Re:Why Torture Doesn't Work: The Neuroscience of Interrogation
by bluecalm on Monday November 09, 2015 @04:51AM
(#10532126)
>>if you could verify the crucial piece of information, you wouldn't be torturing him in the first place.
This is not true. There are many things easy to verify but difficult to discover. For example a place the money is kept in a big house.
Re:Why Torture Doesn't Work: The Neuroscience of Interrogation
by saganus on Monday November 09, 2015 @05:25PM
(#10536283)
Well yes. But I think the parent was framing it with reference to the intelligence world conflicts. At least that's how I Read it.
Imagine you torture a guy to get the name of it's cell leader. You can't verify this easily. You have to capture that other guy, torture him and repeat the process. While in any of those steps you have the chance of getting false information without knowing it.
I would think most intelligence from a war zone would be of this type, i.e. hard to verify, and I think the parent was thinking along those lines as well.
Really? You have data on this? I'd love to see it.
However, there are multiple problems with your scenario.
The biggest being: what happens if the individual DOESN'T KNOW? He's going to tell you anything he can to get you to stop, and, if you could verify the crucial piece of information, you wouldn't be torturing him in the first place.
So, even if I concede that torture works when you know you have the right person (and I do not), the problem is that you can't distinguish whether you have the right person and whether he actually knows the information you want.