The interesting trend now is that so many tech companies have dual-class supervoting shares. It sends the message that a few titans of industry basically make all the decisions, and everybody else is along for the ride. Which is probably where we are, economically, right now, but seems disheartening.
Ford was grandfathered in. Berkshire Hathaway only created a second class of stock in 1996, and that was just because Buffett refused to split the stock, and the current price of $215,000 per share (up from $290 in 1980) was inconvenient for small investors.
The Google and Facebook founder-for-life arrangements are unusual, and they're going to lead to trouble for companies whose stock drops and whose management can't be replaced.
[1] http://articles.latimes.com/1986-07-04/business/fi-648_1_vot...
That will be both the problem and solution. Eventually a situation will arise in which the shareholders get burned, and it will be restricted from that point on, either by fiat or refusal of common investors to partake in any offering with this sort of structure.
I invest in companies run by MBAs all of the time. I don't fear them or think they're inherently stupid.
I mean, "tech people" have never failed at running companies, am I right?
So do I. But not if it's a tech growth startup. If you'd replaced Zuckerberg with an MBA in 2006 they would have exited at $1B, pocketed the cash, and moved on.
Well, this is all bizarre speculation..but so what? Then what would have happened to the company? What would the purchaser have done with it? What would Zuckerberg have gone on to build?
Maybe our difference of opinion lies in what we think of Facebook. Personally, I think it's a successful, well-run (so far) company that makes a product that's a vehicle to sell advertising. From that perspective, I don't think it's exactly earth-shattering stuff. I don't even use it.
I think the SEC should be much harder on this gaming of the system its undemocratic and is not in the publics best interest.
It doesn't mean that the non (or lesser) voting shares are priced wrong; in fact, by definition, they are priced at what the market values them.
Also, different classes of shares aren't exactly 'new' or 'unusual'. http://www.slideshare.net/nimishhalkar/a-brief-history-of-pr... claims that the first preferential shares were issued in 1836 (yes, it's a different kind of 'preferential' than what we're talking about, but it's still a species of the genus 'share differentiation') E.g. they're a very common vehicle for structuring profit sharing in several civil law jurisdictions I happen to know of.
The parenthetical in my original comment was important. If everyone thinks they know what is going on, and they're all wrong, then the price isn't a good reflection of reality.
The problem with 2-class voting is that it dilutes the inherent value of non-voting shares in a way that is not reflected in the price. Shares without voting power increase inflation, right? Furthermore, a lot of tech companies have put only a small number of shares on the open market (likely at the recommendation of banks who want demand to support the share price). I guess the company will gradually become more publicly available as employees sell.
I'd be curious to know what portion of public companies have multi-class voting and which ones have only about 10% available as public shares. If these practices are new and rare... something to think about.