News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by ealexhudson on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:54PM (#10522315)
My last house was built in ~1936. It was cheap for the time, but the entire estate of houses it sat in was complete - virtually nothing had been removed. The form of the buildings had changed somewhat (extension for bathroom instead of toilet in the garden), but the brick walls were incredible and the internal timberwork (joists, frames, etc.) was all hardwood of a quality that would be very expensive now.

My current house was built in ~1985. The brick quality isn't bad, the walls are much straighter, but the wood is cheaper and the materials thinner and lighter. It might be the case this place will last 100 years, but I wouldn't bet on it. It's a middle market house, for the time, not cheap but not high end.

While survivor bias is important, where I live (London) the main reason houses from 100 years ago aren't around now is simply the war. The stuff from then that's still about - including "cheap" factories and other stuff - is now wildly fashionable and still well-built. Stuff built in the 50s was laughably awful and a lot is gone, stuff from 60s and 70s is going the same way. There are definitely other things going on.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:28PM (#10522500)
I think one thing is buildings are now are built closer to their required engineering tolerances. In the past many building were massively over engineered, while modern buildings seem to be built for their exact expected lifespan.

The one thing I really hate about most modern buildings here in Australia is the ceiling height has been reduced. A lot of modern buildings have ceiling heights around 7’ while old buildings will have ceilings of 10’ to 12’.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by tobico on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:11PM (#10522672)
Shorter ceilings are better for climate control, though. No need to heat up a bunch of air that just floats around over your head.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by jonknee on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:35PM (#10522765)
Not a huge concern in most parts of Australia... Having high ceilings (and fans) is actually an advantage.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by prodmerc on Friday November 06, 2015 @10:17PM (#10523514)
It's the opposite in countries with a hot climate - high ceilings make ventilation (without an AC) better.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by feedjoelpie on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:19PM (#10522698)
This is only true if your climate makes it more expensive to heat the building than to cool it.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by computer on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:49PM (#10522587)
Ceiling heights of 7 feet? Are you sure? Many tall people would only just fit upright...
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by nikatwork on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:20PM (#10522703)
7' is accurate for many new Housing Estate houses eg AV Jennings. The buildings all look similar except for roof color. It's very disorientating.

My house is 1860s with a 12' ceiling. Those other places feel like claustrophobic rabbit holes in comparison.

Low ceilings minimize material costs and maximize profits.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:12PM (#10523120)
This is exactly right - it is done to reduce the building cost.

Of course having a ceiling this low is terrible for natural cooling so you then have to run air conditioning all the time costing far more in the long run. I live in a 1920s building with 11’ ceilings and I don’t have or need air conditioning because the place stays cool enough even through the height of summer.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by maccard on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:41AM (#10524746)
most places in the UK don't run AC even during the summer.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by redcalx on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:52PM (#10522836)
> Low ceilings minimize material costs and maximize profits.

They also minimise heat loss, which is strictly regulated in the UK. Hence that other annoying feature of many modern build - tiny windows.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by oh_sigh on Friday November 06, 2015 @07:44PM (#10523016)
Why is heat loss regulated? Shouldn't I be able to heat my home as much or as little as I want?
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by mrec on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:03PM (#10523081)
The regulation is about energy efficiency of new-build construction, not how much you have your heating on. Partly it's a green thing, partly it's pragmatic, in that the UK has failed to invest in serious power generation for decades and faces the real possibility of brownouts in the not too distant future.

Plants are approaching EOL and they haven't been building new capacity to replace them. They've thrown a bunch of money at wind, but I think that's been more of a handout to (traditionally Conservative-voting) landowners than a viable strategy.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by speeder on Friday November 06, 2015 @11:04PM (#10523644)
UK STILL don't fixed those issues?

UK since middle ages was already infamous for having cities (specially london, but not just london) that have energetic problems and rely a lot on coal (and now other fossil fuels), leading to the infamous killer fogs, and to the victorian fashion (in victorian era, people tried to use stuff that would not have issues in a highly polluted air, for example extremely thick and dark curtains, so that people don't notice you aren't washing them a lot...)

