News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by networked on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:12PM (#10436055)
I was late last time, so this is my chance to ask again. Is the Urbit team familiar with Ted Nelson's work? For some context, see my question from the previous Urbit thread at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10286521.
Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by yarvin9 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:29PM (#10436110)
How could anyone not be familiar with Ted Nelson's work? In the broad sense, anyway.

I think the crucial layer that we need to implement... a lot of things... is a global immutable (aka referentially transparent) namespace. Urbit is one project building such a thing; another one is IPFS. (Urbit names are addressed by identity; IPFS names are content-addressed; so they're complementary and not competitive.)

One of the reasons the Web seems like such a poor imitation of Xanadu is that it rests on this rickety foundation of a mutable binding from name to resource. Once global immutable namespaces -- Urbit, IPFS, anything -- are more widely deployed, I think Xanadu would be wise to use such a thing as a layer.

But to paraphrase a famous saying: grant me the serenity to accept the code I cannot rewrite, the courage to rewrite the code I can, and the wisdom to know the difference :-)

Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by unimpressive on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:40PM (#10436157)
>I think the crucial layer that we need to implement... a lot of things... is a global immutable (aka referentially transparent) namespace.

Theodore Nelson has said this himself, I can't remember the exact source but I think it was in his google talk he said that you need permanent addressing for Xanadu to work. He at least reiterates the concept (though with less principal importance) here:

http://xanadu.com/XanaduSpace/btf.htm

"STABILIZED ADDRESSES

Imagine that everything you type is given a permanent, immutable address. Then to refer to a given sentence, or paragraph, you would refer to its permanent address span (start, length). This would have many benefits.

This is not the way things are ordinarily done, but in this system we simulate such permanent addresses in order to get these benefits."

Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by e12e on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:44PM (#10436349)
> How could anyone not be familiar with Ted Nelson's work? In the broad sense, anyway.

Computer Science is not renowned for it's diligent study of history. And that's just for those that actually study it in some form of institution, not all the people who "practice" it without any formal training.

That said, the fact that Ted Nelson/the publisher have stubbornly refused to just publish for example "Computer Lib/Dream Machines" free on the (inferior) web, or at least as a DRMed ebook or merely a dead-tree re-print -- makes it unnecessarily hard for people to read up on the concept(s).

Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by teh_klev on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:28PM (#10436482)
"Computer Lib/Dream Machines" was in print once upon a time. I bought a copy circa 1992, the copy I have is the revised edition which was published in 1987, these are photos of my copy (it's a wee bit aged looking now):

http://imgur.com/a/ghtEb

You can still find copies on Abe Books but they're not cheap.

http://www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?isbn=091484549...

Glad I held on to this little bit of dead tree history even if it is the revised version.

Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by zekevermillion on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:36PM (#10436144)
Ted Nelson had some great thoughts, but fell short on implementing them. Nelson's Xanadu stands for the impossibility of implementing a perfect system. One cannot implement a perfect system, b/c anyone's idea of perfection must necessarily confront reality. Nelson was never willing to compromise to reality. I get the sense that Mr. Yarvin is totally willing to compromise in the face of reality, and has already done so in many respects to get this far with urbit.
Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by hga on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:19PM (#10436267)
Another important lesson is not to take decades before trying out things end to end. According to second hand report, the API to connect a UI to Xanadu was very complicated, way too complicated to expect wide adaptation.

Another lesson is to avoid too long a stealth period.

Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by zekevermillion on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:44PM (#10436347)
I'm not sure that Xanadu's stealth period was intentional. Maybe only a few people really understood what Nelson was talking about, at least until the Web came along and it was clear that Nelson was really on the right track philosophically. He could've run a superbowl ad every year until 1990 --most people would've shrugged their shoulders and wondered why this crackpot was wasting so much money on a silly piece of performance art!
Re:Urbit user guide, hosted on Urbit by state on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:54PM (#10436546)
I love that you emailed him!

Urbit is 100% open source, and (as you mention in your other post) probably a good fit for implementing Xanadu on top. Our filesystem satisfies a lot of the requirements.

Want to build it? Great. We'll happily help.