News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 23, 2015 @05:04AM (#10437543)
Sometimes I feel that people writing about physics are having great fun with deliberately confusing people by making stuff sound magical and illogical.

This particular effect has nothing to do with whether or not anyone is looking at an object. It's the methods of making it visible that cause the effect.

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by gus_massa on Friday October 23, 2015 @06:23AM (#10437742)
I agree.

I think that a big part of the problem is trying to make the new more layman friendly removing all the math. Quantum mechanics is unintuitive but the math is very clear, so "anyone" can get the same correct result for an experiment. When you remove the math, you keep only the unintuitive part.

Another part of the problem is linkbait, making slightly wrong interpretations make more interesting articles. Sometimes there are a few articles from different news sites about some subject, and it's very common that the more misleading gets more attention here.

Sadly, my rule of thumb is https://xkcd.com/1240/

For an interesting explanation of what is happening here, I like the stack of slightly rotated polarizers. (See this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10437289 ) The math is equivalent, but the result is not linkbaity. You can even try it at home! If you think enough about it, it's completely weird, but the calculation are pretty straightforward.

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by arrel on Friday October 23, 2015 @10:56AM (#10438949)
A better title might be "Scientists pause the motion of atoms by blasting them with an imaging laser"
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by acqq on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:50AM (#10439357)
"Atoms cooled near absolute zero don't move while beamed with the laser"
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by Benichmt1 on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:34AM (#10438163)
I thought the same thing when someone showed me the popular "Dr. Quantum" double slit video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfPeprQ7oGc).

Generally a decent layman's explanation of the experiment, but they had to conflate quantum mechanics with magic by saying "the atom knew it was being watched..."

It's very hard to handle these misconceptions once they're already so widespread.

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by DyslexicAtheist on Friday October 23, 2015 @07:35AM (#10437932)
could swear I've had some debugging / system testing sessions where the effect of me looking into it changed its state :-)
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by rybosome on Friday October 23, 2015 @07:49AM (#10437973)
We call those "heisenbugs" - one of the most terrifying and maddening things you can encounter prior to a launch. I'm almost positive that I remember reading a sort from a game dev who ran into one of these right before a release, where printing some variable caused it to have the correct value; in this case, it was left in the game.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by EwanG on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:45AM (#10438213)
Well, I know that I ran into a situation (and may once have posted about it) in a C program where I was doing printf to debug a program, and it ran fine. Whenever I removed them, the program would crash. Finally discovered that the printf debugging was forcing garbage collection which took care of a bad pointer somewhere else in the program. Honestly can't remember if I ever found the pointer or just left the printfs in the code...
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by nitrogen on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:43PM (#10440104)
Thank goodness we have Valgrind these days. Though I don't know how well it would handle a C app with a garbage collector.

Calling printf can (will) change what's beyond the stack of the calling function, so if the pointer in question pointed outside the active stack, printf may have put a safer value there by coincidence.

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by backlava on Friday October 23, 2015 @09:06AM (#10438296)
There's the related example of the segfault termination message that was changed in a hex editor to "thank you for playing!" Wing Commander, maybe.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by knodi123 on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:49PM (#10439751)
That's a classic!
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by justifier on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:09PM (#10439878)
any language with mutable values will drive an unwarned mind insane

methods of disassociating mutable objects before printing will save you from some heisenbugs

a la javascript

    console.log(JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(obj))
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by knodi123 on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:51PM (#10439772)
This happens all the time. I very recently had an issue where a deadlock was fixed by a print statement, because two lists were being lazily evaluated at the same time, and the print statement forced one of the lists to be evaluated earlier and finished by the time the deadlock was occurring.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by grokys on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:18PM (#10439944)
I think this video is a good explanation you can use to refer to people with that misunderstanding:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQfSm6o-KlQ

(Assuming it's correct - I'm not physicist)

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by Strilanc on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:09PM (#10442267)
The main problem with that series of videos, if I remember correctly, is that it only ever gives high-level descriptions of experiment outcomes. Those are interesting, but they aren't really good explanations. Then to top that off, they get some of the important details wrong.

For example, in the quantum eraser video referred to by the video you linked, it's said that there's an interference pattern for B when you don't measure the entangled associated photon A (and that there is one when you do measure A). That's not the case. If it was the case, we'd have a handy-dandy FTL communication mechanism.

What actually happens is that there's never a visible interference pattern for B in this experiment. Instead, you use the measurements of A to filter or split the measurements of B into two groups (e.g. Bs when A up, Bs when A down). Within each group of measurements, you'll find an interference pattern. The two interference patterns will complement each other so the sum is an apparent lack-of-interference; you need the As to do the separation.

I personally think the the quantum eraser experiment has a terrible misleading name. It's more of a "use entangled measurements to find the interference" experiment.

Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by rottyguy on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:00AM (#10438020)
When I was in highschool, I thought the same when opening up a Calculus book. Now, it's looking at stl code :-)
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by TillE on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:19AM (#10438099)
I do remember a data structures textbook in university that actually managed to confuse me about stuff I already understood really well. It wasn't offering a different perspective, it was just that badly written.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by Dylan16807 on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:27PM (#10439994)
But it doesn't matter what method you use. Anything that checks the position rapidly will keep it from moving.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by trevelyan on Friday October 23, 2015 @10:28AM (#10438754)
Please explain?
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by gnaritas on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:14PM (#10439512)
Atoms don't know they're being watched and using language like watched misleads people into thinking they do. Same issue as the double slit experiment. Watching is not passive, the correct term should be measured and the methods of measuring things affects them because you have to bounce particles off of things to measure them and thus measuring them (watching) changes their behavior.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by criddell on Friday October 23, 2015 @02:39PM (#10440482)
Is it possible to measure with multiple devices that cancel each other out and get back to the same behavior as the unobserved system?
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by gnaritas on Sunday October 25, 2015 @12:20AM (#10445963)
They actually are coming up with crazy ways to indirectly obtain measurement without interference or at least less, but this is about the limits of my knowledge on the subject.
Re:'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch by recycleme on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:42PM (#10439705)
Basically, this is called the observer effect. The process of observing something can change the thing you are observing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observer_effect_(physics)