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by roel_v on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:34AM (#10524175)
Across Europe there are strict standards for building efficiency. This is not just about insufficient infrastructure, it's to keep energy waste in check. People want as cheap a house as possible (which I understand, it's hugely expensive and most people have to make serious sacrifices) and when having to choose between not terribly energy-inefficient and full-height bedrooms, they'll often choose the latter. Which is unsustainable in the aggregate. Hence, tight regulations on energy efficiency.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by oh_sigh on Saturday November 07, 2015 @05:56PM (#10526557)
> Which is unsustainable in the aggregate.

Isn't that just implying that most energy is artificially cheap, relative to its externalities?

Why can I own two new homes with 8' ceilings and heat them both(even if I don't live at one for 90% of the time), but I can't own one new home with 12' ceilings?

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by roel_v on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:11PM (#10526938)
"Isn't that just implying that most energy is artificially cheap, relative to its externalities?"

Yes it is. But if you're going to charge 'real' price (even assuming you can), people with the least disposable income will have to pay disproportionally more for their energy, which is a a basic need in 2015. Plus it would cause ripple effects that are impossible to predict. So the prudent way of mitigating this is with targeted policies, like building efficiency. It's a political decision. Of course one might say 'we should charge everything at the full rate and let the market sort it out', which is a fine position (one I personally lean towards, for as much as that matters) but it's irrelevant to the fact that there are many groups that don't agree. So what we have now is a system with many groups pushing in various directions, and 'patches' for situations where that causes unwanted effects that all parties can agree on (well, a majority can agree on) should be mitigated somehow.

"Why can I own two new homes with 8' ceilings and heat them both(even if I don't live at one for 90% of the time), but I can't own one new home with 12' ceilings?"

So to come back to the issue at hand, I can also buy a 10MW heater, put it outside in my garden and have it 'waste' energy 24/7. We don't have laws against that (afaik). But our policies rely partly on the assumption of economically rational actors, which to a degree and in the aggregate is the empirically verified reality.

In other words, for ever policy I'm sure one can think of 100 ways to stay within the law yet violate the spirit of the policy. That's just the nature of governance, and it works fine in the vast majority of cases. Law is not a closed rule-based system like computers are, and that's fine.

(actually that last part is up for debate; even Montesquieu (who was the guy to come up with the original theory of 'balance of three powers') was of the opinion that perfect law should be just that, and that judges should do nothing but apply rigid rules to facts. But that's getting way more off topic than is reasonable...)

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by swampthinker on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:18PM (#10523148)
It's a the result of new of building code, which has minimum energy efficiency requirements. Residential energy efficiency is projected via heat loss calculations among other things.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by coldtea on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:06PM (#10523095)
Not when your country imports oil and you have a negative impact on its trade deficit (and/or environment).
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by oh_sigh on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:09PM (#10523107)
Shouldn't I be regulated as to when I can open my windows then too? (as in, not in winter)
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by coldtea on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:16PM (#10523138)
Well, "should" or "shouldn't" can get too complex to analyze.

There's no god given set of rights -- what we get to do is what the era/society/legal system we live in allows us.

And what's moral/good to do even outside or against what's allowed, is a matter of philosophy.

People expected to be able to smoke even on an airplane in the 70s. Nowadays not so much. Asking someone not to smoke "within 30 ft of this building's entrance" (a common sign), would seem as ridiculous to them as the regulation of heating to you.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by oh_sigh on Saturday November 07, 2015 @05:54PM (#10526548)
The difference being that I don't pay a tax to the people who are inconvenienced when I smoke. Suppose everyone in an area set a price that they would be willing to smell cigarette smoke during their meal. If I pay them all that price, why shouldn't I be allowed to smoke? And some people would set it at +infinity, which is fine too, which would mean I don't get to smoke.

