News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by dchuk on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:10PM (#10465223)
Isn't this sort of a cake-and-eat-it-too situation? If you want a slim, lightweight laptop that still performs at a high level, you can't expect the old pop out batteries with the little switch we grew up with on laptops.

While $400 is expensive to replace a battery, it's obviously not as simple as just popping a new one in, which is the compromise one has to make if they want a Macbook Pro. If you want easily swappable batteries, get a different machine.

Also, $400 to get a brand new battery to essentially revive a computer that will probably work great for a few more years is a whole lot cheaper than having to buy a new computer. Just food for thought.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by andrelaszlo on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:17PM (#10465294)
Is this a trade-off that most buyers are aware of? I'm not sure it's as simple as "shaving off a couple of millimeters", but if that's the case I know I would personally trade those millimeters for better serviceability, especially the day I realize I need a new battery.

I was thinking about switching to a Macbook Pro, but for me this is just another argument to go with something else.

Can't deny that the hardware is great though, but to me this makes it less great. I had my last laptop for 8 years because I could replace broken parts myself, and upgrade to an SSD, I think that's a nice feature of the hardware too.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tptacek on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:19PM (#10465320)
They've dedicated whole chunks of keynotes to talking about how the new batteries are integrated with the chassis. Obviously, most of their customers don't care, but then: you can say that about this story too! Most people just take their laptops back to the Apple Store when they want anything changed.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by jacobr1 on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:34PM (#10465481)
> Most people just take their laptops back to the Apple Store when they want anything changed.

Yep, and this would still be true if the laptop was more serviceable. Most people don't change the oil on their car either even if it relatively easy. In fact most people don't even put air in the tires and instead rely on getting that done during quarterly oil changes!

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tptacek on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @06:54PM (#10467998)
If you could make a car more fuel-efficient, faster, or less polluting by making it difficult to change the oil yourself, that would be a valid tradeoff. Maybe you'd keep buying Volkswagens so you could enjoy the DIY, but it would be weird to try to make a consumers rights case out of the manufacturer who took the other side of that tradeoff!
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by rayiner on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:31PM (#10465448)
Apple tends to use the space savings to stuff in class-leading batteries.

I have a T450s at work. The stock battery is only 46 watt-hours, versus 75 on the similarly-sized 13" rMBP. The 15" rMBP has a 100 watt-hour battery, which you can get on a T550s only if you buy the extended battery that sticks out half an inch from the bottom.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by slantyyz on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:57PM (#10465681)
>> Apple tends to use the space savings to stuff in class-leading batteries.

But can you imagine how big the batteries could be in a 15" MBP that was roughly the same size as those from 2012 and earlier? Those things would last even longer than a current 15" rMBP would, especially under load.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by freehunter on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:50PM (#10465627)
Hey those extended batteries make great handles.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tjr on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:26PM (#10465388)
I would personally trade those millimeters for better serviceability

Same here. I've been a dedicated Mac user since 2002, and have been contemplating upgrading my 2010 MBP. The decreasing serviceability gives me lengthy pause, though I'm not sure that I would be happier with something else (even if it were more serviceable).

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by slantyyz on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:42PM (#10465552)
The primary driver to me switching from Mac to Windows was the lack of serviceability in newer models. That and the fact that my 2011 MBP bricked (famous heat issues that Apple pretended didn't exist until after I bought a replacement laptop).

I loved, loved, loved the 15" unibody Macbook Pro design. It allowed me to upgrade to better components (RAM, SSDs) as prices came down. The only thing I felt was missing from my 2011 MBP was USB 3. Once the shift was made to thinner bodies and soldered-on RAM, the writing was on the wall for me.

Personally, after using OSX on Intel for a decade, I found that moving to Windows 8.1 and now 10 was not nearly as jarring as I thought it would be. Windows isn't the XP I remembered using. I actually like using Windows. The one thing I really like is touchscreens on Windows PCs. Of course, depending on your preferences (and/or biases), going to Windows may not be for you.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by freehunter on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:49PM (#10465615)
I always had the opinion that I would never buy a computer that wasn't able to be serviced by me and I would build my own desktops and buy Thinkpads. Then I realized that I never did any upgrades anyway, if the battery died, the laptop was usually ready to be replaced. If the CPU or memory needed to be upgraded, usually it was both, and there was probably a new technology (new socket, new type of DDR, etc). And I realized I hated dealing with my desktop, hated troubleshooting and fixing and buying replacement parts and stuffing it all together and scraping my knuckles on the case...

