His conclusion was that 9/10 projects of this size run over budget, 9/10 run over time and 9/10 have benefits that are oversold.
Rail projects are particularly bad. The average traffic on them was 61% of that forecast and some are as low as 25%.
His homepage: http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/community/people/bent-flyvbjerg
An interview with him : http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/05/bent_flyvbjerg.html
One of his books that is very readable: http://www.amazon.com/Megaprojects-Risk-An-Anatomy-Ambition/...
This isn't to say that such projects should not be built, just that those selected should be the ones with the best realistic cost benefit, not those where the backers have made up the numbers most creatively.
Of course, no-one will actually know if the costing was accurate until it's finished. Does being accurate really pay off for a politician?
Anyway, the point of these large project is, we will need them. We can build them easier now, than later as congestion and land prices go up even more. When calculating overruns, I'd like to compare the ultimate cost with, what would it cost if we hadn't? Congestion, choked commerce, slowed economic growth all cost something.
Sometimes you have to buckle down and actually build the brave new world. "Skate toward the puck" is how its sometimes called - build the thing we will need to be a functional, thriving society in 100 years.
I hope someone does a detailed comparison between the two projects!
What we need is a true accounting of the cost of things, and the political willingness to do them. This way we don't have to worry about politicians 'underbidding' their projects just to get enough popular support. It becomes a rigged game when that happens, where the public approves projects that everyone on the project side knows will costs several times that early estimate.
If we want the bridges and the tunnels and the shared transportation, sanitation, etc. We need to understand that these projects cost money, and we need to be able to have t true accounting of them, not one that is politically convenient.
Otherwise, we'll just have this, with 2x and 3x being common run ups, ad infinitum.
Good numbers, on all projects, would help us better allocate our future dollars. Big numbers shouldn't kill meaningful and worthwhile projects. Bad ideas should.
The Swiss seem to be able to do it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gotthard_Base_Tunnel
On time and on budget.