With heating, the government is placing a +infinity price on heat retention for buildings(with ceilings > 8'), but isn't actually enforcing that price in any other manner. Why not just charge progressively increasing amounts for electricity/gas expenditure? Right now, I can have a 100% legal, heat-efficient home, and heat it day and night by leaving the windows open. I wouldn't do that because I don't like to waste money, but that is just like I would not live in a house that was extremely energy inefficient.

Basically, if I want to pay for tall ceilings in my house, shouldn't I be able to, assuming I pay the appropriate amount?

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by coldtea on Sunday November 08, 2015 @10:01AM (#10528630)
>With heating, the government is placing a +infinity price on heat retention for buildings(with ceilings > 8'), but isn't actually enforcing that price in any other manner. Why not just charge progressively increasing amounts for electricity/gas expenditure?

Because they just want to impose a rule for what they believe is better for the environment.

They don't want to make it into a market product.

>Basically, if I want to pay for tall ceilings in my house, shouldn't I be able to, assuming I pay the appropriate amount?

That just makes it into something the rich can do while the poor can't. While indeed it also servers to lower the number of people doing't it -- it's not what any society that holds to high esteem any values besides net worth would want to do.

And I'm not just talking about the "tall ceilings" thing here, which might or might not be reasonable, but the more general question "shouldn't I pollute/waste as much energy as I want if I pay enough for it?".

Somethings we don't allow people to do at any price. Like kill people. Even if the victim also agrees. I, for one, don't believe payment trumps any morals in principle, and I wouldn't want that to be the case.

Whether it happens in practice (e.g. bribery etc), that's OK. But I wouldn't design a system where that's accepted and celebrated too.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by nikatwork on Friday November 06, 2015 @11:46PM (#10523758)
Mate, this is bloody Oz. It hit nearly 46C (114F) last year in my city. Last thing I'm trying to do is minimize heat loss.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by plonh on Friday November 06, 2015 @10:24PM (#10523536)
UK tenements had few or no windows due to the perverse tax formula.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:08PM (#10523103)
Yep it totally claustrophobic if you are over 5’ in height. I really, really hate low ceilings.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by tgb on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:14PM (#10523341)
Huh, I grew up in a house with ceilings no higher than maybe 7'2" (though that was not usual for buildings) and am 5'11" and wouldn't dream of calling it "claustrophobic". My father is even a couple inches taller. I guess it depends a lot on what you're used to.

Meanwhile my current residence has ceilings so high that I haven't bothered to install some LED bulbs that I have lying around since I don't have an easy safe way to reach the light fixtures.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:24PM (#10523376)
I am sure different people feel differently, but for me low ceilings are a non-option. In a climate like mine high ceilings avoid the need for air conditioning.

You can get special poles for changing high bulbs. I have seen them before, but I can't remember what they are called.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by gluggymug on Friday November 06, 2015 @10:50PM (#10523601)
Ah you must mean the good old "ceiling puncher". :)

Actually I think the pole is just the regular extension pole you'd use with a paint roller. You get a light bulb changing attachment instead.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by sliverstorm on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:46PM (#10522811)
That opens the question of expected lifetime of a house though. The interior might need to be ripped out and plumbing or sewage etc retrofitted, but in plenty of cases there is simply no reason why the foundation, framing, or other things can't be retained. Which, given the value of high quality timber, seems like a goal worth striving for, rather than disposable houses.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:15PM (#10523135)
From a purely economic perspective a building that lasts more than 50 years is probably not worth doing. In theory you could invest the initial savings and replace the whole building in 50 years from the income.

The downside of pushing the engineering to the limit is the builders often cut corners to make their own savings so that the building does not even make 50 years. Plenty of new buildings here in Australia are having major structural issues after only 5 to 10 years because of this.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by gluggymug on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:12PM (#10523331)
Agreed. I was a victim of this in my former home in Adelaide.

It was a newly built townhouse complex so we were a body corporate. Within 4 years of building completion, we were suffering from rising damp and completely loose paving in the shared driveways. The paving was too high relative to the damp proof course and the base wasn't prepared properly.

It took a couple of years of legal stuff to claim on the building warranty.

