News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by brandonmenc on Monday October 19, 2015 @02:44PM (#10414748)
> The campaign behind Prohibition was hugely successful — and may have inspired the NRA's modern tactics

I see the NRA adopting something more akin to pro-choice advocacy - a zero compromise scorched earth policy, where any attempt to discuss banning the most extreme products (late term abortions, unlicensed fully automatic weapons) results in arguing uphill against a slippery slope.

(disclaimer: I am an NRA member)

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:27PM (#10415075)
Seeing as how the NRA signed off on a ban of new licensed "fully automatic weapons" in the FOPA of '86, and I can't recall them in my politically aware lifetime challenging the NFA of '34's licensing regime for full auto-weapons, perhaps you might want to study up on this.

If by "modern NRA" you mean the post-"assault weapons" ban NRA, extremely notable because it was the first Federal gun control measure they didn't support, you need a better analogy, one I can't think of. We've already given up so much I can't think of any "extreme product" that would fit the bill.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by brandonmenc on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:59PM (#10415286)
> Seeing as how the NRA signed off on a ban of new licensed "fully automatic weapons" in the FOPA of '86

You're correct, and I am aware because it comes up all the time.

My off-the-cuff comment was more about the membership I've encountered than the official organization.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by drzaiusapelord on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:13PM (#10415381)
This seems like a misinterpretation to me. The NRA draws the line in many places, especially with anything that stinks of military hardware.

Pro-choice advocacy has been on the rope for decades and with recent state laws many abortion access difficult or impossible for poorer women. For example, not is really fighting to overturn the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003. NARAL's website concedes with this language, "NARAL Pro-Choice America does not oppose restrictions on abortion after a certain point in the pregnancy as long as there is an exception to protect the woman’s health." I think society is always going to have a discussion on what kinds of abortions are allowed and at what week. NARAL seems to be part of this conversation and doesn't oppose it.

I don't think either group is special and both work with the status quo of advocacy and lobbying.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:24PM (#10415459)
The NRA draws the line in many places, especially with anything that stinks of military hardware.

The latter turns out not to be the case. Yep, they allowed it for full auto weapons, and AP ammo, but for the first time ever refused to sign off on any and all "assault weapons" bills when that mess started in the late '80s.

Otherwise, yeah, the "compromise" a lot, so much that I'm not a current member and have an alert set for 10 years having passed since they last tried to sell us out. Still has a few years left.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by douche on Monday October 19, 2015 @11:00PM (#10417157)
The "assault weapon" label is complete horse-manure. With $100 of aftermarket components and a half hour, you can take a stock Ruger 10-22 and make it "scary" enough to qualify as an assault weapon, then break it down and reassemble it in it's perfectly innocuous hunting configuration.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:11PM (#10414937)
The pro-choice side has let a lot of things slide without notice. Most notably access is the line in the sand not discouraging hoops.

That said, the NRA has also let a lot of things slide. There pro armor piercing bullets, but not anti-tank rounds. Even if the lack of anti-military hardware makes the second amendment almost pointless.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:37PM (#10415149)
"There pro armor piercing bullets"

Assuming you mean "They're", nope, they signed off on the ban of AP ammo that can be shot from a handgun, which means all AP ammo short of, say, .50 BMG, which I'm pretty sure would pulverize anyone's hand, wrist and arm.

As for "the lack of anti-military hardware makes the second amendment almost pointless.", you suffer from a lack of imagination:

The small arms we're all allowed to own everywhere but NYC and D.C. are quite sufficient to procure the heavier stuff.

Being able to reach out and touch someone from 800 yards and more means something serious.

The US has never fought a war without a secure rear area.

There are many, many other things small arms make more achievable. Like making it too expensive to do a lot of things en masse; as Alexander Solzhenitsyn put it in The GULAG Archipelago:

And how we burned in the camps later, thinking: What would things have been like if every security operative, when he went out at night to make an arrest, had been uncertain whether he would return alive and had to say good-bye to his family?