As soon as I realized this, I said "to hell with it" and bought a Macbook. I don't need the downsides to having a serviceable laptop if I never actually perform any service on it.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by MBCook on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:27PM (#10465401)
More and more PC laptops are moving to the same model. There are a lot of benefits for the manufacturer. Fewer parts (less $ to make), less to break (less support $), can make the laptop thinner and lighter (so you can charge more $), the battery no longer has to be a easy to use shape (have you seen Apple's tapered layers of thin batteries?), extra engineering costs, etc.

There are people who really like/want removable batteries but it doesn't seem to be enough to keep most of the market supplying them. And now that laptops use less power little juice packs (not unlike those for cellphones) become reasonable. Plus in general removable batteries made a lot of sense when basic typing would only get you 3 or 4 hours, but now that many machines can do basic typing for 10+ hours a ton of users can get by without needing that second battery.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by bildung on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:52PM (#10465648)
> More and more PC laptops are moving to the same model. There are a lot of benefits for the manufacturer. Fewer parts (less $ to make), less to break (less support $), can make the laptop thinner and lighter (so you can charge more $), the battery no longer has to be a easy to use shape (have you seen Apple's tapered layers of thin batteries?), extra engineering costs, etc.

Conveniently, built-in batteries also harm the resale value of a used device.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by cdubzzz on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:27PM (#10465399)
> I know I would personally trade those millimeters for better serviceability, especially the day I realize I need a new battery.

Eh, does any non-tech savy person really care about anything outside of size and weight? And maybe "speed", hah.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by RBerenguel on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:48PM (#10466053)
My previous Macbook (early 2008 white, plastic one) lasted for 5 years, no issue. Battery was fine (slowly dying as all batteries, but no big deal, it just wouldn't last as long as it used to.) Then I got a message about the battery actually dying (get to service, the white early 2008 has user-replaceable battery, though.) But it was already the time I needed a more powerful computer, and I just got a new one and removed the battery of the old one (it still works perfectly fine, no longer as a portable though.) I don't expect a computer (i.e. all pieces together) to serve me for more than 4-5 years, so this battery life is more than I can expect. Of course, if it was a system I could tinker and slowly replace piece by piece, it could but I no longer feel the tradeoff of money/abilities/time is worth it.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by branchan on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @07:54PM (#10468286)
I expect the consumers to do adequate research before plunking down over a grand on a new laptop.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by consto on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:37PM (#10465516)
I don't expect to be able to pop a switch, but there is a difference between integrating the battery with the chassis and gluing the battery, keyboard and logic board together in a way that makes the laptop extremely difficult to service.

From what I can tell, to replace the battery on my year old lenovo ultrabook, you need to remove 16 easily accessible cross screws and disconnect a single ribbon cable. That shouldn't take more than 5 minutes. I guess there could be glue hiding under there.

Not to mention it continues to last up to 10 hours on a single charge.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by rasz_pl on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:50PM (#10465631)
It is not difficult to service .. by a service person. It is simply not user serviceable.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by dkonofalski on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @07:20PM (#10468114)
Except that even that's not true. You can service it yourself for pretty cheap by getting a kit from iFixIt. It's just that you need a Torx screwdriver (which comes in the kit). It's absolutely user-serviceable if you have the right tools.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by rasz_pl on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:33AM (#10471260)
Absolutely NOT. You will hear same thing about iphone battery replacement - just get iFixit kit and diy. What happens is people dont know how to work with glue and try to pry it open ripping 0201 parts off the boards edge.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by redidas on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:19PM (#10465319)
Personally, I'd rather have a few extra mm of thickness and batteries that are not glued to a keyboard. Efforts could be made to keep this tech more repairable.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tptacek on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:21PM (#10465337)
Speak for yourself. I want a thin laptop that feels almost like a slab of mysteriously lightweight solid aluminum, and Apple is delivering that.

It's not like this was a cost-saving measure for them; they're not pulling one over on you. They went nuts trying to make these things solid, lightweight, and skinny, and this was a tradeoff they made --- at significant expense.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by 51Cards on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:09PM (#10466190)
" --- at significant expense."

