Further, the business could decide to buy the tools, supplies, and provide the plumber's van. In exchange for providing all these supplies (which are deductible for the business), there's a strong argument that the salary due the plumber is less than if he had to provide all those tools himself.
There's a fair amount of flexibility in determining how much of the total is salary and how much is dividends and that's why there's "nothing wrong" with the first example when properly applied. Saying a plumber worked 100 jobs for a penny-per-job is not reasonable, but there is a broad range of reasonable.
To put it in our field, suppose I had the fortune to create the next modest sized thing that was purchased by Facebook for $10MM in cash. Suppose that a team of 2 of us (me and one other) created this over a 1 year period and it was 100% funded by me (no VC, no angel, etc). Suppose that I paid the other person $200K salary for their efforts. How should the remaining $9,800,000 be divided on my tax return? Surely you wouldn't argue that my "salary" was $9,800,000, but rather my salary should be $200K and I should receive the $9,600,000 as non-salary compensation (capital gains in this case, presumably, but not W-2 salary).
Now why people need to resort to these practices to get more fair share of their brutto income is completely different topic, something around "voting with your taxes" about how public cash is spent (usually pretty badly). FYI, I don't do it anymore, got a perm job, but when I was doing consulting this way, I had all the possible support of my local tax office when something was unclear.
Finding a bright line differentiation between formation of a company for "legitimate" (what does that even mean?) reasons vs. tax avoidance/optimization is likely impossible. It's quite likely that even pursuing this in legislation would only result in a net loss due to regulatory burden etc. without any real gain.
If you ask about the schemes, the advisor will openly tell you they expect a ruling, ie there is some contention about whether it's actually legal.
A doctor typically has a staff, or may want to have the ability to sell the practice later on. If you make $600,000 a year, why should you have to pay 40-45% tax on that income when $250k will be invested back into the business anyway? Why should you be compelled to subject your spouse and children to the liability of the business?
A real estate investor will often setup LLCs to isolate the liability associated with one property from the overall portfolio. Again, a legit business use.
Obviously there are abuses here, but the fundamental concept isn't wrong. Typically the abuses are when there isn't a bona-fide business. Some financial dude setting up a shell company for his bonus is an example of a questionable use of this approach in my book. When a person sets up a chain of shell companies to obfuscate the ownership or transfer of assets, that's obviously crossing the line into money laundering territory!
Theoretically, a dividend is a share of the profit generated by the business. Salary is payment for labor rendered. They both exist for different reasons.
Personally, I also think that any dividends and capital gains should be taxed equally, or more, than salary, but that's a different topic.
If by "fair" you mean we all pay a roughly equal amount, then I'm cool with that.
If by "fair" you mean that people who are more productive contribute a greater share of that production to the pot to achieve the social justice goals of others, then that's where I think there is room for debate.
I understand the arguments for progressive taxation and I'm not advocating against them, but when you look at taxation in the western world (particularly in the USA) you see a steady rise in use of tax funds to insulate people from negative outcomes that derive primarily from their personal choices.
I'm all for freedom of choice. I'm less for "you pay for my stuff" because I made a choice to pursue a life that doesn't contribute to the general welfare of the country, now or in the future.
I know people will downvote this post, but I know I'm not alone in my thinking.
- In most countries you can set yourself up as a company. This means you can write off certain things and adjust the proportion of revenue that ends up as salary, which has implications for various types of tax. For instance in the UK NHS contributions are dependent on salary, so you can give yourself a minimal salary and lots of dividends. This is a pretty standard play, probably done by everyone in the country who has a business, eg. doctors and plumbers. I don't think there's anything wrong with this.
- At some point a guy will phone you. He finds your name on lists of likely people. He shows up at your office draws you a box diagram of corporations, with lots of little arrows. He quotes tax legal terms you won't understand, but they are always some sort of loophole. In one case I was offered to do a company with P Diddy (or whatever he's called now) in which I was to critique his new music. I had to produce evidence that I'd spent at least 10 hours a week or so on this. Now keep in mind I can't even read sheet music, have zero appreciation of Diddy's genre, and generally have no interest in him as a musician. I suppose this was mutual, as I've never heard of him being associated with quantitative developers either.
- A friend told me about what he'd been offered. Along similar lines, he'd been told there was an opening in poetry. Another box diagram with arrows, and it boils down to that you can get a tax benefit if you publish your own book of poetry. The guy in question was an old school Essex local (shoutey trader). I doubt he'd spent much time reading Sylvia Plath. So anyway, the organisers had all their City connections write crappy (who am I to judge?) poetry, print up a few hundred books, and distribute it to everyone.
- I never did any of these last two schemes. If something sounds ridiculous, you know it's a tax dodge. They tend to end up in court, where they are decided on arcane points if tax law, eating up the productive time of many people. If it goes wrong, you lose the money, a long while after you thought you had it. If it goes right, you are abusing the law in some sense. The other way you can tell is there are some plays every accountant in the whole country will tell you. Other will require a somewhat more entrepreneurial accountant, one that requires a sales operation.