No! They're poor because their parents were poor or because they grew up in a poor neighbourhood and lacked access to a proper education.
This article highlights one egregious myth but far more pernicious is the one you just highlighted: that poverty is a personal or moral failing rather than a lack of opportunity.
It's really simple: people are poor because they don't have enough money. Don't let yourself fall into the Just-World Fallacy.
I think it's easier to defend the claim that the kids lacked guidance and support to take advantage of the education provided for them.
In the US a single mom who homeschools, with only a high school education, will have her child place in the top 70% of public school kids.
Parental involvement is so important, it's the only factor that matters.
Education funding in the US is wildly uneven. Spend some time visiting inner-city schools. They are not even remotely "well-funded".
Property-tax driven school funding formulas ensure that richer areas have much, much better funded schools than poor areas.
The wealthy suburb of DC where I grew up spends $13,500 per student per year. That's a lot less than DC or Baltimore or Chicago, all of which have 70-85% low-income students, and only moderately more than Philadelphia, which is also almost all "inner city" schools.
Also, are you certain that wealthy suburbs are spending that little? I know some rich families in NYC who are sending their kids in high school to schools that ask above $50k. It's a straight pipeline to Ivy league, and from what I understand there are good reasons this high school asks $50k -- they have top of the line 3d printers, souped up computers, etc.
Yes, teachers are better in my town - but the most important difference are the role models. IN my town most families are professional couples, typically doctors, executives, etc. Kids are expected to not only go to college but good college and then continue on to graduate school, to at least match their parents' status. None of that, sadly, is at work in inner city families. It is a difficult problem and not something that money alone will fix.
Teaching students that live in wealthy suburbs.
there are good reasons this high school asks $50k -- they have top of the line 3d printers, souped up computers, etc.
Those things probably account for $5k of value, with the other $45k being the ability to list the school on the kid's Ivy league application.
That guidance is a critical part of a "good" education. Unfortunately, we leave it up to parents and don't have a way to teach them how to raise a successful kid.
My brother went to public high school in Washington DC graduating in 2008. His school had tracking, meaning you could only take classes available in your "track". A student was in either all honors/advanced classes or in all regular classes but could not take a mix of both.
The regular track was exclusively black, while the honors track was for white and/or rich students, regardless of actual academic performance!
Unless a non-white student is both high achieving and has parents who are able to navigate the bureaucratic nightmare that is the DC public schools (it was a mess even for upper-middle class white students like my brother) they don't really have an opportunity for anything other than a poor education.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/graduation-ra...
So no, if you're poor in the US it's not just because you've got a mental illness, that's a very wrong view of the world. Poverty is a big issue in the US and it is distinct from many (not all) developed economies for having a lot of working poverty, i.e. people who are not ill, do not suffer substance abuse, who aren't homeless and who have a job (often multiple) and yet are poor. That is very much an American phenomenon, no other developed country has so many normal people who have jobs and yet are poor and who struggle to leave their children a better life than they enjoyed.
I could not disagree more with the title, based on my own observations. I mean, aren't most of the people in this country poor because of mental illness or addiction?