Which is being directly passed on to the client along with an extra slice of profit making. Brilliant but not so nice if you're the client.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by zzleeper on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:35PM (#10465494)
It reminds me of printer sales or high-fee consumer credits.. they benefit from consumer myopia about the future. There's even a lot of literature about that:

https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/4554333/Laibson_...

In this case, I'm guessing many people that are not that well-off still buy macs but don't really realize the future repair costs..

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by oldmanjay on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:13PM (#10465823)
Does it remind you of buying nearly everything? Do you think the average consumer decides to buy a home appliance or a television based on the possibility of providing user service at reduced rates?
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by Bud on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:43PM (#10465556)
"Efforts could be made"? Which passive-voice efforts do you mean, specifically? Apple has designed their battery to be made up of several curved units that take up all available airspace in the case, and those have to be secured in place somehow, so that they don't rattle around like cheap PCs. Screws are not a realistic solution here because of obvious strictures from the design. A simple one-piece replaceable battery design is simply no longer feasible in this form factor.

So if you think it'd be trivial to make this more repairable, you need to say precisely how.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by rasz_pl on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:51PM (#10465638)
good for you, HP and DELL are ready to take orders.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by p0wnd on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:27PM (#10465411)
Great, you can buy a chunky ass hp laptop and enjoy that big ol paperweight all you want.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tracker1 on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:58PM (#10466131)
I had a C2D based MBP that I absolutely loved... the drive, ram and battery were user serviceable, and the form factor wasn't that much bigger than my current i7 based MBP. In fact if the original weren't stolen, I'd still be using it.

BTW, $400 comes pretty close to buying a new laptop nearly as capable as a 2 year old machine.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:36PM (#10465509)
> If you want easily swappable batteries, get a different machine.

Apple doesn't make a different machine.

Obviously what you mean is to buy from a different vendor, which is what I expect to do when the time comes for a new laptop. But how is it good for Apple that they got my money last time and won't get it next time?

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by freehunter on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:56PM (#10465673)
Judging by the increase in sales year over year for the Macbooks, it doesn't seem like it's bad for Apple. How many sales has Apple gained by making the laptop thinner and lighter and giving it a longer battery life compared to sales lost from not making a few parts user-replaceable?
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:21PM (#10465875)
> Judging by the increase in sales year over year for the Macbooks...

...you get a number that tracks the economy in general and the consumption of luxury electronics in particular, is affected by the relative strength of Apple's ecosystem against Microsoft and Google, how badly Superfish has affected Lenovo's reputation, etc. etc.

And in any event the numbers aren't particularly optimistic:

http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2015/10/08/apple-mac-sales-slow-...

> How many sales has Apple gained by making the laptop thinner and lighter and giving it a longer battery life compared to sales lost from not making a few parts user-replaceable?

We don't even have all the data yet. Customers don't realize they want a user-serviceable battery until they've had to replace one that isn't. Apple started selling glued batteries three years ago, which means they're only starting to have to be replaced now and the largest effect will be seen going forward when the people affected are buying new laptops.

But you're asking the wrong question anyway. The interesting question is: What would their sales look like if they had both ultra lightweight models and slightly heavier models with user-serviceable parts?

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by Recurecur on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:39PM (#10465988)
"And in any event the numbers aren't particularly optimistic"

The article is stating that the rate of growth (still positive) for Macs slowed somewhat.

The same article states:

"Apple nonetheless outperformed the overall PC market, which saw shipments plummet 11% to 71 million for the quarter, according to IDC. Moreover, given the worse performance of other PC makers, its market share rose to 7.6% in 2015 from 6.9% last year, according to Gartner."

That looks decidedly optimistic to me!

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:02PM (#10466152)
This is exactly what I'm talking about. The "overall PC market" is very different from Apple's market segment:

http://gizmodo.com/5033865/study-average-mac-computer-price-...

You might as well compare sales of Macs to sales of office furniture or canned beets.

The information you want is the effect of the battery/case design on Mac sales. The only way to get that is to exclude the effect of everything else that has changed in the interim, which we can't.

In other words the data we want is not available and the available data is not overwhelmingly positive.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by efaref on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:09PM (#10465789)
If you try to please everyone, you'll please no-one. Most people, certainly most Apple customers, don't care that the battery is not replaceable. In fact, it works in their favour as they can use the failing battery as justification for getting a shiny new MacBook Pro in a few years' time.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:38PM (#10465980)
> If you try to please everyone, you'll please no-one.

