News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by cm2187 on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:00AM (#10451437)
The difference with Uber is that it requires a lot more trust to give someone access to your home while you're away to clean it. Not sure I would want to subscribe to a service where I would have to trust any local dude to visit my home. It's like a nanny. Picking someone to look after your kid is a very personal thing. It's not a lowest bidder thing.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by forgetsusername on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:04AM (#10451464)
>The difference with Uber is that it requires a lot more trust to give someone access to your home while you're away to clean it.

In one case you're risking personal items and privacy; in the other your life is actually in that person's hands.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by philh on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:17AM (#10451569)
With a driver, your life is in the hands of someone who has nothing to gain from getting in a car crash. With a cleaner, your possessions are in the hands of someone who might have plenty of incentive to steal your stuff and sell it.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 26, 2015 @07:38PM (#10455252)
Have a bit of imagination, there's got to be plenty of ways for a driver to exploit you being in their car for criminal profit too. Provide wifi and slurp data; kidnap you; notify an accomplice that you've left the house empty and it's ripe for burglary; clone a payment card (and/or steal a pin) when you pay; take your DNA to plant at a crime scene for blackmail purposes ... erm, what else, clearly I'm not nefarious enough ...
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by CamperBob2 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:43AM (#10456733)
If this sort of thing were common, I'd hear about it.

On the other hand, home burglaries are so common they don't even make the local news.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:28AM (#10451645)
This casual assumption that all housekeepers are thieves is galling. Its a kind of working-class bigotry that is tossed around by the entitled without even noticing they are doing it.

Of course folks have plenty of incentive to not steal - they have self-respect.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by rhino369 on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:18AM (#10451981)
Almost all maids won't steal, but it's a great cover for thieves who want access to houses. You can't know which is which unless you get a good recommendation or hire the person and test it out.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by nommm-nommm on Monday October 26, 2015 @04:49PM (#10454376)
Its the other way around. The vast majority of housekeepers are not thieves however thieves pose as housekeepers very easily. Thieves (and other criminals) pose as all kinds of different occupations.

Almost no actual landlord will take your security deposit and run but there's plenty of people on Craigslist posing as landlords to do just that. So the moral of the story is try not to be taken in by a scam.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by zzalpha on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:42AM (#10451749)
Not to mention, they want more business. A cleaner who steals doesn't work for long. The business is heavily driven by referrals and references.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by philh on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:38AM (#10451718)
You seem to be replying to a comment which has very little in common with the one I wrote.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:52AM (#10451836)
Huh. The Uber driver could rob you too; they could rape or murder. They could kidnap. They have, really, far more opportunities to harm you. But the ol' housekeeper is alone in getting assumed to be a thief.

Probably this was not meant. But its been a hot button, the casual assumption that housekeepers are thieves, since forever. I guess I read that into the comment too readily.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by EdiX on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:46AM (#10452167)
Yes, the Uber driver could rob you or worse, but they would also be guaranteed to get caught, so they probably won't do it.

I think you are picking on a rather objective and dispassionate observation about incentives to take a grandstanding against classism, I appreciate the sentiment but the execution is flawed.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by zurn on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:50AM (#10452192)
Modeling the behaviour of personal assailants from the POV of their rational risk-reward expectations does not match reality very well. They are largely people who are not in control of their impulses.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by EdiX on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:16PM (#10453244)
My impression is that it does for crimes committed against people the assailant is not related with.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:46PM (#10455028)
Guilty as charged. But those cold dispassionate observations can inject casual bias as well as heated comments. That was what was galling. The 'oh you know how the domestic help is always stealing stuff' injected casually was more than my bs-meter could handle.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by jpatokal on Monday October 26, 2015 @07:10PM (#10455155)
...except that your strawman there isn't even close to what philh actually said.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:58AM (#10456383)
"With a cleaner, your possessions are in the hands of someone who might have plenty of incentive to steal your stuff and sell it. "

Did we read the same post?

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by philh on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:02AM (#10457084)
I said that a cleaner might have incentive to steal. You've turned this into "all housekeepers are thieves" and "the domestic help is always stealing stuff". That's not what I said, it's not what I meant, and it's not what I think.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:37AM (#10458228)
I'm glad to hear that, and I believe it. What I'm very sad about is, its the first thing that's brought up whenever housekeeping is mentioned. The casual assumption that its a huge problem, happens all the time and is the major issue.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by andy_ppp on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:18AM (#10451580)
People are more scared of burglary than car crashes.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by mikeash on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:24AM (#10451618)
Which is probably justified. There are a couple of million burglaries per year in the US (many/most of which will affect multiple people), and only about 30,000 traffic fatalities per year. And a good chunk of those fatalities are either easily avoidable by passengers (wear your seat belt!) or unavoidable even by drivers (getting whacked by a drunk driver).
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by jdmichal on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:03AM (#10451461)
Getting in a car is pretty much the most dangerous thing a person does in an average day. You may be trusting a cleaner with you possessions, but you're trusting that Uber driver with your life.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by mikeash on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:21AM (#10451604)
The difference is that with a driver, our incentives are aligned. My desire to continue living injury-free matches up perfectly with his desire to do the same, and not damage his valuable equipment.

