News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:23AM (#10498586)
Well one factor is neatly summarized in this quote, which I found when I googled the phrase "inequality possibility frontiers" found in the first graph:

"The frequent claim that inequality promotes accumulation and growth does not get much support from history. On the contrary, great economic inequality has always been correlated with extreme concentration of political power, and that power has always been used to widen the income gaps through rent-seeking and rent-keeping, forces that demonstrably retard economic growth."

http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2007/12/the_fron...

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by ancap on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:44AM (#10498667)
Then, it would seem, the focus should not be on lessening inequality but rather destroying this "extreme political power". Ironically those who beat the drum of inequality most often call upon the use and expansion of those political powers to battle the symptom.
Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by asgard1024 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:12AM (#10499021)
Why not, but how? No matter how you want to dance about it, money are strongly related to power. (To most girls this is probably obvious. :-))

It's not just literally true - you can exchange money for raw materials and energy (power), but every time you give money to someone else to do your bidding, you are exercising power over them.

The only time this power is not really being exercised (as in "power over other people") is when you're spending for your own pleasure, buying things like a new car or a spa visit. Investing money is almost always exercising power, depending how much and with what intent you will affect future of others. For example, you can buy a newspaper company to make good PR about you.

So to be able to "destroy the power", in capitalist society, you would have to very tightly control how people spend money. This is not only fiendishly difficult, but also undesirable from a free market perspective.

Reducing inequality is a much simpler way to remove power from too powerful people, because it simply gives more power to other people. And there is in fact not much need to be wealthy in the first place, unless you can have associated power - there is only so much cars one person needs.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by ancap on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @08:03AM (#10499237)
> every time you give money to someone else to do your bidding, you are exercising power over them

I disagree. As long as you're referring to a non-coerced transaction, each side agrees to the transaction because they receive more benefit from engaging in the transaction then not engaging in it.

I don't think you're addressing the point I raised. Allow me to rephrase in case there's some ambiguity. The quote I originally replied to indicated that income inequality was an affect of a high concentration of political power. Assuming it is true that income inequality derives from a high concentration of political power, then using political means to solve income inequality is not only futile but demonstrates either a misunderstanding of the cause of income inequality or a kind of Stockholm syndrome from those who advocate to do so.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by thegp on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @12:31PM (#10501045)
Doesn't the qoute state that income inequality is supposed to enact accumulation and growth("give something to aspire to") but instead leads to concentration of political power among the wealthy, who then use that power to further secure their higher income, creating a feedback loop?

That directly implies that removing income inequality and adding feedback loops that avoids excessive capital concentration is the way to go.

And to your point about non-coerced transactions, where does coercion start? Monopolies? Excessive costs? Does Comcast coerce their customers, if they have only no internet as the alternative? Does uber coerce people with surge pricing? And that pharma guy, raising the price of the drug, did he coerce people ? I would tend to say yes in the case of the Comcast monopoly, no in the other cases.

But it's hard to define exactly where coercion starts.

A more fundamental examples, from my libertarian socialist perspective: advertising in public view. Is that coercion of a third party(the advertised to?) Microsoft windows/ apple and other walled gardens with no data export, but payed for upgrade path and end of support?

And even more fundamentally, sometimes any and all transactions you make can be under duress and make you inherently dependent on the partner: Getting a shitty job that barely feeds you, because your skills are obsolete and your country doesn't provide basic income?

Startint that shitty job early, due to not having the same resources, stability and growing opportunities because your father is working a shitty job just to make ends meet?

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by ancap on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @10:53PM (#10504491)
> Doesn't the qoute state that income inequality is supposed to enact accumulation and growth("give something to aspire to") but instead leads to concentration of political power among the wealthy, who then use that power to further secure their higher income, creating a feedback loop?

That's not how I am reading the quote. It states there is a correlation between a high concentration of political power and income inequality. Thus it seems absurd, even if you don't think the former causes the latter, to believe you can solve the latter through political means.

> And to your point about non-coerced transactions, where does coercion start? Monopolies? Excessive costs? Does Comcast coerce their customers, if they have only no internet as the alternative? Does uber coerce people with surge pricing? And that pharma guy, raising the price of the drug, did he coerce people ? I would tend to say yes in the case of the Comcast monopoly, no in the other cases.

> But it's hard to define exactly where coercion starts.

I think you're having difficulty with those scenarios only because you have not first defined "coercion". Google gives me this definition:

> the practice of persuading someone to do something by using force or threats.

To clarify my use of the word, and hopefully not completely distort the use of the word I would like to amend the definition as follows:

> the practice of persuading someone to do something by using violence or threats of violence.

When clearly defined it is clear in all of the scenarios you raised, none of them involve coercion.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by asgard1024 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:14PM (#10503126)
> I disagree. As long as you're referring to a non-coerced transaction

If both parties receive the benefit, obviously you can still model that as power exchange where both parties apply their power to the other party. Just like physical forces on an object can be nonzero and yet it stays still. It actually seems like smoother model of social interaction than all the kerfuffle around coercion, but I haven't thought about it in depth.

In reality though, there exist many coerced transactions. For example, I need to eat, and that's why I go to work. I am being coerced by nature. But maybe someone thinks it's better to die in freedom from hunger than to live under coercion with full stomach.

