Rather than targeting event planning pros, we're seeking general consumers, ultimately anyone that is looking for an event space. Think AirBNB for Event Spaces.
I'm not quite sure if it's a product issue that's causing the dis-traction/lack of use OR marketing? That's the real question/problem that we're actively seeking a solution for! If you have any additional ideas on this it would be greatly appreciated.
On the other hand, event venues have common needs and will fall more neatly into a B2B relationship with your company.
That said, it's hard to see an easy value proposition for a middle layer in the transaction. What's to keep the person planning your event from researching venues on your website and then just booking directly with the venue?
AirBnB built itself as a marketplace purely by expanding the pool of overnight accommodations. Not by building a marketplace to connect travellers with hotels. It has been successful by creating a product market fit because it defined a new market.
Because of the way money flows in the industry, it may be better to focus on meeting the needs of venues because they will collect money directly from the transaction and can dictate that your service be used for bookings. Event planners on the other hand are paid outside the booking transaction that you're interested in and they have venue options that are unlikely to appear in your marketplace, e.g. churches, parks, etc.
Good luck.