How is that supposed to provide any support for Apple's one size fits all approach?

> Most people, certainly most Apple customers, don't care that the battery is not replaceable. In fact, it works in their favour as they can use the failing battery as justification for getting a shiny new MacBook Pro in a few years' time.

How is incurring an expense of several hundred dollars (or reducing the resale value by that amount) supposed to work in the customer's favor? It seems the customer could achieve the same "benefit" by smashing it with a hammer.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by yeukhon on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:15PM (#10465271)
Depends. These days with hardware failure rate becoming higher (maybe it's just an illusion due to the ability of providing feedback on the Internet, but I argue that most of the old machines I know still work today but not so many with the more recent one), the next victim can be your SSD. Apple does get some good SSD from Samsung though. The benefit of a lock-down is controlling variable, and placing Apple at a higher standard (I hope they still do for software). Raising the bar so fewer people are able to customize computer helps controlling quality and also prevent wasting time on figuring out if problem was caused by foreign hardware's fault or not.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by relaxatorium on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:18PM (#10465307)
At the risk of being "cites articles about cognitive biases guy", it's worth remembering that the reason that the old machines you know today still work is because people have generally gotten rid of all the old machines that are broken (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias)
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by yeukhon on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:39PM (#10465533)
Absolutely. I really don't have anything scientific but my really unscientific reasoning is that, even if my observation is true, the reason behind it are mass production and the ease of replacement. when you do DOA you usually get a replacement fairly quickly online. Unlike in 2000, you can get computer parts entirely online now, though computer parts are still very expensive (the good one).
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by tptacek on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:18PM (#10465306)
I've been nothing but Apple laptops since 2001, when I ran Yellow Dog Linux on a TiBook, and co-ran a company with ~40 people all using MBPs, and my experience is that Apple hardware is getting significantly more reliable than it was before.

I think the effect you're seeing is just that more people are using Apple computers than were even 5 years ago, and so there's just more feedback to read.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by yeukhon on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:33PM (#10465462)
For the old ones, I am referring to non-Apple machines.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by venomsnake on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:21PM (#10466281)
> If you want a slim, lightweight laptop that still performs at a high level, you can't expect the old pop out batteries with the little switch we grew up with on laptops.

I can actually expect that. Apple have good enough designers to do so. But lack of serviceability for them is a feature, not a bug. Apple is pushing for rented hardware as a service in consumer space. Repairable, tweak-able or modifiable device is contrary to their goals.

Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by stevesearer on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:18PM (#10465300)
Agree. My older Macbook Pro basically has a dead battery and I'm thinking about just replacing the battery and swapping the hard drive for an ssd to give it some new life. That said, it is used primarily at the house so we just plug it in to watch some netflix and browse the web or pull up a recipe for dinner, so it isn't that big of an issue in the first place for my purposes.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by giarc on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:26PM (#10465396)
A SSD and some ram upgrade can do wonders for an older machine (and price is pretty reasonable for both these days). You can even get kits that allow you to take out your 'superdrive' and install a second hard drive.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by MBCook on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:28PM (#10465417)
Yep. I'm still using a 2010 MBP. I maxed out the RAM a few years ago and it performed better. Now I've got an SSD in it and it feels like new. Almost nothing I do pushes it so I simply have no good reason to replace it. If I hadn't put the SSD in I would have replaced it two+ years ago because it felt slow.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by gambiting on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:35PM (#10465482)
I'm actually still using a 2009 MacBook Pro(core2duo+4gb ram), I put in a Kingston 128GB SSD and the machine runs El Capitan without any problem. I keep it permanently on as a kitchen PC, for looking up recipes and stuff.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by Eric_WVGG on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:23PM (#10465367)
I’ve had outstanding luck with DIY fusion drives. A cheap 64gb SSD can be had for under $50 and is more than adequate.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by n1000 on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:34PM (#10465478)
Once the battery is completely dead the CPU will throttle however.
Re:The Nightmare of Replacing a Battery on a Mac Laptop by alistairSH on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:51PM (#10466083)
If you want easily swappable batteries, get a different machine.

Does Apple make a user-serviceable laptop these days? I suppose you could switch to PC, but that's not as simple as spending your $3000 at BestBuy instead of the Apple store.