News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by AdieuToLogic on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @02:00AM (#10423940)

  Actually no, TCP/IP/DNS is the backbone
  of the Internet and what made the Internet
  possible, HTTP was invented before Roy
  dropped his thesis. People like to give Roy
  kudos for inventing the Internet ...
Hi strawman[1], nice to see you again. I specifically stated that Fielding, Berners-Lee, and Frystyk were responsible for defining HTTP. A fact well documented by the aforementioned RFC-1945 reference. Since your reply was submitted by some form of HTTP client (a.k.a. "web browser"), by definition it used said protocol or the derivative "HTTPS" protocol to do so.

This is further supported by you acknowledging the same:

  ... the thing that makes the web platform
  powerful is modern web browsers ...
You see, these "modern web browsers" support a thing called "HTTP." And this "HTTP" thingie was defined by a handful of people (this sounds familiar).

Regarding web client performance verses native apps, you state:

  Which Despite its primary focus and
  decade-long head-start it's still getting
  eaten by Native Mobile Apps ...
This largely can be explained by bloated JavaScript-based SPA's[2] downloading megabytes of interpreted code. Want faster performing interaction? Don't stuff dozens of script references into a page which mandates the system to download them before being useful.

How could this be done? One is called Code-on-Demand[3]. But for this to be viable, the system must recognize the server as being a first-class concern which collaborates with its clients instead of being a glorified data base connection pool. But if a person is myopically focused on what executes solely in the browser, this might elude them.

  >  you'd prefer whatever Facebook tells
  you is better?

  No people should learn to think for
  themselves and use their experience to
  pick the best tool for the job ...
Here's a point we agree upon. Nice to end it on a high note.

1 - http://www.asa3.org/ASA/education/think/strawman.htm

2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-page_application

3 - http://restcookbook.com/Basics/codeondemand/

[dead]
Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by AdieuToLogic on Thursday October 22, 2015 @02:30AM (#10430705)

  Thanks but I don't need a misguided history
  lesson skewed to support your warped view of
  events attributing the creation of the Web to
  your lord and savior who you wish was sole
  entity responsible for the Internet but was
  instead created by the geniuses who built the
  ARPANET in 1969 which is what formed the
  technical foundation and what made the
  Internet possible.
I have no idea where your anger, vitriol, and venom originate. I humbly suggest you find someone professionally qualified to help you work through these issues. Perhaps you are experiencing a persecutory delusion[1], though I freely state I am not a clinical psychiatrist and only present this as a possibility from someone who has never met you personally.

  Your fixation of the HTTP protocol was
  invented by Tim Berners-Lee, on-his-own.
  The first version created in 1991 supported
  the most important GET Request method
  (http://www.w3.org/Protocols/HTTP/AsImplemented.html).
Of course Tim Berners-Lee has been and remains a major force in defining the HTTP protocol and "the Web" as we know it. This is well documented and an indisputable fact. However, as great as his contributions have been and continue to be, he has not operated alone.

What you fail to mention in the statement you quote is:

  This is a subset of the full HTTP protocol,
  and is known as HTTP 0.9.
  (http://www.w3.org/Protocols/HTTP/AsImplemented.html)
The HTTP protocol has not stood still and has had contributors throughout the last 24 years. If you cannot accept this, that is your issue to deal with and not mine.

If you had even read Section 1.1 of RFC-1945, you could have saved yourself the embarrassment of saying "The first version created in 1991", as the RFC reads thusly:

  HTTP has been in use by the World-Wide Web
  global information initiative since 1990.
Remember that one of the authors of this RFC is Mr. Tim Berners-Lee.

You then go on to spew:

  The fact you glorify a simple text
  protocol as the magical thing that makes
  the web possible is indicative of the
  extent of your religious delusion to a
  single technology.
Well, if you cannot accept my explanation of the importance of HTTP, perhaps you can fathom what Mr. Berners-Lee wrote instead:

  Did you invent the Internet?
  
  No, no, no!
  
  ...

  I just had to take the hypertext idea and
  connect it to the TCP and DNS ideas and
  -- ta-da! -- the World Wide Web.[2]
Can you accept/understand that the primary contributor to what you colloquially describe as what "makes the web possible" is, in fact, stating that the web was made by combining hypertext with previously established technologies? See also previous mention of persecutory delusion[1].

  Go ahead and try make versions of Gmail,
  Facebook, Google Maps, Google Docs / Office,
  etc with dumb clients and full page
  reloads on every request ...
The fact that you conflate a REST architecture with "full page reloads" only shows your ignorance. There is nothing precluding an XMLHttpRequest sent from a browser client to a REST endpoint. Actually, it is quite common and the REST server wouldn't know/care if it were done anyway.

  Any fool can create simple a text protocol,
  any fool can create a dumb, server-driven
  client, any fool can document a
  code-on-demand solution.
No, any fool can trivialize the accomplishments of those before them. Any fool can benefit from infrastructure which allows them to be oblivious to how the bytes sent around the world "just work." Any fool can lament about performance on a resource constrained platform, such as a mobile device, and reject possibilities to address them.

  That isn't to say HTTP isn't a well-thought
  out and defined work, it is ...
That must have seriously hurt you to type.

1 - http://psychcentral.com/encyclopedia/2008/persecutory-delusi...

2 - http://www.w3.org/People/Berners-Lee/Kids.html#invent

Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by dang on Thursday October 22, 2015 @02:48PM (#10434112)
Your comments have broken the HN guidelines by being personally abusive. That's not allowed, regardless of how wrongly someone else has behaved, and we ban accounts that do this repeatedly. Please re-read the guidelines and post civilly and substantively or not at all.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by AdieuToLogic on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:54PM (#10436379)
I see your point and apologize for letting the interaction degenerate to this point. Allowing myself to intermix reactionary statements with this post is a regrettable decision. The wiser choice would have been to "walk away from the thread."
Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by DanBC on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:53AM (#10432565)
What a rude, hateful, comment. You should probably re-read the site guidelines.
[dead]
Re:Facebook Relay: An Evil And/Or Incompetent Attack on REST by DanBC on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:51AM (#10432553)
You probably need to re-read the site guidelines.