News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by pmalynin on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:12PM (#10436593)
Where to even begin,

Part of this issue I feel is, as mentioned in the article, is that boys are taught from the young age to take care of their problems, which leads to more isolation. Another important reason I feel is the rising amount of "girls-only" opportunities that systematically make boys feel inadequate and since they are not able to participate for whatever reason (e.g. "its only for girls") they continue to lag behind. I even have a perfect example of this, my city has a "Girls Learning Code" meetup / lecture series that while advertises being gender neutral is clearly not so, the question is how many meetups are there that are for boys, e.g. "Boys Learning Code" (creating these would be classified under men 's rights activism and therefore dismissed). My point is (or rather society's) is that if you're male and have a good start then you're automatically golden, but for those that do not have the same starting opportunities there are simply no other options that are, on the other hand, available to girls from all backgrounds. There has also been a decline in male bonding occurring at the young age, which I (and some academics) believe is very important to male development over all. This is caused by the fact that traditionally boys-only facilities (in this specific example Scouts Canada) have been pressured into accepting girls, which prohibits boys from...essentially being boys. Girl Guides of Canada received no such pressure. Coming back to the issue of masculinity, even though many young adults might have good enough grades to get into university they might not be high enough to go into fields that wouldn't cause strange questions and don't have stigma around them if you're male (I'm talking about fields such as Medicine, Law, Engineering, Computer Science), they might have the grades to get into Arts, specifically psychology, nursing and things such as women studies, all of which have a very high female to male ratio (and are generally considered a "girls" field) making boys pursue other interests (such as not going to university) instead for the fears of unsexing themselves.

(Whats the deal with gender issues anyway in North America? I've immigrated from an Eastern-Block country as a teenager to NA and I've never seen these problems because communism required that all members of the society do essentially the same jobs, that is why would you sacrifice half of the working populace, so you have women in high power positions, police, factories, the military, a lot of girls even take mathematics and computational sciences, sure there were problems but not at this scale (my grandmother was a Chemist and my mother was a corporal in the Defense Ministry and also studied thermal physics in University); I've never even imagined it was an issue elsewhere in the world until after I moved to Canada)

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by cthalupa on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:59AM (#10437382)
>my city has a "Girls Learning Code" meetup / lecture series that while advertises being gender neutral is clearly not so

The majority of women drop out of the running for STEM jobs before they even go to college - something is persuading them at the primary school level to avoid tech related fields. It's the biggest reason that the idea of sexism in the workplace pushing women out of IT is absurd - because they never got there in the first place. They never even got to the college classes in the first place. Even high school vocational programs focusing on tech have girls wildly unrepresented.

And it's the exact same reason that organizations like Girls Who Code is extremely important. It's the same reason that an organization like Boys Who Teach/Nurse/Other female dominated profession would be a godsend for evening out the gender balance in those fields.

Should there be code/stem programs for boys? Absolutely. Is there anything wrong with programs that exists primarily for outreach to a gender that is underrepresented in that field? Absolutely not.

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by JPKab on Friday October 23, 2015 @09:06AM (#10438293)
"Whats the deal with gender issues anyway in North America? I've immigrated from an Eastern-Block country as a teenager to NA and I've never seen these problems because communism required that all members of the society do essentially the same jobs"

The problem in this country is that we have identity politics, which helped to address real discrimination, but all too often is misused as a tool to obtain power and support from vocal special interest groups.

Perhaps most disturbingly is the rise of the professional identity politician/professor/activist complex, where students are brought in to universities majoring in "Women's Studies", with zero job prospects when they graduate except for teaching more classes or becoming an activist. Suddenly, you have entire groups of people who, although they won't admit it, NEED the problem they are claiming to fight to exist forever if they want an income.

The end result is a constant search for new manifestations of oppression of their chosen group, real or perceived. All too often, its perceived, and even when it's real, these folks have solutions which do nothing more than create new inequalities.

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by lordCarbonFiber on Friday October 23, 2015 @09:33AM (#10438406)
I feel like the dynamics are way too fuzzy to point at one group of people an say "this is the cause of outrage culture, and that is the dominate driver of unexpected inequality flux". The US has a host of initial conditions (heterogeneous population, very young age, combination of high overall wealth as well as extreme wealth inequality) that makes it very difficult to compare apples to apples with much of the world.

It appears that there are only ~2.5k genders studies majors matriculating at any given year [1]. I doubt that's pushing the needle appreciably in terms identity politics. IMO I'd look more too the cognitive dissonance between the gap in achievement of the wealthy vs poor and the taboo in talking about any sort of income inequality in this country as a more potent driver to the under-directed efforts to impose a slanted "equality" in the name of social good.

