News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by logicchains on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:06AM (#10513325)
Deaths under Pinochet: 3000, according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_dictatorship_of_Chile.... Deaths under Mao: 20,000,000 - 70,000,000, according to http://necrometrics.com/20c5m.htm#Mao. Deaths under Stalin: 20,000,000 - 50,000,000 according to http://necrometrics.com/20c5m.htm#Stalin. Deaths in 1990s Russia: I can't even find a source.

So if 1990s Russia and Pinochet's Chile are examples of extreme free market experiments, I'd take the human misery they cause over the human misery of extreme no-market experiments any day.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by asgard1024 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:25AM (#10513803)
> So if 1990s Russia and Pinochet's Chile are examples of extreme free market experiments

You're confused. They're examples of free market experiments, however the Pinochet's deaths had nothing to do with the free market and all with his political power.

If you want to see deaths caused by free market, look at e.g. homeless people who freeze on the street during winter.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by fsloth on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:15AM (#10513372)
The statistic you want for russia is the life expectancy. Russians are dying very young. The situation got worse after 1990s.
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by ctlby on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:30AM (#10513459)
Why is this relevant? The proximate cause for the decreasing life expectancy is massive alcohol consumption. You could assign the blame by drawing long, tenuous chains of social causation from policies you don't like. Or, not unreasonably, you could just fault those destroying their bodies through substance abuse.
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by tormeh on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:37AM (#10513874)
Indirect harm is no less harm than direct harm. If life expectancy plummets after capitalism takes effect then yeah, capitalism is probably to blame.

Anyway, I don't think anyone excuses dictatorships in this thread.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by seanflyon on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:07PM (#10516786)
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by Dylan16807 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @12:31PM (#10514698)
I wouldn't say that's the main cause. It's more about the collapse of the previous infrastructure than the particulars of what came after.
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by saiya-jin on Thursday November 05, 2015 @11:47AM (#10514360)
why the need to narrow complex set of factors affecting each other into a single bullet point? it doesn't work, not only in this scenario. General Russian mentality is a prime example of one f*ed up beyond repair, for quite a few generations to come unless some miracle happens (and Putin is making sure it won't happen during his reign).
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by gdy on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:20PM (#10515112)
"General Russian mentality is a prime example of one f*ed up beyond repair"

What do you mean?

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by fsloth on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:18AM (#10513748)
Well, my first hypothesis for rampant alcoholism - cultural background nonwithstanding - would be the lack of options in the social environment.
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by PhasmaFelis on Thursday November 05, 2015 @03:54PM (#10516048)
> Why is this relevant? The proximate cause for the decreasing life expectancy is massive alcohol consumption.

IIRC, this is not true. It's a contributor, certainly, but Russian life expectancy is substantially lower than other nations with similar alcohol consumption.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by ctlby on Thursday November 05, 2015 @09:23AM (#10513419)
Has any philosophy in human history caused more death and suffering than collectivism and its offshoots? ... and its adherents take the free-marketeers to task for their "cruelty" and "heartlessness"!
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by asgard1024 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:22AM (#10513770)
You have presented a logical tautology. Killing another human being is always collectivist according to your definition.

However, that doesn't say anything about validity of ideas of free market or communism. What does say a lot though is that some free market proponents have the need to advocate Pinochet.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 05, 2015 @03:55PM (#10516053)
> You have presented a logical tautology. Killing another human being is always collectivist according to your definition.

That's not what ctlby said. Nor is it a reasonable interpretation of his/her words.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by asgard1024 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:14PM (#10516493)
OK, consider this. Every (moral) philosophy exists to motivate other people, as a code to follow (if it didn't you wouldn't have reason to tell anyone!). This means there is a group, or a collective, which supposedly holds these values and is to be protected. If fulfilling this philosophy (or its protection) requires killing other humans, then this is (ostensibly) done in the interest of the group.

In other words, if someone is killing for individual reasons, he is not following any philosophy, because he doesn't need any; he's just crazy or psychopath. Killing for philosophical reasons always happens to protect some social order (albeit sometimes fictional).

If you don't agree, there is a simple solution. Just provide an example of philosophy that causes killing of people and is not in fact collectivist (by any definition you choose, it doesn't matter very much, and that's why I was able to do the bold claim I did).

Or to put it even simpler, it's contradictory to kill another human to fulfil any philosophy of individual freedom.

Hitler killed because he wanted to protect Germans from Jews, Pinochet killed because communists were danger to his social order, and so on. Even Winston Smith from 1984 was willing to kill in order to replace the social system (which is the passage in the book I really like, because it's one of the places that makes it actually morally ambiguous, just like real world).

