News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by slapshot on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:53PM (#10521209)
I'm totally with you in spirit. Solitary should not be used for long-term punishment for offenses in prison, or as punishment for what happened on the outside.

But what do you do about an inmate who terrorizes his cellmates, his peers on the yard, his peers in the cafeteria, etc. You've tried solitary for a day, for a week, etc.

If you leave this inmate in with general, he's taking away their rights to learn and rehabilitate. If you put him in with a bunkmate... well, that seems like punishment to the bunkmate. You end up creating a new ad-seg unit that looks just like the old one, but with a new name.

I'm not meaning to say that solitary is used correctly in the US right now. Not at all. But it may be an inevitable result for a very small group of prisoners who would otherwise take away the others' right to rehabilitate.

(Edit: replaced stray ? with .)

Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by mod on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:57PM (#10521237)
Give him a solitary bunk but without the lack of sensory input. Leave a TV and view to the outside and all of the things a normal cell has.
Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by thaumasiotes on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:59PM (#10521248)
So, these people get better treatment than the better-behaved prisoners? You don't foresee any incentive-related problems?
Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by jsharpe on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:12PM (#10521336)
Why not let people opt into it?

For a lot of people, even if there are some benefits, they aren't going to make up for the lack of social contact.

Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by waterfowl on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:10PM (#10521319)
ADX(fed supermax in colorado) prisoners have TVs, I don't think people are trying to get sent there for the TV.
Re:Solitary confinement: More than a decade after release, t... by jdc on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:11PM (#10521333)
Please show me the evidence for confinement incentivising good behavior.