Having been through this, I now are more acutely aware of how dodgy new building are around Australia. New apartments especially.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:28PM (#10523383)
There is no way I would ever buy a new apartment. One of my friends is a builder and the number of horror stories he tells me about current building practices is near endless.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by Khaine on Sunday November 08, 2015 @04:04AM (#10528006)
It is absolutely criminal how much we let builders get away with, and since building inspectors are no longer independent (the builder pays for them) everything is stacked against home-buyers these days
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by roel_v on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:39AM (#10524188)
It's unlikely that the design and layout of a house will remain up-to-date over 50+ years. People's expectations change, see for example the role of a kitchen in a house. 50 years ago, the kitchen was were the wife cooked. Now kitchens are open, connected to the other living spaces, and very much the central point in the house. Re-doing the plumbing is one thing, dealing with that sort of changes is another.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by fweespeech on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:57PM (#10522613)
Are you 100% sure its 7'? There are a number of people [if small percentage wise] that are 7'.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by jonnathanson on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:21PM (#10522711)
Seriously. And it's not just the seven-footers who'd have issues. I'm 6'3, and I'd feel claustrophobic in a home with 7' ceilings. I'm above average in height, but, like, not wildly so. I certainly don't think I'm an outlier or anything.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by garrettgrimsley on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:21PM (#10523157)
Assuming you are a male in the USA you are in the 95th percentile [0] by height. And if you are 7 feet tall then you don't need to worry about low ceilings in council housing because you are probably an NBA [1] player.

[0] http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr010.pdf

[1] http://www.truthaboutit.net/2012/05/true-or-false-half-of-al...

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by jonknee on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:32PM (#10523205)
It would make for an interesting ADA claim...
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by ams6110 on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:47PM (#10523262)
High ceilings help when you don't have air conditioning. They are nice aesthetically but unnecessary and even detrimental (more air volume to cool) when you have it.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by danieltillett on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:18PM (#10523354)
The same argument can be made against windows.

High ceilings not only avoid the need for air conditioning (my home has 11' ceilings and no air conditioning), they make you feel better in the space. When I am in a building with low ceilings I feel totally claustrophobic and tense - this is not something I want to feel in my own home.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by roel_v on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:36AM (#10524179)
Modern windows can be made very energy efficient. In fact, it's possible to design an almost all-glass energy-neutral house in much of Western Europe.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by olau on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:50AM (#10524205)
Feels like nitpicket but: volume of air is in itself not a problem. There's not a whole lot of energy in air. The issue with heating/cooling is the surface area.

With active heating/cooling, what really helps is better insulation. In Scandinavia and Germany people are insulating walls in new houses with 40 cm rockwool, or the equivalents thereof.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by douche on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:19AM (#10524991)
My experience in the US is that 8' ceilings are pretty much standard. I've helped build a few stick-built additions and houses, and when you are buying stud timber in bulk, it comes precut either to 96" or 92 5/8" - which, with standard 2xX top and bottom plates, works out to be 8'.
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by chaqke on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:03PM (#10522643)
There's a saying that goes something like: "Any idiot can build a bridge. It takes an engineer to build a bridge that is just strong enough to stand given the weight it's meant to bear".

A lot of older structural "engineering" was figuring out how much material was required, then multiplying it by 80 just in case.

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by jfoutz on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:23PM (#10522473)
It's also interesting to see 2x4s that are actually 2 inches by 4 inches
Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by pcurve on Saturday November 07, 2015 @12:13AM (#10523826)
I laughed at this post because my current home is all brick house built in 1930s, with a brick extension built in 1980s.

An inspector said, "those are very good bricks from the 30s. They don't make bricks that strong anymore"

Re:Why has the quality of brick buildings declined in the la... by roel_v on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:41AM (#10524193)
Yes they do, if you pay for it. I know several brick factories that will make you those 'high-quality' ones. But they don't stock them (instead they make them custom if you want them) because the demand is so low due to the 100% price difference with other bricks that, realistically, serve they purpose just as well.