News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:12AM (#10419227)
I don't think anybody in a tech role would say they have low pay. Many problems, but that isn't one.

Edit: I meant in a tech role at Amazon. Amazon are not known for low pay.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by rm_-rf_slash on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:20AM (#10419287)
Considering most entry-level positions in big tech pay well but come with outrageous hours and no overtime, an accusation of low pay seems justified. I know plenty of Google engineers who recently started in the Bay Area at around $86,000. Considering the amount of time they're expected to work and the costs of living there, that's pretty pathetic for a huge company with deep pockets.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by nilkn on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:43AM (#10419454)
$86k at Google in 2015? That's the lowest starting salary there I've heard in 5+ years. I'm not saying you're wrong, just saying that not even the cachet of Google could get me to accept that salary in the Bay Area when I could get the same salary in Texas and live twice as nice of a life.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by gogthr on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:05AM (#10419629)
I don't believe there are full time engineers at Google making less than 6 figures. Right out of college at Google I'm making 105 base and way more with stocks/bonuses.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by jnbiche on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:08PM (#10420039)
Wait, so you're making only ~5% more than the threshold you don't believe exists?

You don't think that among the many thousands of people working at Google, perhaps someone has 10% worse negotiating ability than you, or someone's background and experience impressed their interviewers 10% less? Or work in an area of the country with 10% less cost of living?

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by jacquesm on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:31PM (#10420165)
You missed this bit:

> and way more with stocks/bonuses.

The base pay is one thing, the total is quite another. Don't be surprised if the total comes to 200K +.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by lbotos on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:42AM (#10419448)
>Entry level Position.

Median salary for SF Region in 2014 was $75,900. Thats ~10k over the median for an ENTRY level position. Sure, could Google pay them more, absolutely. But I don't think 86k a year is anything to scoff at.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by nilkn on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:52AM (#10419523)
Why should you expect a very technically demanding position that requires passing strenuous filters and interviews to not pay much beyond the median in the entire area across all jobs? Should doctors who've just completed their residency start at $75-85k too just because they're technically entry-level?
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by CaptSpify on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:28AM (#10419336)
You'd be surprised how low people are willing to go in a tough economy. I think the bigger issue is also that techs aren't given a fair-income, especially at places like Amazon, because of the H-1B scam. If you are young and trying to get your foot in the door, you'll put up with the low pay.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by cryoshon on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:49AM (#10419501)
Hm, based off of the wage-fixing done by some of the biggest names in Silicon Valley, I'd say that the pay that tech workers actually get is probably lower than what they're worth. Doesn't mean they have low pay in absolute terms, but I think that for the most part, tech workers could do much better, given the high demand we're seeing right now.
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by seiji on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:48AM (#10419490)
Pay is not an absolute number.

If you make $100,000 per year at an 8 person company, but the company's profit is $12 billion per year — do you have low pay?

The tech industry has discovered you can make employees happy by paying them more than "average," but it's still a lot lower than the benefits, productivity, and supernormal growth powers employees are providing to companies.

A productive software developer is worth at a minimum $3 million per year.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by Johnny555 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:38AM (#10419835)
I don't see how fair pay is linked to company profits, if they are paying you market rate for your job, you're not underpaid whether they earn $12/year in profits or $12B/year in profits.

If the company is earning $12B/year with 12 employees, then the company founders (and early employees who contributed sweat-equity to get the company off the ground) should enjoy their success, but that doesn't mean that they need to pay new hires extravagant amounts of money as a sense of "fairness".

I've seen the balance sheet for my company, and right now, our software developers (well, all employees really) are worth negative dollars per year. Sure, our investors (and to a lesser extent our employees) may be rewarded handsomely some years down the road, but it's not the developers money that's on the line - they get a paycheck for as long as the company is in business, and they have no chance of losing any money they invested in the company. Though even if I could snap my fingers and make the company earn $100M/year overnight, there's no way a developer is worth $3M/year.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by seiji on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:45AM (#10419881)
The concept of "early start" or "sweat equity" resulting in extraordinary reward is a convenient financing meme, but it's not great for reality. It just persists because people like the idea of becoming rewarded more than their contributions.

Just because you "got in early" and worked for a year then coast for the next 10 years while other people pull of the business doesn't mean you should get outsized rewards.

there's no way a developer is worth $3M/year.

Then perhaps your company isn't using developers as efficiently as they could be used? Sure, you can automate a $10 million industry, or you can destroy an $800 billion industry. Not all choices are equal.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by Johnny555 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:08PM (#10420034)
It's not because he got in early and worked for a year, but because he got in early, worked for less (or no) pay than he would have gotten at a more established company. I.e. that developer took on risk, and with risk comes (sometimes) reward. And, his investment may never pay off, the company may never be successful so all of that time and effort spent at low pay may have been for naught.

Not all developers can work for companies poised to take over an $800B industry. For every developer in a disruptive company that's going to earn huge rewards, there's 100 developers writing a web backend for a struggling publishing company, or writing integrations for an ERP implementation. (and though that ERP can save the company millions of dollars, that savings is only due in a small part to that single developer's efforts)

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by seiji on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:17PM (#10420096)
Not all developers can work for companies poised to take over an $800B industry.

That's the point of managing your own career and your own life, isn't it?

Nothing gets handed to you. You have to position yourself for success.

that savings is only due in a small part to that single developer's efforts

Not if you quit, make it SaaS and sell it to 3,000 companies for $100/month (or even $1,000/month).

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by Johnny555 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:04PM (#10420367)
Not all developers can work for companies poised to take over an $800B industry. That's the point of managing your own career and your own life, isn't it?

Well no, it's a market limitation, not every developer can work for companies that are poised to take over an $800B industry. No matter how successful a developer is at such a company, there will still be a need for developers in less lucrative, more mundane jobs.

Not if you quit, make it SaaS and sell it to 3,000 companies for $100/month (or even $1,000/month).

Again, that's the risk part, not every developer is in a place in his life where he can quit his job with a steady paycheck and work for some speculative startup that may or may not ever become successful.

And besides, didn't you just say that developer who quit his job to work at a small startup shouldn't get an outsized reward just because he took that risk to work for an early stage startup?

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by sgustard on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:18AM (#10419712)
Amazon's profit per employee is about $2400. Not sure they can swing that. (360m/150k)
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by seiji on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:14PM (#10420424)
Well, Amazon profit is fictional since they dump so much back into R&D&Growth.

Amazon simply canceled $170 million (http://recode.net/2014/10/23/amazon-takes-170-million-writed...) due to their fire phone failure. Or, they could have given each employee working on the project a bonus of a little over a million dollars.

Easy come, easy go.

Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by ColinCochrane on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:16AM (#10419695)
Not that I necessarily disagree, but how did you arrive at $3 million per year?
Re:Amazon Spars With The Times Over Investigative Article by seiji on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:50AM (#10419915)
Take your yearly salary and turn it into an hourly rate. The standard number is 2087 hours per year for a salaried employee.

So, let's say $100k per year. That's (roughly, rounded up) $50 per hour.

What's minimum wage? A few places have minimum, uneducated, non-creative wage of $15 per hour.

Your hourly rate of $50/hr is about 3x of just somebody who does manual, non-creative labor. Are you worth more than 3x of a restaurant employee? I sure am.

Then, what's your "better than a non-creative womp" multiplier for your output? 10x? Surely you provide more than 10x value as compared to a fast food employee. You're a creative force (or, you can be when you apply yourself). 100x? That's more in the correct range.

So, 100x * minimum wage of $15/hr * 2087 hours/year = $3 million per year.