News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by cabalamat on Tuesday January 12, 2010 @06:10PM (#1048813)
> it would be easy to assume clothes bearing that logo are actually a North Face brand

I really, really doubt it. If you believe that, you'd presumably also believe Spinal Tap were real rock group, that Spitting Image was real, and that The Onion is real newspaper.

Re:Humorless "North Face" Sues "South Butt" For Trademark In... by Goladus on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @12:38PM (#1050599)
Trademarks might be expected to get a few seconds of attention at a given moment, much of it subconscious visual processing. In the 5-10 minutes it takes to read an Onion article, almost all people will observe something not right and be motivated to decide whether it's a fake story or not. In the 1 second it takes to observe a trademark on a piece of clothing, most people will not have the motivation to decide whether it's a fake or not.

And even then, the trademarks are still very similar. Even a person looking at them side-by-side can reasonably suggest that the South Butt logo is a humorous sub-brand that comes from The North Face. Often, with Onion articles, you can point to some fact that contradicts fundamental scientific laws and therefore cannot possibly be a true story. Spinal Tap is technically a real band, and while the story told in the movie is fake it is still plausible. I would not be surprised at all if someone saw out-of-context clips of This Is Spinal Tap without knowing what it was, and assumed it was a real documentary.