News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:31PM (#10475216)
What an ignorant comment. To call Android the "worst currently-shipping security product" is representative of your knowledge on the matter.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by rdl on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:20PM (#10475435)
Within the space of general purpose desktop/mobile operating system products: Windows 10 (pretty good). OS X (not great -- which is a shame). Most Linux distributions (OK to good as shipped, can be great). Most BSD distributions (good to great). iOS (fucking AMAZING). ChromeOS (great, RIP). Windows Phone (honestly don't know much about it). BB OS 10/QNX (great, but irrelevant sadly). And then there's Android.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by ocean3 on Friday October 30, 2015 @01:02AM (#10476233)
Care to explain the reasons? Doesn't windows 10 phone home? The window xp/7 i used previously would inevitability get affected by viruses. I am using Android for last 4 years have not have single virus or even malware problem.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:34PM (#10476025)
This is pretty funny considering Windows is the cause for nearly all of the security exploits that occur. The horror stories of people being infected with viruses, malware and ransomware all have one thing in common - Windows. You only need to look at the thousands of security patches this OS has had applied to it over the years and the new ones applied every month to truly grasp what a sieve it really is. BTW, where are all of the horror stories concerning the Stagefright exploit that so many "pundits/idiots" predicted would be a disaster for Android? I'm still waiting for that.

Also, was there a reason you started referring to specific versions of OS's like Windows 10 and BB OS 10 and then disrespectfully mentioned Android without a version number? Don't you think that was a bit disingenuous, and lame, of you to start mentioning specific OS versions and leave out Android? If you're going to use version numbers then shouldn't you have applied them to all of the OS's you mentioned instead of cherry picking OS versions and then shitting out the line "And then there's Android" at the end?

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by rdl on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:04AM (#10476099)
OK -- Android (until absolute latest) = lovecraftian horror.

Android marshmallow = exceptionally bad.

BB10 is a fundamentally different OS (QNX based) than pre-BB10. but Pre-10 was also a good OS from a security perspective, just utter shit to develop meaningful third party apps for.

Windows...used to be horrible. Big changes around Vista (although, ~unusable). Since Windows 7, it's been "reasonable" in a highly managed corporate environment, and not bad even out of the box. 8, 8.1, and 10 have been improvements on that. It's actually easier to do a 10k user highly locked down Windows deployment (although expensive, and involving a lot of experts and third-party tools) than to do a 10k user locked down Mac OS X deployment. Apple had a lot of advantages by starting from UNIX and from basically starting after security was a "thing", but hasn't done as good a job on OS X security as I'd like. iOS, on the other hand, is amazing -- the only serious deficiencies I find with iOS are a lack of "enterprise as sole root of trust" (which no one does, with the possible exception of (Blackberry Pre-10 and post-10), or roll-your-own open source linux/bsd with a lot of trusted computing grafted on in ways which are not at all trivial to do), and a lack of emphasis on anti-forensics on the device itself -- if you unlock it, it contains an sqllite db with ~every message, which shouldn't be how they do it.

OTOH, on cloud services, Google is far and away superior to Apple. The biggest problem with Apple is you're largely pushed toward iCloud which is not amazing from a security perspective. The true win of ChromeOS was you were equally pushed to the Google ecosystem, which is amazing for cloud service security -- the sole problem being you're 100% exposed to Google, Inc. which is both a US company and a single third-party entity, but if you had to pick a single company to be responsible for your cloud services security, you'd probably pick Google on the merits.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by voltagex_ on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:43AM (#10476196)
Why is Android 6.0 exceptionally horrible? I found one bug in a Play Services API that can crash Play Services remotely, but I can't get code execution so Google aren't interested.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Friday October 30, 2015 @01:06AM (#10476241)
Could you explain why you think Android Marshmallow is "exceptionally bad"? Because I'd really like to know why you think it is. Android gets a bad rap for malware, but it's really a lie perpetuated by people who dislike the platform because they're jealous of its popularity. And even when malware laden apps are sideloaded by people from questionable sites the effects are often minor due to the mitigation strategies employed by Android. Like I said before - where is this pandemic of Android infected phones wreaking havoc? Where are all of the stagefright exploit stories? There's virtually none.

Additionally, Android patches are distributed pretty fast by Google to their phones. It's unfortunate that the OEM's and carriers delay the process for their phones, but Google has no current control over this.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:14AM (#10476373)
Your explanation that Ryan is jealous of Android's popularity doesn't make sense to me. This is a guy that has been working in security for some time, on both ends of the public / private infosec space [1]. Why would he be jealous of Android, but not ChromeOS?

