We can have a debate about whether "industry norms" are fair or not, and that's an interesting conversation to have. But your stake there is well below industry norms.
It's exactly what you'd expect when programmers are willing to sell their birthright for lentil stew.
Frankly, most C-level executives at a small startups are glorified secretaries taking care of the paperwork for the people who provide most of the actual value. They get paid more because they've played the social game well enough to persuade engineers to work for them instead of the other way around.
We engineers are nothing but servants to these people.
Which is funny you say that because apparently the "SV elite" think quite the opposite: https://twitter.com/sama/status/641281287660007424
Indeed. I'd suggest that your understanding of what they do might be a little underdeveloped. (And perhaps your company is particularly dysfunctional.)
Anyone can learn to code! Software should be free!
And they wonder why programmers don't get paid... No other profession talks themselves down like us.
However, dragging software into it is a bit misguided. The value a programmer provides is a service (the production of software) not a commodity (the software). The software has almost no monetary value because it can be reproduced at will. Various DRM schemes attempt to make software a commodity but this viewpoint in general holds humanity back.
More to the point, viewing the production of software as a service rather than viewing software as a commodity demonstrates why programmers are the real value. If you view the C-level execs as retailers of a commodity, their business model makes sort of sense. But if you view software engineers as providing a service, it becomes strikingly obvious that the executives are extraneous, unnecessary middlemen attaching themselves parasitically to a service transaction.
My boss (tech lead) was making a pittance compared to the PM - without my boss the product would literally come to a standstill. The inequality/unfairness of it all was just sad.
I don't see this changing anytime in the near future.
To add insult to injury, Software Engineers are treated as bunch of nerds who are replaceable.
The job market might change on these invidual opinion pieces a little, but on invidiual level the most realistic options are either renegotiations or getting a new job.
If they don't offer you a significant raise with 24 hours, start applying for other jobs.
Start applying for other jobs anyways. Schedule on-site interviews more than 24 hours after you talk about getting a raise. If they offer a significant raise, cancel the interviews.
Edit: been with the startup for over 6 months now and have helped design and develop the software as much as you would expect your second engineering employee to.
Now I am happily employed at a place that pays a very nice salary and I love my job, win win!
It's disappointing to me to see so much disparity between the compensation for C-level and VP-level versus engineering. Without engineering, there would be no product to sell and nothing for investors to invest in. Ideas are nice, but implementation is hard.