Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by Zash on Sunday October 25, 2015 @09:51AM
(#10446860)
> Comets may preserve ancient layered splat structures; the European Space Agency’s Rosetta mission, now on its way to Comet Churymov-Gerasimenko, will be able to take a look.
Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by EwanG on Sunday October 25, 2015 @09:43AM
(#10446851)
Publish date May 2014 - still, glad to see it solves most (but not all) the issues with the known differences between the near and far sides. Another argument for a lunar base so we can safely get some samples to do more hands-on comparisons.
Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by grogers on Sunday October 25, 2015 @05:59PM
(#10448626)
FWIW the best theory we have now is that since the earth was very hot for a while after the moon formed, the radiating heat kept the near side of the moon molten for longer. That means thinner crust on the near side which makes it more likely for early meteor impacts the punch through the crust and cause lava flows.
This seems much more likely than a secondary moon impact that happens to hit the far side. Crucially, this should be testable - which is great!
Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by titzer on Sunday October 25, 2015 @01:27PM
(#10447539)
I'm just gonna burn karma and rant randomly at this kind of narrative style.
<quote>Asphaug was not only annoyed; he was inspired. </quote>
For Science articles, what value does all this narration add? Why do we have to sift through 30 years of background biography material before getting to the new theory and subject matter? Is the state of mind of the researchers important? Do we need to humanize and narrate the proposal of a new model in this way?
Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by titzer on Sunday October 25, 2015 @01:28PM
(#10447546)
Another:
<quote> I remember reading about it as a child, in the dreamy pre-Apollo science books I inherited from my older brothers—books that predated Luna 3 by a few years. </quote>
I like, totally don't give a shit what the author did as a child.
Re:A new model, “The Big Splat”, explains the strange asymme...
by lscritch on Sunday October 25, 2015 @02:17PM
(#10447742)
<quote>For Science articles, what value does all this narration add? Why do we have to sift through 30 years of background biography material before getting to the new theory and subject matter? Is the state of mind of the researchers important? Do we need to humanize and narrate the proposal of a new model in this way?</quote>
That's what popular science sites/books <em>do</em>. Maybe you should be seeking out the original research article.
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/How_...
This seems much more likely than a secondary moon impact that happens to hit the far side. Crucially, this should be testable - which is great!
<quote>Asphaug was not only annoyed; he was inspired. </quote>
For Science articles, what value does all this narration add? Why do we have to sift through 30 years of background biography material before getting to the new theory and subject matter? Is the state of mind of the researchers important? Do we need to humanize and narrate the proposal of a new model in this way?
If you want pure distilled science this is what you are looking for https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h...
http://explosm.net/comics/3557/
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v476/n7358/full/nature1...
by that logic you could reverse it and rant that arxiv.org lacks sufficient fluff
<quote> I remember reading about it as a child, in the dreamy pre-Apollo science books I inherited from my older brothers—books that predated Luna 3 by a few years. </quote>
I like, totally don't give a shit what the author did as a child.
That's what popular science sites/books <em>do</em>. Maybe you should be seeking out the original research article.