I think they are rational - and certainly it's rational for me to defer to their judgement on the matter.
That's fine if you don't agree. But if you're replying in order to help me update my beliefs, then you'll need to provide a rebuttal to 3) - which you haven't. :)
To be honest I don't know how to evaluate the which of these two explanations of the scientist's behaviour are more likely.
I'd like to see some data on how much one can obtain funding by performing what is, given your beliefs, literally garbage science.
If we can establish at least precedent that scientists can attract funding on the basis of their projects that were (at the time, not in hindsight) - un-controversially junk research. Then your explanation would have the upper hand.
If we can establish a clear pattern of such rewards, then you win a slam dunk.
The rationality of performing the tests is that it's the basis of science. If someone claims something is possible, the role of science is not to respond with contempt and condescension, it is to prove the matter one way or the other. If the claimant is a crackpot then the experiment will prove it, which is what will happen most of the time. But not all of the time.
The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not "Eureka" but "That's funny..." —Isaac Asimov
That's where this research started. Is it reaction less? Possibly. Possibly not. It could be something like ablative losses from the metal. Or it could be other sources of experimental error. But right now, the understanding of the experiment is showing some unknown mass effect much greater than equalivalent ion thrust drive.
___________________________
EDIT: This story is false. Read further down for source video by creator. Reasoning: Missile guidance systems during Cold War.
I'll look for the user, and ask of their source.
________________________________________
EDIT: Ok. It looks like the Satellite pushing story was just that: a story. That narrative came from the NASAspaceflight forums where Shawyer was misquoted and the "telephone game" ensued.
The correct way this phenomenon was founded was during missile guidance and testing during the cold war.