Or if, during periods of mass arrests, as for example in Leningrad, when they arrested a quarter of the entire city, people had not simply sat there in their lairs, paling with terror at every bang of the downstairs door and at every step on the staircase, but had understood they had nothing left to lose and had boldly set up in the downstairs hall an ambush of half a dozen people with axes, hammers, pokers, or whatever else was at hand?

After all, you knew ahead of time that those bluecaps were out at night for no good purpose. And you could be sure ahead of time that you’d be cracking the skull of a cutthroat. Or what about the Black Maria [Government limo] sitting out there on the street with one lonely chauffeur — what if it had been driven off or its tires spiked.

The Organs would very quickly have suffered a shortage of officers and transport and, notwithstanding all of Stalin’s thirst, the cursed machine would have ground to a halt!

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by geoka9 on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:07PM (#10415757)
I'm afraid Solzhenitsyn is a bit naive in thinking that would've caused the oppression to stop. The authorities would have just moved in the troops and introduced military law, shooting people without hesitation. After all that's what they did in Budapest in 1956 and Prague in 1968.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by shaftoe on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:33PM (#10416516)
I think you miss the point. Of course someone with a stick against the NKVD is at a serious disadvantage. Of course Stalin didn't hesitate to murder millions.

The point is the bitter shame at having gone quietly and meekly to the camps. The regret at having not fought to defend oneself.

The counter example would be the Warsaw ghetto.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Zak on Monday October 19, 2015 @09:00PM (#10416832)
.50 BMG, which I'm pretty sure would pulverize anyone's hand

Actually, that's been done: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNZgzMtIM7s

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:57PM (#10415684)
By that line of thinking all you need is some sticks not guns to get the ball rolling. Making guns irrelevant if your goal is to protect freedom.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by nsxwolf on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:44PM (#10415190)
Pointless? Every war the US has fought since Vietnam has essentially been a matchup of the full might of the US military against rocks and sticks, and the rocks and sticks always win.

Millions of like minded American citizens could certainly make things difficult for the US military in a guerrilla war.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by lispit on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:58PM (#10415280)
There's some weird cognitive dissonance going on where many of the people that love to point out that the US military can't possibly succeed against guerrilla combatants in the Middle East are the same people that laugh at "gun nuts" for "thinking their small arms would do anything against the military's tanks, artillery, airstrikes, etc."
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by brandonmenc on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:07PM (#10415341)
There's also a failure to acknowledge that some of the military would fight with the gun nuts, not against them.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by thaumasiotes on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:39PM (#10416545)
Also, being sent against the populace is terrible for military morale -- making your guerrilla force slightly more dangerous can end up having really large knock-on effects as soldiers get pushed into things they're not comfortable with.

A lot of people have no problem rounding up a mob, maybe beating them up, and tossing them in jail; a lot of those same people will think twice before saying "We can't go in on the ground... I want to be a part of clearing that mob by bombing it to pulp".

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by douche on Monday October 19, 2015 @10:48PM (#10417128)
Actually, looking at the demographics of the branches of the military that would be most involved in attempting to suppress a home-grown rebellion of gun-owners, it's more than likely that there would be wide-spread mutiny.

Or else an exodus of the leadership and rank-and-file soldiery on par with the Southerners that resigned in '61.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by whatok on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:52PM (#10415648)
And the fact that if the military started slaughtering their own citizens with tanks and bombs, um that kinda might not be seen as too positive to the rest of the world.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by lispit on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:46PM (#10416014)
That's another good bit of cognitive dissonance. I'd wager that many of these same people are aware of and support movements like #BlackLivesMatter, that use social media to spread awareness of instances of police brutality to massive audiences. Yet they never stop to consider how effective those same tactics could be in a theoretical armed resistance. Imagine someone recording a group of teenaged American rebels being slaughtered by the military, the media running with it and getting statements from the bereaved families, further polarizing would-be rebels while sparking dissent amongst the other side, growing lack of respect with the military, etc.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by 13thLetter on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:58PM (#10416620)
"the media running with it and getting statements from the bereaved families"

I wouldn't hold my breath expecting, say, MSNBC to give extensive sympathetic coverage to domestic "insurgents" who don't share their political views. The vast majority of the Tea Party did nothing more than yell at congressmen and hold rallies where they got all the official permits and cleaned up after themselves, and yet they were uniformly regarded in the news media as the second coming of Timothy McVeigh. Imagine how the media would treat them if they did anything more with their guns than the occasional dumb open carry stunt in Texas.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by notahacker on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:48PM (#10416328)
I don't think the average liberal underestimates the effectiveness of social media, least of all when it comes to publicising the slaughter of American teenagers.

