News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by hitekker on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @08:13AM (#10499275)
Copy pasting what I think to be the most important part of the article:

  RoboVM is a complicated piece of technology that we have worked hard for years to 
  create. Over the past few months, we have seen competitors actively exploiting 
  our good faith by using our open source code to compete with us directly in 
  commercial products. On the flip side, we have received almost no meaningful 
  contributions to our open source code. 
  You can imagine how disappointing this has been to us; we had hoped our initial 
  business model of OSS with proprietary extensions (like our debugger and 
  interface builder integration) would work.
  But in light of the low contributions and behavior of competitors, we decided 
 to stop automatically releasing changes to the core of RoboVM as open source.
-Zechner

I'm not sure what to think about the competitors-stealing-our-code angle, but the OSS-is-being-used-as-freeware argument is certainly one point in favor of closing/controlling their code (as a business).

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by admax88q on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @08:38AM (#10499417)
They should have used a viral license like GPLv3, and sold commercial license exceptions.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by zxv on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @09:15AM (#10499619)
Yes, the GPLv3 is a powerful tool, but it doesn't completely eliminate the need to control when and how source code becomes open.

In practice, GPLv3 may only offer hope that one could some day prevent violations after the time and expense of litigation. VMWare and Tivo are examples.

Consider Google Android, which releases sources with binaries when the release occurs, not before. Balancing the how and when is just as important as the license.

Gnu Ghostscript was an example for many years. They used a dual license and released source to the public six months after binaries.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by admax88q on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @10:45AM (#10500272)
> In practice, GPLv3 may only offer hope that one could some day prevent violations after the time and expense of litigation

That's overly pessimistic. People abusing your GPLv3 licensed code would be almost the same as people pirating your proprietary software. It would still be copyright infringement and with prices already set for commerical license exceptions it would be relatively easy to sue for damages plus legal fees.

It's funny in this case that the Free Software approach may actually be a more viable business model for RoboVM than the OSS approach. Many people consider Open Source to be better for business and Free Software to be a bunch of hippies. But had RoboVM used a viral license and sold commercial exceptions (a model that the FSF considers acceptable) they could be defending user's freedoms while also building a viable business.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by bad_user on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @11:07AM (#10500435)
A successful open-source project is also about building a community of third-party contributors. Or at least the possibility of one such community happening. Dual licensing basically kills off that discussion, because in order for dual licensing to work, then contributors need to sign a contributors agreement that licenses their work for whatever purpose the parent company sees fit.

And this is where I've always disagreed with FSF's stance. Many people claim that GPL is inadequate because of the "ASP loophole". But a much bigger loophole is dual licensing. This is because dual licensing happens (and is useful) only when the product is unusable as open-source. For example Gitorious is AGPL licensed and does not need dual licensing because you know, it's meant for people to have an on-premise solution for Git hosting and it's a take it or leave it thing. A Javascript library on the other hand is totally useless as AGPL. Dual licensing is also what made Qt and consequently KDE to be less popular than Gtk+ and Gnome in distributions such as Red Hat's or Ubuntu, or why popular project such as Firefox or LibreOffice are better integrated with Gtk+/Gnome, even though Qt has always been technically superior. Heck, Qt's licensing is why Gtk+/Gnome happened in the first place.

You see, the biggest advantage of open-source, its raison d'être if you will, is the possibility to fork. But if a fork cannot survive because of licensing reasons, maybe because it cannot be applied to the same projects as the original, then that's not really open-source.

Personally I prefer the open core. For example I currently work with Scala and the JVM and I use IntelliJ IDEA as my IDE. It has a community edition with everything I need. Yet I pay for the Ultimate edition anyway. If the community edition gets discontinued, I'll switch in a heartbeat.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by jordigh on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @03:09PM (#10502211)
> A successful open-source project is also about building a community of third-party contributors.

Not necessarily. Depends on your goals. You might want to free up your software because it's the right thing to do and it guarantees your customers have a way out should should your business ever fail. You might scare away a few contributors by requiring copyright assignments so you can sell GPL exceptions, but the whole idea that you should free your software so you'll get more contributors is (1) sometimes false as it is in the present case, and (2) part of the campaign slogans that OSI made when they tried to rebrand free software as "open source".

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by mehrdada on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:00PM (#10503051)
> You see, the biggest advantage of open-source, its raison d'être if you will, is the possibility to fork

It might be the raison d'être of open source, but the goal of free software is preserving users' freedom, not ensuring usefulness of software in some commercial proprietary context. That seems to be at the root of your disagreement with FSF. You simply care about different things and therefore prioritize differently; everything else is secondary. FSF does not aim for popularity, convenience, or playing well with one's commercial interests as its primary goal.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by bad_user on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:45PM (#10503572)
The right to fork is a prerequisite for users' freedom and without it the software is not free. The right to fork is about having complete control over the software that you're using. And it's usually a fact - either you have that right, or you don't, instead of being a warm and fuzzy social ideal, like the issue of "users freedom" tends to be.

