On the way up the escalators, we all commented to each other how the station felt considerably different to other tube stations. It felt better, nicer, more pleasant. This was strange, as the fit and finish is no different to other new tube stations. Eventually one of my friends realised the difference: there was no advertising.
I think we underestimate the mental load that advertising clutter causes us, even when it's merely in the background. We're so used to it that it's not until it's gone that we realise how burdensome it actually is.
I work in marketing / previously worked in more direct advertising, yet most of the time find adverts annoying. But not on the underground.
Otherwise I actively avoid advertising wherever possible – I haven't watched broadcast TV or commercial radio in years and block all the things online.
Interestingly, the other day I was on the tube and every single ad was for web-based services. No physical products or pre-Internet companies at all.
Perhaps because they are passive - you choose to view or not simply by looking at them or elsewhere.
Digital media is often a different mechanism - actively choosing to interrupt what you are reading or doing. Which causes the user behavior the publishers are struggling so hard to avoid - abandonment.
OK, Times Square is a special case, but it didn't seem to get much better elsewhere. Pretty much everything that could be held still for more than five minutes seemed to be sponsored, co-branded or had an advert stuck on it. I was surprised the pigeons didn't have little logos stuck on their wings.
I just could not get my head around the TV ads for medicines. They were some of the most bizarre things I've ever seen, beyond parody. One advert had an elderly couple laughing, drinking wine and standing around on boats, while a voiceover quickly listed all the terrible side effects of taking it. For about three minutes.
There may be a little bit of hope in stopping the hemorrhage: making people that have not yet installed an adblocker to not do it, if they can paint the move as not really worth it. But even that is going to be very hard, so we'll see.
I've previously advocated for a different kind of reform. I want advertisers to start paying web users directly. Then web users can reward publishers with their traffic. It's not a perfect solution because it probably means that web users will still see advertising, but at least they would be somewhat compensated for it.
One page I looked at (the homepage of a popular dutch news site) has no less than six adverts on it, two of them animated and one a 'rotator', taking up a very large fraction of the total available space. Compared to a 1980's newspaper or a 2001 website that's absolutely horrific, all this besides the tracking and other implications.
So yes, it's gotten really worse, and not just a little bit. The creatives look better and the 1000000th visitor ads (that were spread through 24x7 mostly) were dumb but there are other metrics than the 'level' at which an ad addresses the audience.
I'm not saying you're completely wrong but you seem to remember the past through rose colored glasses.
[1] http://www.cnet.com/news/geocitizens-fume-over-watermark/
[2] http://web.archive.org/web/19990208003328/http://angelfire.c...
[3] http://web.archive.org/web/19990208014605/http://www.lycos.c...
[4] http://web.archive.org/web/20000229043301/http://www.altavis...
[5] http://web.archive.org/web/20031012062202/http://yahoo.com
[6] http://web.archive.org/web/20010402054709/http://www.msn.com...
- popups that obscure the article after you start reading and scroll down
- campaigns that follow you everywhere
- advertising in the middle of the text you're reading, in the same font as the article
- entire articles written simply to be able to place a product or an ad (advertorials)
- pages on which 50% or more is taken over by ads
and on and on.
Really the web of 2000 was so much more innocent in this respect. Those 640x480 ads were relatively easy to ignore, usually above the fold and maybe a skyscraper along the side but that was about it. Irritating, sure. But nothing compared to being hounded by ads for a specific product because you once googled a particular term or that feeling halfway through reading something that it is simply an un-declared ad.
Btw, I host a copy of geocities today and it is entirely ad free :)
I am pretty sure that they fully understand it but they can not openly admit it because that would completely destroy their ad revenues forever. Instead they try to get back to the good old days somehow because money from ads is the method which requires the lowest effort on their side.
I refuse to have every famous person of the past and the present to be subconsciously linked to six letters of a brand name.
So I installed adblock. This is quite ironic, since Google depends on people looking at ads.
This shows that they still don't see the big picture - that it's not just in digital media that ads have completely crossed the line, it's everywhere, from TV, radio and print, to billboards, jumbo-trons and corporate names on structures and landmarks. They are still clinging to the idea that they can go back to good times if they just reform some of their practices.
This is the end result of one group (publishers) relying on a revenue stream (advertisers) that destroys their own service and credibility. They still don't understand this.