News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by dredmorbius on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:00PM (#10453608)
The point that it's organisational and management issues which so frequently seem to be behind major disasters -- four of the larger nuclear accidents (Fukushima, the earlier Japanese criticality incident at Tokaimura, Chernobyl, Three Mile Island), as well as numerous other large-scale industrial accidents, of which energy systems play a large role: the BP Gulf Oil spill, Exxon Valdez, Banqiao Dam (China, 1975), recent South Carolina flooding and dam bursts, the Union Carbide Bhopal, India, disaster.

You cannot engineer out human nature. This isn't a root cause for which there are technical solutions.

I hugely recommend Charles Perrow's Normal Accidents and The Next Catastrophe. As well as other writings.

Note that Rickover also wished we'd never gone to the nuclear option. He defended his choice for lack of options, but would have preferred to see all plants mothballed.

"Paper Reactors", which you quote in part, is excellent.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by ars on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:02PM (#10454453)
> You cannot engineer out human nature. This isn't a root cause for which there are technical solutions.

Have you heard the saying: In the future they will be staffed by a man and a dog. The man to feed the dog, and the dog to bark at the man in case he tries to touch anything.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by dredmorbius on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:54PM (#10454753)
I have. Frequently when making comments similar to those above ;-)

(The dog is doing his job....)

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by eropple on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:07PM (#10453656)
I have to second Perrow's Normal Accidents. I read it first in college and I've kept my copy sitting on my desk ever since as a reminder. (I joke-not-joke that, if I ever run a startup, every employee gets a copy on their first day.)
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by Retric on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:16PM (#10453719)
You cannot engineer out human nature.

You can do a lot to minimize the effects of human nature or even utilize it. You just need to build systems for humans not some abstract ideal. Case in point, the giant Menu inside a fast food restaurant has a lot of counter intuitive properties designed to alter people’s behavior. It's not pretty, but it works. Note, we are talking about the masses of humanity not just those you select or train etc.

Now, doing the same for complex systems is hard. But, clearly there are ways to improve.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by dredmorbius on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:00PM (#10454801)
You can engineer to influence human nature. But often the task is, as you highlight, to take existing tendencies and influence them. Fast food, and consumer marketplaces generally, are highly engineered to prompt desired behaviors. Those generally aren't, though, very high reliability error-correcting behaviors.

Some other examples that come to mind:

1. Public spaces designed to be "riot proof". Generally this works by avoiding single large assembly points, putting entrances and exits such that there's no through transit of a space or building, and otherwise dispersing the energy of crowds.

2. Las Vegas. The manipulation is so grossly apparent to me that the entire place disgusts me. Windowless interiors, no clocks, bright lights and flashing displays, loud music. And, most iconically: moving walkways to take you into casinos, but having to depart under your own power.

3. Much of air safety practices. While it's not possible to design out pilot (or other human) error, you can become highly aware of what leads to accidents. The commercial air travel industry is a fascinating study in risk reduction, starting with the goal of incident studies, which is to ascertain cause, not assign blame.

Perrow goes into this in depth in his books.