Because the second you said "users freedom", you're in danger, because what constitutes a "user" is unclear. Is a user a person that pushes buttons providing input for your program to produce its destined output? Or can a user be a programmer as well? Because depending on its needs, different users want different freedoms. And for example I do not consider AGPL to be open-source (or free software for that matter) because modifying code without redistributing the binaries is simple usage for a developer, which means AGPL imposes restrictions on usage, being a freaking EULA.

But going back to our subject, dual licensing, take a look at projects that are dual licensed and usually you'll notice that the choice of the license had nothing to do with users freedom, quite the contrary, after all, without serious constraints dual licensing wouldn't work.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by admax88q on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:46PM (#10503832)
What constitues a user is not unclear.

A user is both someone who uses the compiled software (pushes the button in your example) or a developer capable of modifying the software.

A developer doesn't need the freedom to redistribute the software to other users without also respecting their freedoms.

Dual licensing does nothing to hurt freedom, as a user of the GPL licensed software your freedom is protect, both to use the software, and to modify it for your usage.

Needing to assign copyright to make upstream contributions may hurt the rate at which the upstream project develops, but in no way hurts your freedom.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by quadrangle on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:52PM (#10501199)
The dual-licensing problem for software freedom is easily dealt with: just accept community contributions WITHOUT requiring a CLA. That is enough to legally guarantee the software will stay free for everyone.

Dual licensing isn't otherwise a loophole since it is a decision the primary author organization makes for themselves, not something someone else can do to your copyleft code.

Copyleft does protect the commons. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UneYZikN85Q

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by Dylan16807 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @03:04PM (#10502169)
> That's overly pessimistic. People abusing your GPLv3 licensed code would be almost the same as people pirating your proprietary software. It would still be copyright infringement and with prices already set for commerical license exceptions it would be relatively easy to sue for damages plus legal fees.

It's easier both to do and to get away with when there's an open license. They can adjust it to integrate, and claim confusion or delay while rounding up source code.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by admax88q on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:47PM (#10503838)
> They can adjust it to integrate, and claim confusion or delay while rounding up source code.

Then sue them for damages immediately. If they offer up their source code during the lawsuit then great! If they don't then you get damages.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by rmc on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @09:02AM (#10499553)
Or a licence like Affero GPL, which requires you to release the source code (and changes maybe?) if you make it available online.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by quadrangle on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:48PM (#10501173)
AGPL requires that you release the version that you are actually running on the server.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by s73v3r on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:56PM (#10501224)
The main purpose of their tool was running Java code on iOS. Using GPLv3, you couldn't do that.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by bad_user on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @09:07AM (#10499582)
There have been several projects closing the source of their software due to the competitors-stealing-their-code angle. All of those projects I know of are dead, because in most cases what makes them interesting is the open-source nature.
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @10:41AM (#10500250)
This is kind of the elephant in the room isn't it? I know there are a lot of mediocre FOSS software I tolerate solely because its FOSS. I know of several commercial or free closed alternatives that are better in a lot of ways, but the FOSS angle makes it interesting to me and others (others who freely contribute support in forums, code, etc).
Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by bcg1 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @09:40AM (#10499785)
> I'm not sure what to think about the competitors-stealing-our-code angle, but the OSS-is-being-used-as-freeware argument is certainly one point in favor of closing/controlling their code (as a business).

Implicit in this argument is the assumption that Xamarin ever wanted RoboVM to "win" at all.

I'm not saying that they don't... just that they subsumed a smaller competitor with an arguably superior product. Its logical to conclude that there exists a possibility that they simply paid to buy out RoboVM because they thought it would be cheaper than trying to compete head to head (especially, since as your c+p points out, competitors were/are using RoboVM code), and if RoboVM returns some of that money then it is just gravy on the biscuit.

If that's the case then too bad for Xamarin... it is more of a sign of their ineptitude and of their eventual demise... if their leadership choose to use cash to knock out competitors instead of innovation, it will be interesting to see how long they can keep that up.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by jbigelow76 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:41PM (#10501126)
I don't think shutting down RoboVM to avoid competition is Xamarin's goal, after all if RoboVM were to shut down there is no reason to assume that the Java developers that use it would migrate wholesale over to the Xamarin C# development environment.

My theory is that Xamarin is starting to care less and less what language is used to build mobile apps (for a while they claimed to care more about C# than Microsoft did); and instead own the products that become a natural pipeline into their service offerings like Test Cloud. Buying RoboVM lets Xamarin build in hooks that will mean staying in Xamarin platform is a natural progression.

Re:RoboVM Is No Longer Open-Source by HillRat on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @08:43AM (#10499447)
I'm about to do a Java to iOS shootout, so this is fairly apposite for me. RoboVM's big advantage for us at the moment is that it's a commercially-supported product in a space where you are completely at the mercy of your tools; if your use case falls outside Google's, then j2objc is a potential cul-de-sac; XMLVM looks interesting but may still be more of an academic project than professional tool, and so on. Ultimately, it makes more sense for Xamarin to give RoboVM more resources and take the codebase internal: the end result is likely to be a better tool and higher revenue.