News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A sociologist on the international wealth-management prof... by sokoloff on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:33PM (#10459142)
In the plumber's case, he's created two kinds of value: one, from his direct labor on jobs, "ought" to be paid out in salary. The other, inherent in the operation of the business itself (markup on equipment sold, face value of service contracts sold, etc) is value created by the business, and profits not retained "ought" to be paid out as dividends to the owner (the owner just happens to be the same guy).

Further, the business could decide to buy the tools, supplies, and provide the plumber's van. In exchange for providing all these supplies (which are deductible for the business), there's a strong argument that the salary due the plumber is less than if he had to provide all those tools himself.

There's a fair amount of flexibility in determining how much of the total is salary and how much is dividends and that's why there's "nothing wrong" with the first example when properly applied. Saying a plumber worked 100 jobs for a penny-per-job is not reasonable, but there is a broad range of reasonable.

To put it in our field, suppose I had the fortune to create the next modest sized thing that was purchased by Facebook for $10MM in cash. Suppose that a team of 2 of us (me and one other) created this over a 1 year period and it was 100% funded by me (no VC, no angel, etc). Suppose that I paid the other person $200K salary for their efforts. How should the remaining $9,800,000 be divided on my tax return? Surely you wouldn't argue that my "salary" was $9,800,000, but rather my salary should be $200K and I should receive the $9,600,000 as non-salary compensation (capital gains in this case, presumably, but not W-2 salary).

There are no comments on this comment yet.