[1]http://www.nwsa.org/files/NWSA_CensusonWSProgs.pdf

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by vlehto on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:02AM (#10438986)
I had similar suspicions about women's studies. But I didn't really believe it.

Then I read Judith Butlers Gender Trouble to about halfway. It's a book that's canonical in womens studies these days. Holy shit it reads like political manifesto, with sciency stuff only to mask it little bit.

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by nv-vn on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:21AM (#10436783)
>My point is (or rather society's) is that if you're male and have a good start then you're automatically golden, but for those that do not have the same starting opportunities there are simply no other options that are, on the other hand, available to girls from all backgrounds.

This is definitely due to the mentality of "all boys are the same" and "all girls are the same" collectivist mentality that's so popular today. The same thing exists for races, ethnicities, etc. Basically, rather than looking at the background of a person these people tend to blindly make assumptions about exactly who and what they are. I think that this is one of the reasons affirmative action is especially broken -- a poor Asian student is basically doomed for failure whereas a rich Black student is going to have a huge advantage (over both White students at their socioeconomic level and poorer Black students). Rather than fixing the problem that people get unequal opportunities it sort of decides what the opportunities should be for every single person regardless of their actual situation, and that creates really skewed edge cases.

>Whats the deal with gender issues anyway in North America...

I think that the root of this issue is that there are basically two ways to fix inequalities: flattening out the entire system or raising those below up to the same level as everyone else. The technique that has proven most successful was really the type of communist philosophy that was used by lots of these Eastern European states, and that essentially comes out to be leveling the playing system by putting everyone below where they could possibly be. Of course raising everyone up is a possibility, but as a whole it's proven extremely difficult to do.

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by asgard1024 on Friday October 23, 2015 @04:09AM (#10437399)
> think that the root of this issue is that there are basically two ways to fix inequalities: flattening out the entire system or raising those below up to the same level as everyone else. The technique that has proven most successful was really the type of communist philosophy that was used by lots of these Eastern European states, and that essentially comes out to be leveling the playing system by putting everyone below where they could possibly be. Of course raising everyone up is a possibility, but as a whole it's proven extremely difficult to do.

I disagree there is a binary choice. Educational system in Finland was intended to address the inequality, but in the effect it actually helped the performance.

On the other hand, the U.S. with No Child Left Behind policy failed, mostly because it didn't address the inequality.

I think there are two things conflated here: power and choice. We should strive for equality in power, but still give people the choice. If you have the choice, then no one puts you below. I think the fallacy here is that people actually don't need huge resources to become successful, only modest ones. So you can distribute resources equally and yet the best people won't be topped out.

Contrary to popular opinion, lack of possibility to be rich wasn't the biggest obstacle in Eastern European countries. The biggest obstacle was existing bureaucracy (which actually had more power than normal people, it just wasn't expressed in money). Good innovators don't need financial incentives; they need (at least modest) access to resources and freedom. For example, this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_Wichterle

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by TeMPOraL on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:07AM (#10437240)
Isn't North America / Western Europe going the flattening way? Most of the gender equality movement today seems to be focused on creating hatred and making life harder for one group, as well as forcing arbitrary and artificial adjustments.
Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by jacalata on Friday October 23, 2015 @06:06AM (#10437707)
> the question is how many meetups are there that are for boys, e.g. "Boys Learning Code" (creating these would be classified under men 's rights activism and therefore dismissed)

Do you know this because somebody tried to do it, or are you assuming this? The use of 'would be' sounds like the latter. If so, why don't you try?

Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by vlehto on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:20AM (#10439122)
I was a scout and this really frustrated me. There is currently situation here in Finland "boys are fleeing from scouting". Your choises are to play counter strike at home or knit a pot coaster with girls in scout meeting. What are you going to do?

In 1910 your choised were playing capture the flag with boys in scout meeting. Or stay at home with mom and help her. What are you going to do?

This used to be movement that helped poor boys more than any other single thing. Boys have not changed, scouting has.

[dead]
Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by nv-vn on Friday October 23, 2015 @02:01AM (#10437038)
You're making the assumption that every single male has experienced the exact same thing and that every single female has experienced the exact same thing. While it may not make sense to create these types of programs in terms of number of people they could cater to (although these could be a great idea in low income neighbourhoods as something for both boys and girls), that doesn't make them ethically/morally wrong. I don't see what there is to be offended by here.
Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by wcummings on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:25AM (#10439165)
There's adequate support and encouragement for young men interested in science and technology, comments like the parent only serve to undermine and attack efforts to include women, you'd have to be intentionally daft (or have a massive persecution complex) not to see why it annoys people.
Re:A Disadvantaged Start Hurts Boys More Than Girls by aaaaaa1121 on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:45AM (#10437005)
Now you're just trying to discourage them even further.