News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by petra on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @10:36AM (#10425683)
>> after the acquisition doesn't pan out.

Considering that this is common , one wonders - wouldn't it be better investing the $19 billion in innovation, even if in non-related fields ?

Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by mbesto on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @11:38AM (#10426159)
This is a common misconception by non financial people (no offense). You have to look at this from a finance and risk perspective.

1. Cash lying around in your bank account is usually a poor use of working capital (you are effectively "losing" money by it sitting in the form of cash)

2. Investing in "innovation" is always risky. Look at how many internal Google apps get scrapped a year or two into launch. They effectively write those off and it's a direct loss to Google's bottom line.

3. "Innovator's Dilemma" - big companies realize they are not the best suited to invest in innovation, hence why startups and buying them are actually a net positive for large businesses.

Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by petra on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @01:05PM (#10426775)
Bit first, this is not cash lying around, this is new debt. Second ,Even if you take all of Google's investments into innovation and and look at them combined ,they would probably offer a decent return on investment. Similarly if you look at intel capital's investments , you'll probably get a nice financial story + a decent strategic lever.

Also from a pure financial perspective - sandisk has a profit of $1.22 Billion.That would take 15 years to repay. Isn't risky to make such long term investments in i a single investment , in tech , which is a dynamic field usually ?

Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by 212d1d on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @03:54PM (#10428170)
1. This is not cash in a bank. 2. Innovation is a requirement not an option. 3. Innovator's Dilemma completely contradicts the point you attempt to make in #2.
Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by pmorici on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @10:51AM (#10425801)
Considering they are only over paying by roughly 10% if you assume the current stock price is fair then they are "only" throwing away $1.9 billion. They probably can't develop their own flash technology and build a fab for that amount of investment.
Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by jo909 on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @12:53PM (#10426687)
To make some sort of (of course flawed) comparison:

You want a nice house.

You can drive around the neighborhood, look at what houses exist and inspect the house you are interested in from roof to cellar bevor making an offer. You adjust your price for the parts you think need renovating, market conditions etc. Banks will gladly finance the deal, you don't need to have very much money of your own.

Or you buy an empty plot, buy a lot of materials, hire people to turn the materials into a house of your specifications. In many established neighborhoods it's very hard to even get an empty plot. Maybe you don't find the materials or people in the quantity or quality you want. Maybe your plans are not that good. Maybe the weather is bad and you take much longer than you planned, and you can't stop at half a house when you run out of money. If everything goes well you can get a better house for less money, but you have to be able to afford the risk.

Re:Western Digital agrees to buy SanDisk for about $19B by ma2rten on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @10:48AM (#10425772)
You mean like Xerox Parc?