News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by latchkey on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:06PM (#10423441)
I'm an American (San Francisco) visiting Saigon right now for work. The traffic is insane and the air quality here is horrid (even indoors!). I've been avid cyclist my entire life and motorcyclist for the past 10 years. I use either one in SF almost every day of the week.

Everyone here rides scooters and motorcycles. There is almost zero 'law' when it comes to moving around (walking, biking, car or moto). People drive on the sidewalks, wrong way, don't stop, 2 people a baby and a lawn mower, etc. The amazing thing is that while I'm sure there are a lot of accidents (although I have yet to see one personally), in general things _just seem to work_.

I've rented a moto here and experienced the flow first hand both by myself and with locals. I actually feel much safer on two wheels than while playing frogger trying to cross a street on foot.

I also felt safer here on a moto than I do in SF, simply because the culture here is to accept the insanity and not fight it. In SF the 'us' vs. 'them' argument has gotten so out of control that I feel like many people in cars literally have put a target on my back. I get none of that attitude here in Saigon and it is refreshing.

So if SF wants to let cyclists yield at stop signs because it is actually safer for the cyclist, then let them do it. If you hit the cyclist with your car because they did something stupid, you aren't going to get hurt and you won't be liable (just like before this rule). Many other places in the world have already figured this out and are working just fine.

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by dasil003 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:45PM (#10423584)
You're really putting your finger on something here which is the American attitude and sense of entitlement that infects both sides.

I experienced what you are describing when I moved to London for the last 3 years. Congestion in London is really bad, not just cars, but public transport and pedestrian traffic as well. The city has worked really hard to optimize everything for the massive movement of people. Vans and motorbikes sometimes go onto the pavement (ie. british for sidewalk), and sometimes pedestrians overflow into the road. Buses often go into the oncoming lane to get around other buses with the full expectation that oncoming traffic will make room for them. All of this happens with a fraction of the road rage that you experience on much less congested US streets. Part of it seems to just be an unspoken moral duty and perhaps even comradery of everyone doing there part to help everyone else get where they're going.

That's not to say that it's all rainbows and unicorns in other countries—tube/rail commuting in London can be pretty traumatic, and if there's a strike or mechanical problems the knock-on effect through the system can be dramatic given how stretched it already is—but San Francisco transportion is drastically unoptimized (eg. BART 4-trains/hour per line vs Victoria Line 33-trains/hour) and it's not going to get better by quibbling over rolling stops and warring between drivers and cyclists. There was a time when the American people had the sense of duty and self-sacrifice to get on with massive transportation infrastructure projects like the Interstate Highway System (however misguided it may have been in hindsight), but now it's all about entitlement and NIMBYism and fighting over the crumbs from a decrepit and inadequate system.

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by Symbiote on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @03:45AM (#10424153)
I learnt to drive in London this summer.

Half an hour into the first lesson, the instructor asked me if I cycled regularly in London (yes). He'd noticed that I was yielding to oncoming vehicles some distance away, and said new road users often took several hours of lessons to get the hang of this.

It's possible to fail a driving test if you fail to yield to an approaching vehicle, which includes not moving slightly to the left to let an oncoming bus use part of your lane, and includes a bicycle if they have "right of way".

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by vacri on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:36PM (#10423553)
Saigon is attached to the rest of Vietnam, which is used to slow-moving two-wheel traffic chaos. SF is attached to the rest of the US, which is used to fast-moving four-wheel traffic. When you're making traffic laws, you have to take into account how visitors will commonly behave. Not necessarily limit yourself to their behaviours, but it's important to keep that demographic in mind.
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by latchkey on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @12:06AM (#10423644)
You have a very good point. That said, it isn't the 'SF stop' law they are trying to pass right now. ;-)

Also, I'm a visitor in Vietnam and I'm doing just fine. It goes both ways.

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by abalone on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @04:37AM (#10424298)
That is an utterly unscientific anecdotal argument on an important safety issue. Vietnam has over double the traffic-related fatality rate as the United States.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by monort on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @05:24AM (#10424394)
This difference can be due to driving motorbikes, Vietnam has few cars. According to http://www.iii.org/issue-update/motorcycle-crashes in 2013, motorcyclists were about 26 times more likely than passenger car occupants to die in a crash per vehicle mile traveled and five times more likely to be injured.
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by bweitzman on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:23PM (#10423497)
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by Symbiote on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @03:49AM (#10424171)
I think the number of deaths in Vietnam is significantly higher than reported.

On a two week trip, I saw one fatality, two serious injuries and two minor injuries. This wasn't unusual, most tourists seemed to have seen at least a serious injury within a couple of weeks.

This seemed far more than 10× worse than the UK, where I lived for decades and saw less than one accident (even minor) per year, and where the police take a lot longer to clear things up (they do more investigation).

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by latchkey on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:32PM (#10423536)
Interesting numbers. Vietnam is pretty high up there for deaths / 100k people. I'd attribute that more to the lack of proper safety equipment. Almost everyone wears helmets (required), but they are a joke in terms of quality and nobody wears any sort of armor cause it is too hot. Many people also ride two up which is the max allowed (3 with a baby). The speeds here are also just not that fast because of the traffic and quality of the scooters. Top speed is maybe 30mph.

In San Francisco, I strictly follow ATGATT and have had zero accidents, but a million close calls.

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by roel_v on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @12:46AM (#10423770)
Not to turn this into that discussion again, but helmet do not substantially improve safety while they do significantly reduce acceptance of bikes as a mass transport mode.
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by mvid on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @01:04AM (#10423816)
The previous post was talking about motorcycles.
Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by roel_v on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @01:21AM (#10423851)
Was it? I took it to mean bicycles and light scooters which don't drive much faster than bicycles and share lanes with them; drivers of faster scooters generally do wear helmets, in my experience.

Well if we are talking about motorcycles, then of course, and my previous post doesn't apply.

Re:San Francisco May Let Bicyclists Yield at Stop Signs by wj on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @07:04AM (#10424673)
If you aren't liable as the driver, and the biker is, how does it work if you car is damaged due to them not having auto insurance?

One of the (few) nice things about insurance is that when you are in an auto accident typically the insurance companies battle it out on your behalf rather than you have to sue somebody for damages directly.