Regarding "political power". What is that? I don't see significant boundary between "political" and "economic" power, but rather smooth transition. Therefore, to me power is power regardless of the social domain where it manifests.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by randomsearch on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @08:42AM (#10499444)
> No matter how you want to dance about it, money are strongly related to power. (To most girls this is probably obvious. :-))

Sorry, could you explain what you mean by that last comment?

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by asgard1024 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @05:20PM (#10503155)
> could you explain

No. I am not in a mood to receive a false accusation of sexism.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by randomsearch on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @07:41AM (#10506066)
I was not going to accuse you of sexism.

Rather, I wanted to understand your world view, because I guessed it might disagree with mine, but listening to other people's POV is a good way to learn and question your own beliefs.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by asgard1024 on Thursday November 05, 2015 @01:40AM (#10511982)
OK, I'll bite.

Most girls/women have a very sensitive detector of social status or it's various proxies, because that's what they sexually select for. (It's kind of similar to how boys/men are attuned to detect physically attractive women.) And many of them are quite self-aware and honest about this capability, and they will confirm that having money is related power and status. Some will even openly admit that they're attracted to wealthy and powerful people.

So I was merely suggesting, if the GP doesn't personally believe there is a strong connection, he should find a honest girl and ask her, she will probably confirm that, it shouldn't be too hard. (Actually, Piketty makes a similar point indirectly by quoting various Jane Austen's works, where people are just obsessed with the question how to marry to wealth).

To clarify, it doesn't mean that men don't want to gain social status; men can do the detection too of course, but it's less of a concern for them, so they're probably less skilled at it (they are interested only indirectly).

Of course, this is not even remotely sexist, because I am not talking about anyone's preferences to begin with. But I was worried that explaining my point could cause derail of the discussion (not necessarily by you).

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by notahacker on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:03AM (#10498984)
Centralisation and expansion of political power /= concentration of it in the hands of the few.

Political power is far less concentrated in a big government elected on a wide franchise which legislates and redistributes in a way not seen as conflicting with the perceived interests of a diverse majority than if wielded through a set of local private or quasi-private enforcement services effectively owned by those with the means to purchase their decisions.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by amelius on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:53AM (#10498936)
The solution, I think, is to make sure that the political process happens completely transparently and with approval of the people. Properly designed IT systems could thus help solve the problem. See: [1][2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-democracy

[2] http://liquidfeedback.org/

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by tankenmate on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:01AM (#10498734)
The problem with this in countries like the US is that money talks, unlimited contributions to PACs and various ways to mask those contributions means that at the very least election media is largely controlled by money. This obviously tilts political favour to those with money to spend.
Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:11AM (#10498770)
Yep, it's a chicken and egg thing, small groups with money -> small groups with political power -> small groups with more money -> small groups with more political power -> etc.

Though other political factors do have a role to play, a dysfunctional two-party political process where many feel disenfranchised may well be the link that explains the graphs for english speaking nations differing from the European nations for example.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by yummyfajitas on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:48AM (#10498908)
Of course, when you look at the biggest sources of rent seeking in the US, they are mostly not protecting the interests of the very wealthy.

Exclusionary zoning, occupational licensing, overpriced government services, these are probably the biggest (in terms of $) examples of rent seeking in the US. These generally favor some middle class and poor folks at the expense of other middle class and poor folks.

If this theory were true, where is the rent seeking?

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by xiaoma on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @03:49AM (#10505319)
How much has Apple paid in taxes as a percentage of revenue (or even profit) over the past 5 years? While the tax system may look progressive at a very superficial level, the richest people or corporations tend not to pay as much in taxes as the middle class does. Even beyond the specifics of the law, the sheer complexity of the law means that only those whose earnings is high enough to justify the cost of a good tax accountant or tax lawyer can get a good rate.

Regulatory complexities in general are also a burden on smaller companies and sole proprietors. Ted Turner described his experience building CNN as one where he was climbing a ladder and seeing the rungs he had just climbed knocked away. Outsiders now simply don't have the ability to handle the regulatory costs of creating the next CNN unless they're already extraordinarily wealthy.

Finally, our banking system is a model of rent-seeking. There are fees charged for doing just about anything with money (borrowing it, lending it, exchanging it for another currency, etc), many of the fees are invisible and once again they are extremely difficult to avoid. Example: how much of the money from YouTube's acquisition went to the financiers? How much do banks make when a tech company IPOs?

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @08:35AM (#10506311)
Rich people pay a disproportionate amount of taxes, and that doesn't even account for taxes paid by corporations they own.

http://taxfoundation.org/blog/no-country-leans-upper-income-...

http://taxfoundation.org/article/new-data-top-1-pay-greater-...

I agree with you about regulatory complexities. But you seem to be going very counter to the narrative - greedy rich people pushing for more regulations to harm incumbents and consumers? So, yay for deregulation?

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by asgard1024 on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @06:16PM (#10503437)
> these are probably the biggest (in terms of $) examples of rent seeking in the US

LOL. You forgot big banks and "too big to fail", military-industrial complex and all the wars.. Your examples are peanuts compared to these.

Re:Income Inequality: Empirical View by yummyfajitas on Tuesday November 03, 2015 @07:34PM (#10503786)
Um, banks and "too big to fail" cost a few billion dollars a few times a century. The most recent bailout was profitable for the treasury.

While I'm not generally a proponent of war or the military, it's hardly clear that these are a large amount of rent seeking compared to the broader economy.