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 05, 2015 @05:27PM (#10516584)
You said, "Killing another human being is always collectivist according to your [ctlby's] definition."

Now you argue that killing another human being for philosophical reasons is always collectivist according to your [asgard1024's] definition. That does nothing whatsoever to make the quoted statement true.

[Edit: For that matter, I see nowhere where ctlby gave his/her definition of "collectivist", nor where he/she assented to yours definition.]

To your point in this post:

You are kind of arguing a tautology. If someone expresses a moral philosophy (no matter how twisted), but they are the only one who believes it or adheres to it, they're collectivist, because they're trying to motivate other people to follow their code. But if someone doesn't express their reasons as a moral philosophy, "he's just crazy or a psychopath". You dismiss any possibility that such a person is following an inexpressed philosophy. In fact, you have pretty much defined out the possibility of there even being such a thing. From that starting point, you argue that your position is correct, but in fact it was contained in your starting assumptions, so your argument is of no value.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by asgard1024 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:30PM (#10516858)
> Now you argue that killing another human being for philosophical reasons is always collectivist according to your [asgard1024's] definition. That does nothing whatsoever to make the quoted statement true.

What I said is true of (almost) any definition of "collectivist", including ctlby's.

> You dismiss any possibility that such a person is following an inexpressed philosophy.

Yes, because any inexpressed philosophies were not subject of the discussion; we can't assign killings due to inexpressed philosophies to any philosophy, since we don't know which one.

I mean, show me one non-collectivist philosophy according to which is OK to kill human (except in unavoidable self-defense). There is no such thing - all of them are collectivist.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 05, 2015 @07:18PM (#10517081)
> What I said is true of (almost) any definition of "collectivist", including ctlby's.

No, your definition of collectivist is so expansive, everything fits. My reply is trying to communicate something to you, therefore my reply is collectivist (or else I don't understand your definition). But presuming I do understand, I reject your definition as being so broad as to be meaningless.

> I mean, show me one non-collectivist philosophy according to which is OK to kill human (except in unavoidable self-defense). There is no such thing - all of them are collectivist.

The Marquis de Sade had a philosophy. Since there is no God, whatever is, is right. And, hey, nature made man stronger than woman. Therefore man has the right to do to woman whatever he wants. I can't find any sane way to describe that philosophy as "collectivist", but de Sade lived out his philosophy to the extent of torturing women. (To my knowledge, he did not actually kill any, but certainly he was free to do so, according to his philosophy.)

Now, I will agree with you that collectivist philosophies (conventionally defined) are much more likely to say that it is OK to kill an individual, because those philosophies start from the group being important, and the individual not. (That's kind of the definition of collective.) From that starting point, it's really hard to find a way to stop short of "It's OK to kill an individual if it's for the good of the group."

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by dragonwriter on Thursday November 05, 2015 @06:46PM (#10516925)
> I mean, show me one non-collectivist philosophy according to which is OK to kill human (except in unavoidable self-defense).

Individualistic (as opposed to ethical or utilitarian) hedonism: if it brings the holder of that philosophy net pleasure to do a thing, it is right to do it.

Pretty much the most anti-collectivist philosophy possible.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by asgard1024 on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:38AM (#10518253)
Yes, but it is also kind of trivial. I mean isn't this philosophy something that every agent ultimately follows?

I would like to see an example that would be useful to classify social systems, as ctlby attempted to do. But I don't see it. Once you put "social system" into it, killing happens for collectivist reason.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by PhasmaFelis on Thursday November 05, 2015 @04:00PM (#10516089)
So your argument is "Stalin and Mao were monsters, therefore fuck the poor"?

Life is not black and white. The hardline communists were awful. That doesn't mean that hardline capitalists can't also be awful. Maybe they're less awful, in a "rather be kicked in the face than shot in the head" kind of way, but that's not a positive recommendation.

Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by toyg on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:25AM (#10513797)
Dude, you cannot compare a country the size of Chile (8m in the '60s) with a country the size of Russia (120m in the '60s) or China (600m in the '60s).
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by tedunangst on Thursday November 05, 2015 @10:59AM (#10514031)
But we can divide 3000 / 8M and 20M / 120M to get ratios, no?
Re:Text of the Trans-Pacific Partnership by toyg on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:07PM (#10515009)
No, because you also have to account for duration and for a number or other factors (e.g. Chilean population was concentrated in very few cities, so the effect of one death was relatively higher than in a place like Russia, where things often happen "at very long distance"; and so on and so forth).

This is not a rational historical comparison (if such a thing can really exist), these are just random numbers shouted in a pub argument, "My guy killed less people than your guy!"...