With a house cleaner, my desire to keep my possessions is at odds with the cleaner's desire to have more stuff. I have to count on their desire for repeat business, or their morality, to outweigh that.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by cm2187 on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:09AM (#10451503)
This is a VaR vs Average risk discussion. Yes the potential harm is higher in an absolute worst case with a taxi but it is a really rare event. Cleaner stealing stuff is unfortunately quite common. When you know the person the risk is relatively low but when it is a complete stranger that has been selected by an online company which itself never met that person, I would say the probability is too high for my own taste.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by ghaff on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:13AM (#10451544)
That's a reasonable evaluation to make. I'd note though that people use cleaning services all the time so Homejoy wasn't in any way unique in this regard (which was one of their problems).
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by Mickydtron on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:15AM (#10451559)
While this is statistically true, people don't act as if this were the case. While trusting someone with your physical safety should be a high-trust decision, we treat it cavalierly enough in our day to day lives that most people clearly don't worry about it.

Maybe it makes sense, though, because the other person in the interaction has more incentive to defect when given access to all of your possessions than when given control over you yourself. That is, you have little reason to think that the Uber driver is working at cross purposes to you, and mainly just have to take their competence on faith. With something like Homejoy, it is their character and motivation you are gambling on moreso than their competence.

I haven't heard of people abusing Homejoy to rob houses or anything, but it seems not entirely stupid that someone would worry about bad actors more than incompetent ones.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JohnBooty on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:50AM (#10451817)

     While trusting someone with your physical safety should be a 
     high-trust decision, we treat it cavalierly enough in our day 
     to day lives that most people clearly don't worry about it.
We just can't avoid it. We assume that nobody's poisoned our food, we assume that nobody is going to go suicidal on the roadways and ram themselves head-on into our car, we don't wear body armor to work because we assume our coworkers won't shoot us. We even assume that the anestheseologist at the hospital isn't housing a wicked hangover that will prevent him from doing his job.

Essentially our lives are in other peoples' hands pretty much 24/7!

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by Mickydtron on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:44AM (#10452147)
Right, exactly. I didn't put enough conditions on my "should". I meant that in a crazy utopia, we would never be put at risk because of others, the real world is very very far from this utopia, and we put high levels of implicit trust in other people all the time. There's nothing wrong with this, given the world as it is.

Going back to Uber vs. Homejoy, the level of risk differential is much higher with Homejoy, because when using an Uber, you are probably not assuming much extra risk compared to what else you would do to get where you are going. For a cleaning service, then the risk differential is noticeable ('someone has access to my house' vs 'Only I and my family have access to my house') when jumping up from "doing the cleaning yourself". If you're comparing Homejoy to other cleaning services on a risk basis, you'd have to actually look at the numbers. I'm really not trying to bash Homejoy or cleaning services here.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by JohnBooty on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:44AM (#10451763)
Lives are infinitely more valuable them possessions.

If an Uber driver wanted to hurt you, he would be extremely likely to pay the legal price. After all, there's an electronic paper trail of the ride he gave you. So an Uber driver won't do that unless he's essentially insane and a) doesn't understand this or b) has nothing to lose and doesn't care if he's caught or c) thinks he can get away with it because you're incapacitated/inebriated or something.

Whereas with housekeepers, it's more a crime of opportunity. They notice that you have valuable items laying around that won't be missed. Or an acquaintance of theirs pressures them for tips on houses to rob. A housekeeper that's an otherwise "good" person can convince themselves that it's a victimless crime if they decide that you won't even miss the item(s) they take. I mean, who wouldn't be tempted to take a shiny, never-used bauble from the home of somebody with 10x their income if it was the difference between having food on their table or not?

Don't get me wrong - the vast majority of housekeepers are great people. I have family members that clean houses. I just mean that an Uber driver would have to essentially be insane to harm you, whereas a housekeeper would just have to give into temptation in order to pinch some items.

    You may be trusting a cleaner with you possessions, 
    but you're trusting that Uber driver with your life.
1. Everybody I know that's had their house robbed has had reason to believe that it was been an inside job.

2. If you have things worth stealing, each person you let into your house increases the odds that a robbery will happen. Maybe the cable guy isn't a burglar, but how many friends does that guy have? 50? Is one of them a burglar? If you were a burglar and you knew a cable guy, wouldn't you bug that guy for tips?

3. Any home burglary is potentially dangerous to one's life. Who knows what happens if you're home while the robbery is in progress or if you arrive home while it's happening.

So yeah, there's a trust factor there!

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by landryraccoon on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:31PM (#10453377)
Also the Uber driver can't easily injure you without injuring himself and his car.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by gambiting on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:20AM (#10451594)
The driver has no incentive to be in a crash. The cleaner has all the incentive to steal your stuff.
Re:Why Homejoy Failed by dkharrat on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:00PM (#10453612)
Doesn't Airbnb fall in the same category? Renting out your property for a few days to complete strangers requires a lot of trust, and yet from what I can tell, Airbnb seems to have overcome this hurdle.

I do agree there was a trust issue with Homejoy (I've personally tried them once and had similar concerns). But, I don't believe the issue was that they were in an unviable business where trust can't be gained, but rather they didn't have the right mechanics in place that help develop the necessary trust between the consumer and the cleaners.

Re:Why Homejoy Failed by secabeen on Monday October 26, 2015 @08:10PM (#10455358)
Most people who rent out their homes to AirBNB strip the home of small, valuable items who's theft would not be noticed. I've never been in an AirBNB that contained jewelry, bank statements, blank checks, or other personal items.

For large valuable items, they inventory them before the rental, and check the inventory when the rental ends. As such, a thief trying to steal from an AirBNB can only take large expensive items (like the TV), and will be immediately caught during the check-out check.

Cleaners can quietly lift the pearl necklace you only wear for the holidays and you might not notice for a few months, at which time you might have 6 homejoy cleaners as possible suspects. People don't want to theft-sanitize their homes every time a cleaner comes.