Someone else expounded earlier: "On Android, questionable apps have direct access to the entire kernel system call interface, as well as to other OS features. Personally, I'm not so much upset because Android is uncommonly bad (it's like any other system that gives untrusted users non-root access to Linux: you can probably get away with it, but eh), but because CrOS is uncommonly good."

I don't think it's reasonable to ask for pointers on how to root an Android device in a public forum, and the size of the attack surface seems to me like a rather reasonable measure of a system's security.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Lackey

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by ocean3 on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:34AM (#10476400)
A explanation would be better. What is CrOS? edit: got it ChromeOS
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:44AM (#10476430)
Chrome OS.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:53AM (#10476451)
Please, I did not specifically say this person was jealous of Android's popularity. I simply stated that the impetus for people who denigrate Android are generally people that are jealous of the platform's success and try to knock it down a few notches. Also, Android apps are sandboxed and each app is isolated in its own directory. Additionally, could you please cite how these "questionable apps have direct access to the entire kernel system call interface"? If Android apps want to access system functionality then I believe they have to go through a layer of Android framework services which in turn have access to the real kernel system calls.

As for the size of the attack surface being a factor - I agree, but with the exception of QNX and its microkernel (which has issues of its own) pretty much every other monolithic kernel based OS also has a large attack surface so I'm not exactly sure what point you're trying to make other than the obvious.

>Personally, I'm not so much upset because Android is uncommonly bad (it's like any other system that gives untrusted users non-root access to Linux: you can probably get away with it, but eh), but because CrOS is uncommonly good."

Chrome does have great sandboxing, but don't disparage Android just because it works like 99% of the other OS's out there. And I wouldn't be surprised if Android inherits some of Chrome's sandboxing tech when the two merge because I think it's pretty much inevitable that it will.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by castis on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:22PM (#10475607)
rdl works on security at CloudFlare. What do you do?
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by scintill76 on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:54AM (#10476218)
OK, this is one of those times where infosec people get annoyingly close to "appealing to authority." So far 'rdl has said Android is "the worst currently-shipping security product", "[Blah blah blah], and then there's Android", "Android (until absolute latest) = lovecraftian horror" but the latest is upgraded to "exceptionally bad", and a deeply-nested subcomment about running every task on a separate machine (which I'm sure ChromeOS does... /s) But who needs to hear logical arguments? When the guy from CloudFlare speaks, the thinking is done!

Alright, as something of an Android fanboy it pains me to admit, he probably has a point in this case. But it'd be nice to hear about what specifically is wrong, especially since it would seem there's a fair bit right, like SELinux, automatic encryption, ASLR. The worst thing in my view, is the permissions system, which is probably salvageable (and as I understand it, was improved in Marshmallow.) 'rdl has given more details about pretty much every imaginable system but Android -- are we supposed to just assume Android does every bad thing he mentioned, and the opposite of every good thing?

Edit: I could almost let this slide since the particular counter-comment was equally vacuous. It's still annoying to see "security guy from $BIG_CO => GTFO" (who is apparently smarter than all the security people at Google who've worked on Android, but we just have to take your word for it since you didn't elaborate.)

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by chetanahuja on Friday October 30, 2015 @01:51AM (#10476332)
OK, this is one of those times where infosec people get annoyingly close to "appealing to authority."

This. It's not just "close to" appealing to authority, it's straight up appealing to authority. And yes, it's a common practice in the infosec community. The whole security industry is built on a reputation system. It pays to remember that the number of exploits and vulnerabilities etc. in commonly used software that are reported on practically a daily basis came out of the same reputation based system.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:00AM (#10476348)
In another comment, he says "user/process/thread security in UNIX/POSIX/etc. is bullshit weak sauce, sadly."

Geofft expounds some more: On Android, questionable apps have direct access to the entire kernel system call interface, as well as to other OS features. Personally, I'm not so much upset because Android is uncommonly bad (it's like any other system that gives untrusted users non-root access to Linux: you can probably get away with it, but eh), but because CrOS is uncommonly good.

I'm not sure if these are related, nor how iOS avoids it. The answer is probably in here: https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf

FWIW, I've heard Googlers familiar with it refer to Android as a pile of crap, as well.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by scintill76 on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:39AM (#10476420)
> he says "user/process/thread security in UNIX/POSIX/etc. is bullshit weak sauce, sadly."

