Re:Rackspace vs. EC2: Performance Analysis
by pquerna on Monday January 11, 2010 @04:35PM
(#1046087)
its a decent enough test, mostly because most geeks out there have done it themselves, so you can get a good 'feel' for a machine by knowing how long it takes to compile the kernel.
its not perfect, and yeah, its kinda a geeky-benchmark, but it doesn't make it an invalid benchmark, as long as it was conducted correctly.
Re:Rackspace vs. EC2: Performance Analysis
by allertonm on Monday January 11, 2010 @04:45PM
(#1046105)
I consider myself a geek (and most of my friends would agree) but it's been 15 years since I last compiled the Linux kernel :)
That said, I wouldn't rule it out as a test because of that, but I do think that if you are going to compare 4 different RAM sizes of CS instances, and compare the costs of doing a job using those different sizes then you need to pick a job that is going to make use of the RAM. You can see from the results that there is a small (time) benefit moving from 256 to 512MB (but not enough to offset the increased costs) and virtually none above that.
In addition, it doesn't seem like compiling the linux kernel requires very much RAM, so you get the most bang for your buck using a CS VM with only 256MB and the cost only goes up from there as you add more RAM that the test cannot benefit from.
(Edit: I would love whoever downmodded me to explain why I am wrong.)