News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by wmeredith on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @10:05AM (#10507028)
I do as well. What's wrong with leaving it there?
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maaku on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @11:10AM (#10507512)
Many times in the past bitcoin companies have been hacked, embezzled or otherwise lost user funds. There is no recourse.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:10PM (#10507962)
> Many times in the past bitcoin companies have been hacked, embezzled or otherwise lost user funds. There is no recourse.

Many times, other companies have had that happen, and there is all kinds of recourse. To the extent bitcoin companies are special, its because people participating in the bitcoin craze have been willing to entrust large amounts of value with companies that don't have the basic characteristics that would otherwise establish trustworthiness, or at least accountability.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maaku on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:40PM (#10508187)
What do you do when the money is gone? With other payment technology you can get court orders to freeze funds, or judgments against current holders.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, is irrevocable and pseudo-anonymous. In July 2011 the owner of MyBitcoin.com web wallet allegedly walked away with 50,000 btc of customer funds. We know where those funds are. You can see them on any block explorer. But it is not possible to freeze or confiscate those funds. And we don't know what real world person or people have access to the keys controlling those funds. So what are you going to do?

MtGox went under with 850,000 btc of customer funds. Its creditors are currently fighting over the 200,000 btc that was found to still be in possession by the company. The other 650,000 btc? Who knows.

It's just a simple fact of reality. If you don't have physical control over the keys for that bitcoin, it is not your bitcoin. Some of us have learned that lesson the hard way.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by jsprogrammer on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:34PM (#10508525)
>But it is not possible to freeze or confiscate those funds.

That is just a limitation of the Bitcoin protocol. One could build a protocol where communities could agree to freeze (not accept) or greatly devalue those funds.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maxerickson on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:39PM (#10508553)
Miners could conspire to mostly freeze certain bitcoin.

It wouldn't even have to be done in a way that was visible on the bitcoin network, they would just have to agree to not include transactions from whatever addresses.

A strong majority could probably refuse to acknowledge blocks including the blocked addresses, which would be a real freeze (rather than the hassle freeze obtained by not including the address in blocks produced by the conspiracy).

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by jsprogrammer on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:45PM (#10508588)
You'd need >50% of the miners to do that. It is precisely what I mean by building a protocol.

Of course, without strong consensus (and a real algorithm/protocol) such attempts will likely just result in fractured blockchains (basically the state at the moment, with many competing implementations of the same basic idea).

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by csomar on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:39PM (#10509040)
Not really. you are talking about an attack.

You'll need 100%, because if a single miner decided to include the transaction, then it is in!

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maaku on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @03:47PM (#10509585)
You need only a cabal of >50% of the miners to agree to not build on any block that includes such a transaction.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by jsprogrammer on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @04:26PM (#10509900)
An attack and a new protocol are the same thing.

If a single miner includes the transaction, a majority can just bypass that sole miner.

You do need 100% of something, but that something is just >50% of the miners.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by bduerst on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @03:16PM (#10509323)
Only if that miner is successful for a block. Until then the blocked transaction stays in limbo.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maaku on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:24PM (#10508916)
It is an explicit design choice of the bitcoin protocol (feature, not a bug) that doing so requires a cabal of the majority of the hash power. With properly distributed hash power like bitcoin had in its infancy, this would not have been possible.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by fixermark on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:32PM (#10508114)
Given that BTC is a currency that is not backed by a national treasury (and is, in fact, technologically not backable by printing more money), such insurance would be a prohibitively expensive percentage of a company's BTC resources.