Android's security indeed relies on UNIX's (filesystem permissions, separate UIDs for each app), but he praised OSX and iOS (I think) for starting from UNIX[0], so it would be inconsistent to also damn Android for it (which I don't think he necessarily did, since dissing UNIX security was in a different context.) From skimming the iOS security guide (and having no iOS dev experience) it looks like it's similar: "The majority of iOS runs as the non-privileged user “mobile,” as do all third-party apps" -- although being BSDish vs Android's Linux could mean that's quite different.

> On Android, questionable apps have direct access to the entire kernel system call interface, as well as to other OS features... because CrOS is uncommonly good.

So CrOS has the advantage because I guess it does not allow running untrusted native code at all, containing things entirely in interpreted/JIT'd VMs. That would be a good point... except every other OS 'rdl esteems higher than Android (Windows, OSX, iOS, Blackberry) probably also runs native code with full access to syscalls (making some assumptions here, but I think it's reasonable that to whatever extent 'geofft's statement about Android is true, it applies fairly uniformly to the rest.) So, why are they good or even just OK, but Android is horribad?

I'm not sure I'm actually addressing arguments 'rdl would have made about Android -- but that's the point, he didn't really say anything that can be argued!

> FWIW, I've heard Googlers familiar with it refer to Android as a pile of crap, as well.

Yeah, it's probably true -- I wasn't saying "Google made it, so it must be good", but underlining the fallacy in relying on a prestigious company association as proof of merit. Android probably didn't have the best talent when it started in 2003 and is now painted into a corner of backwards-compatibility and a huge codebase that would be risky to revamp all at once. I guess my favorite aspect of Android is really just that it's open-source-ish and has enough critical mass to be useful (as opposed to Firefox OS and Ubuntu at the moment) -- so if ChromiumOS were to become the new AOSP as some are speculating, sounds good to me.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10476099

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by digi_owl on Friday October 30, 2015 @05:12PM (#10480562)
To speculate a bit, he seem to favor iOS above all else because:

A) its BSD (Torvalds have offended a sizable part of the -sec community by not highlighting security updates in release notes)

B) it is locked down by default, to the point that there is not even a common storage area for files (this "blew up" in Android a while back because some big name messaging app was dumb enough to put unencrypted user data in exactly such a common area).

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Friday October 30, 2015 @03:42AM (#10476561)
Good points. I think bullshit weak sauce is busllshit weak sauce regardless of context. If you don't trust it on a server, why should you on your phone?

The comparison between Android and iOS is especially curious, in part because it's such a competitive space, and also because rdl's opinions varied so extremely.

Both OS X and iOS are based on Darwin, which also suggests vulnerabilities in kernel calls are not what rdl had in mind. When his latest startup was acquired, the blog post [1] described a part of it as:

> Beyond the company’s work in VPNs, CryptoSeal applied Trusted Computing technology to commodity servers, protecting them from compromise by outsider attackers or insider subversion, and guaranteeing the integrity of server-side applications to remote end users.

Perhaps something about the hardware iOS runs on is what impressed him so?

1. https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-acquires-cryptoseal/

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Friday October 30, 2015 @03:09AM (#10476482)
>FWIW, I've heard Googlers familiar with it refer to Android as a pile of crap, as well.

Have you see the CVE iOS database? If "Android is a pile of crap" then I can only imagine what iOS must be.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Friday October 30, 2015 @10:54AM (#10478153)
"There are security bugs" does not mean "pile of crap". Everything has security bugs. The question is how bad they are and how much it costs to buy a zero-day / the use of a zero-day.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:30PM (#10479610)
I agree that everything has security bugs. It's pretty much inevitable. But, one platform has nearly 5.5 times the security issues of the other. So, if you're using security issues to correlate what a "pile of crap" is than you need not look further than iOS.

iOS: 749 Vulnerabilities http://www.cvedetails.com/product/15556/Apple-Iphone-Os.html...

Android: 138 Vulnerabilities http://www.cvedetails.com/product/19997/Google-Android.html?...

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Monday November 02, 2015 @02:55PM (#10494672)
Oh, interesting stats. Thanks for linking those!
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by Oletros on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:46AM (#10476436)
> rdl works on security at CloudFlare. What do you do?

The he can give reasons about his comments.

until now, they sound just like hatred and nothing more.

Appealing to authority is always a bad thing without any arguments backing the claims

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by andreyf on Friday October 30, 2015 @10:58AM (#10478176)
> until now, they sound just like hatred and nothing more.

Or perhaps advice given based on non-public information.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by Oletros on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:06AM (#10478244)
Sure
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bitmapbrother on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:08PM (#10475951)
I'm a developer at one of the world's biggest computer companies. And you?