Both get a little carried away, but the main melody is clear and pretty interesting.

In case it wasn't clear, "Death Waltz" is just a cover of "U.N. Owen Was Her?" from the Touhou games (as are many of the more popular black MIDI songs from what I've seen).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyC5eWJhCr8&list=PL_I1U99bY0...

Circus Galop was cool, though. That's the first original black MIDI piece I've enjoyed so far.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by tkrajcar on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @05:16PM (#10549746)
Circus Galop was actually originally written for player pianos, not "in" MIDI, but with a surprisingly similar goal in mind to black MIDI. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circus_Galop
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by joeyspn on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:41PM (#10547870)
It has been proved that the subconscious finds more pleasurable musical simplicity or pieces that despite having many notes can be reduced to simple patterns:

There is a long held theory that the subconscious mind can recognise patterns within complex data and that we are hardwired to find simple patterns pleasurable. Dr Nicholas Hudson used 'lossless' music compression programs to mimic the brain's ability to condense audio information. He compared the amount of compressibility of random noise to a wide range of music including classical, techno, rock, and pop, and found that, while random noise could only be compressed to 86% of its original file size, and techno, rock, and pop to about 60%, the apparently complex Beethoven's 3rd Symphony compressed to 40%.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/01/110120073507.ht...

Music is very complex, you need to master harmony to make many notes sound as a whole and interconnected piece. That's the secret:

Less is more. "More notes" is not necessarily better.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by gluelogic on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:57PM (#10548006)
Where has your first claim been proven?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by hebdo on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:51PM (#10548820)
Random noise cannot be (on average) loselessly compressed, not even by 0.0000001% of the original size. To see that it is the case it is sufficient to notice that a compression algorithm is essentially a way to reorder all possible inputs, all at once, and then apply the pigeonhole principle. Kind of similar to the proof that if a loseless compression algorithm shortens at least one input, it must also extend at least one.

Claiming that there exists an algorithm that loselessly compresses random noise to 86% of the original size is just wrong.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by dspig on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @04:07PM (#10549280)
It could have been pink noise rather than white (an argument for using it here would be it has a more similar spectral content to music). Pink noise definitely compresses more though still maybe not that much.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by mtone on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:54PM (#10548840)
Comparing music complexity with audio data compressibility sounds like a big stretch. Music made of random notes doesn't sound anything like random noise, and a simple lullaby where the instument would be a random noise flute would still be hard to compress.

Compressing midi files would probably have been nore useful, and I doubt classical music would have topped the charts.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by tekp2 on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @05:01PM (#10549651)
Chris Ford has something interesting to say about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qg3XOfioapI
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by coldpie on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:38PM (#10548720)
Sounds like pseudo-science.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by SixSigma on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:13PM (#10548963)
Then explain the Baroque!
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by heuermh on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:30AM (#10547454)
Yours reminded me of:

"Someone once said that the Philistines just try to sing too many notes at once. And that the notes seem to stumble and fall over each other. Listen to the Philistines' bubbly song as it gains speed and complexity as it moves along."

Tarquin Descending · The Philistines Jr. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PepVNaznzEE

More on topic, little-scale wrote a tool in MAX/MSP that renders an image into MIDI data in this style

http://little-scale.blogspot.com/2014/03/picture2midi-max-pa...

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by cma on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:19PM (#10548184)
>Want can we do with a piano if we had more than ten notes to play at a time.

Zappa explored this heavily with his synclavier work. Wasn't a fan, but the early MIDI sound of it it turned me off more than anything and I didn't give it a fair shake.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by ccvannorman on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:08AM (#10547311)
Cut to His Majesty being blown out of his throne by dubstep. "Is this few enough notes for you?" Mozart yells, hands cupped.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @11:28AM (#10547436)
"Oh well, a little zen music won't bother you then, your majesty"

https://youtu.be/WOqrJong0Pk?t=2m31s

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by wldcordeiro on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:59PM (#10548028)
It bothers me that they took a perfectly good Aphex Twin song and threw yelling on top of it.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:02PM (#10548050)
Naww man its perfect. That's a perfect scene in an almost perfect movie.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by coldtea on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @10:59AM (#10547268)
>This certainly is an interesting area to explorer musically. Want can we do with a piano if we had more than ten notes to play at a time.

We do, there are lots of pieces for 2 people playing the same piano (so 20 fingers).

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by skywhopper on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:21PM (#10547743)
Composers have been known to write in fist-clusters and forearm-strikes that resemble the sort of stuff going on in the video. Ben Folds in the early days would often slam his piano bench into the keyboard to hit quite a few more notes than would be possible using just one's arms and hands, even.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vlunkr on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @01:24PM (#10548215)
There are other limitations that we can't achieve naturally. Like speed. There's a limit to how fast you can make those hammers move.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by beat on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @02:30PM (#10548660)
Conlon Nancarrow, who was mentioned at the beginning of the article, challenged those limitations pretty hard. In his home studio, he had two player pianos physically synced, and the felt hammer heads replaced with steel hammers. There was sometimes so little paper left on the rolls that they would shred and jam while playing.

Despite the busy approach, though, Nancarrow's music tends to be joyous and delightful. It reminds me much of Duke Ellington's orchestral compositions.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by SixSigma on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:16PM (#10548976)
Or Bach's concerto for four pianos, or Vivaldi's

http://youtu.be/7OwQOb6bd1M

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by hellofunk on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @12:04PM (#10547643)
And lots of pieces for 2 pianos and 4 hands, so 40 fingers.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by SixSigma on Wednesday November 11, 2015 @03:20PM (#10548993)
Imagine if he'd written it for three pianos:

http://youtu.be/eZBTVismQBk