3rd Bn. 75th Ranger Rgt. was where "winners go to feel bad about themselves". Jesus talk about eat your own toxic. You had to hate yourself to succeed there.
However the 10th SF Group guys I worked with, and all the guys I knew who subsequently joined talked about about how great the culture was. Obviously there were exceptions to the rule but overall the feedback I got was positive, which added to my anecdotal evidence.
It is possible to do hard things and maintain camaraderie. Frankly camaraderie is the different between toxic and non-toxic when trying to do "hard things". Either you have unit cohesion and strong leadership that understands how to truly "take care of soldiers and their families" or those that simply pay lip service and grind you down until you wash out. We're either all "in this together", or it's "don't get caught on the edge of the herd when the hyenas come".
This culture most certainly comes from leadership. It takes a special skill to put the troops first and still drive them beyond what they even thought they were capable of. Boy, when it happens, it's beautiful and it builds strong friendships that last a lifetime.
The kicker is, camaraderie is a force multiplier. Cohesive units absolutely out perform toxic ones.
Agreed also on variability between Tier-1 units morale also. Hell, it's variable between teams, which is really where my distinction between having a high speed culture vs. having a terrible commander/boss would be made.
Hire smart people, treat them like human beings. If you're constantly working 12 hour days in a tech company, either you or your manager are doing something wrong.
Disagree. We have 4 people. We have the money for 4 people. We have the workload of probably 8 people. If I don't put those hours in, things don't get done that need to for us to stay alive.
I'm wasting my time right now responding to this because I think it's an important discussion. That just means I'll get 4 instead of 5 hours of sleep tonight.
I have two 15-20 slide decks to finish tonight: 1 for our board meeting tomorrow and another due tomorrow morning for an Angel pitch on Wednesday. I also just hung up from a technical call, cause we are trying to push a new release to the app store tonight. I still have to review some cards in leankit and respond to a handful of emails from today.
The problem comes when the bottom of the barrel people are working those same hours. Working 80 hour weeks doesn't really help them unless they really like doing it. Some people legitimately like work. That's great. They shouldn't set the bar, though.
They should be working someplace where they can comfortably be marginally talented.
The corollary of this, in a startup, would be don't expect great employees to work 10+ hours a day for 0.5%.
If you expect people to put in that same level of effort, compensate them to the same degree.
Meanwhile those of us who've already been through that meat grinder will be enjoying our 9-5 and large salary, regardless your baseless slight about being "marginally talented."
Can't agree with this enough - it's the same reason Special Operators get a shitload of incentive/hazard duty pay and signing bonuses.
Meanwhile those of us who've already been through that meat grinder will be enjoying our 9-5 and large salary, regardless your baseless slight about being "marginally talented."
I was simply responding to the OP's "Bottom of the barrel" comment.
Pardon the military metaphor I am going to make, but it's the closest thing that I know of that can compare.
In the U.S. and most first world nations, you have two distinct groups within the military: The line military which makes up 95-99% of the force and special operations which is somewhere between 1-5%.
The line military generally works 7-4, has most weekends off and generally you can have a normal family life. There isn't much of a selection process for the troops and you only need to put in a huge effort for a small portion of the time. They mostly do low intensity training and in a really big conflict a subsection might see combat twice or three times.
Special Operations has a long selection and initial training process that can last years. This group is at the top of their game 90% of the time and is constantly in high intensity training. They see combat constantly regardless of if there is a big war going and a good portion have significant trouble maintaining a stable home or family life without significant effort from the spouse. If they start to fail, they get removed from the unit and sent to the line (fired). You've never seen "eat your own" like there is in Tier-1 Special Operations units - because you have to, to stay that good.
In my opinion, high tech, "disruptive" high growth companies by definition are the Special Operations groups of the business world. It's a tiny percent, but you have to be at the top of your game 90-99% of the time. That means dedicating your life to the job. That means hiring "killers" who are intensely driven.
The rest of the business world is the line and cannot, or do not want to be in that kind of "always on" 24/7 environment.
I think the disconnect is that there is a large group of people who aren't special operators, they are line soldiers, but they joined special operations companies. This is partly the fault of the company for not making it clear to them before hiring what they would be getting into, and partly their fault for not seeing the company for what it was.
This metaphor seems to apply to companies like SpaceX, Amazon, etc...
You can have a well run company with empathetic staff that crushes spirits constantly because they have such a high bar and a subset of their people were just not up to the task. "Your best isn't good enough" is a constant mantra during Special Operations selection and I don't see why such a bar would be any lower in an elite business organization.
This quote was great: "Amazon is where overachievers go to feel bad about themselves.”
This same quote has been applied to Harvard, Stanford, the US Military Academies, Goldman Sachs, EXXON etc...so it's not unique to tech by any means.
Any relation to Objectivism may only apply to that first group I mentioned before, but is certainly not a prerequisite for a company which has insanely high standards.