The same features of BTC that serve as its advantage and, arguably, goal make it more difficult to offer basic protections that other fiscal infrastructures have had for decades.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by aianus on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:13PM (#10508813)
You can store $100m in bitcoin on a piece of paper in a vault. It reduces perfectly to the solved problem of securing $100m in $100 bills in a vault (which, yes, you can insure).
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by fixermark on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:44PM (#10509069)
While true, that does not offer the same protection as an FDIC-style insurance program (and restricts the storing entity's ability to compete and perform by preventing them from investing that $100m, so the market will tend ceteris parabus to punish companies that take such a step in good times with relatively-slower growth, acting as a disincentivizing counter-weight to offering insurance). In contrast, the FDIC has unlimited borrowing capacity with the US government; worst-case scenario, the Treasury can basically start printing money and the FDIC can hand it out to people with savings in failed banks.

Many see this capacity of the US Treasury to fabricate money from nowhere as the very sort of flaw that BTC's coin-generation process is intended to avoid, but that protection does not come without a price.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by xixi77 on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @04:26PM (#10509903)
Since this is about an amount of $100m, I'd say the above suggestion (theoretically) offers much more protection than FDIC, which only covers losses up to $250k iirc...

I suspect that at the moment it may be more difficult to find an insurer for a vault with that piece of paper, compared to a vault with $100m cash though :) but perhaps that'll change.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:51PM (#10509126)
> While true, that does not offer the same protection as an FDIC-style insurance program

Sure, but whether that difference from "the same protection" is more or less protection depends on the number of people that $100 million is held on behalf of.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by bduerst on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @03:23PM (#10509380)
That's security, not insurance.

FDIC-style insurance is for when the security is breached, not if.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by stonemetal on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @10:26AM (#10507190)
In general nothing. In specific there is no FDIC for bitcoins so if a MtGox type situation happens then you have no coins.
Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @11:10AM (#10507510)
There's no FDIC providing government backed insurance for most commodities, or for non-bank accounts in fiat currency (e.g., those you'd have with a typical brokerage), so I'm not sure bitcoin is really fundamentally different than most commodities as a speculative investment

So for a speculative trader, I dont e that holding keys if any more essential than physically holding goods is for physical commodities; you obviously have to account for trust/security of the entity serving as your agent/broker, but that's typical.

Now, holding the keys may be essential to realizing some of the benefits of bitcoin which drive is value to some users, but for people investing in bitcoin, that may be peripheral to the purpose.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by gohrt on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:05PM (#10508357)
There's a qualitative difference between "I own stock that might become worthless" and "I own a security that someone could just take from me because they notice my deed just sitting somewhere unprotected."

If someone steals my Schwab account contents for Schwab's servers, I can call on the government for help; and the stock market bookkeeping system has the technical ability restore my shares to me. If someone gets a copy of my wallet key, I've got no recourse unless (unlikely) someone can track down the obfuscated thief.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:42PM (#10508569)
> If someone steals my Schwab account contents for Schwab's servers, I can call on the government for help

If someone steals your bitcoin from an exchange, you can call on the government for help, too. If the exchange itself is completely insolvent, that may not be effective recourse, and that risk is certainly greater for the kind of firms people have been dealing with in the bitcoin space, which often aren't held by their customers to the same standards that customers of similar services for commodities other than bitcoin would hold companies to.

That's my point: the lack of recourse isn't essential to bitcoin (yes, holding the keys is like holding cash, and not holding the keys is giving something up just like not holding cash is -- but we deal with other businesses with accounts denominated in national currencies without holding all the cash ourselves all the time, and have recourse available for losses.) The lack of accountability is because the firms people choose to do business with are, compared to the firms that people do other financial business with, shady fly-by-night operators.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by pdpi on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:52PM (#10508263)
> so I'm not sure bitcoin is really fundamentally different than most commodities as a speculative investment

That's the point, though. You're looking at it as a speculative investment, and proceeding accordingly, which is good. The OP is admonishing people to not treat bitcoin like a standard bank account (which is all too easy to do), but rather in the same terms as you already do.

Re:Bitcoin Surges Past $400 by maxerickson on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:51PM (#10508259)
It isn't quite the same as FDIC, but there is SIPC:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Investor_Protection...

Not blanket protection, but enough to ask why such and such bitcoin exchange doesn't advertise their participation.