It's just the incidences of slaughter they - perhaps optimistically given the US status quo - believe may be reduced through gun controls are actually happening on a not infrequent basis, whereas the Second Civil War scenarios are wildly unlikely fantasy.

People believe social media campaigns might work precisely because they don't think that the only thing keeping the US from turning into a fascist police state is consumer weaponry.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by lispit on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:32PM (#10416510)
>It's just the incidences of slaughter they - perhaps optimistically given the US status quo - believe may be reduced through gun controls are actually happening on a not infrequent basis, whereas the Second Civil War scenarios are wildly unlikely fantasy.

That's a reasonable opinion, but one I disagree with. A second secession movement and full-blown Civil War will probably never happen, but martial law ordered in response to protest or active resistance of a law is not unthinkable. The risk of death by gun violence in the United States is dwarfed by the risk of death by automobile accident, heart disease, and so on. I would absolutely rather live in a country of ~320 million with a few thousand deaths per year due to gun violence, than in one with no weapons to deter martial law. I'll take a small (blown out of proportion by the media) threat over an existential threat any day.

And that's even assuming that you could make gun violence disappear entirely overnight. Revoking access to registered firearms could very well reduce the number of spree shootings, but would do little to affect the black market supply used by criminals in robberies and turf wars, and probably increase the amount of gun violence used in robberies (as criminals would then be sure that no one would be able to resist them).

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:39PM (#10416538)
And that's also overstating the fictitious "gun violence", which is conflating public shootings with suicides. Factor that out, and police shootings of felons, and you find auto deaths dwarf shootings, accidental or otherwise
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:52PM (#10416593)
The US is a police state. Just look at the % of people in prison and compare it with say North Korea vs Europe or even South America.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:53PM (#10415658)
The troubles in northern Ireland suggest you can have a long term insurgency without losing a country. Of note it was not defeated with military power, but it was also failed in it's long term goals.

As such there is no cognitive dissonance as propping up a country is different from crushing all opposition.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @09:57AM (#10419125)
Indeed. These people who seem to want violent insurgency as a political right should take a look at how that works out in situations other than the US war of independence. It's usually indecisive with a lot of people getting killed more or less at random.

Mind you, last time I ran the numbers, it was safer to be in Belfast during the troubles than in Detroit over the same period.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by notahacker on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:25PM (#10415902)
Personally I don't see any cognitive dissonance in thinking that a messy decades-long guerrilla war would represent both a failure to "export democracy" when taking place overseas and a failure to "defend democracy" if taking place in one's own neighbourhood.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by ArkyBeagle on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:40PM (#10416299)
Uncle Ho was prepared to throw any number of people under the bus for a unified Vietnam. Our senior command just didn't understand this or couldn't deal with it.

Estimates are a million Vietnamese died between 1950 and 1975.

And you understand that the entire plot of "Apocolypse Now" ( which was fiction ) was that Kurtz was prepared to use any means to win, and that this is why he was targeted for assassination? "His methods were... unsound."

This led to the Powell Doctrine. In the early-90s Gulf War I, the objective was actually met, although the resulting equilibrium was not stable.

Open-ended foreign entanglements are generally bad practice.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:09PM (#10416413)
Uncle Ho was prepared to throw any number of people under the bus for a unified Vietnam.

Case in point: they had a policy of regularly making battalion strength night attacks on our fixed positions, deliberately sacrificing about a company's worth of men. It worked because it made our commanders unreasonably afraid of venturing outside at night.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by ArkyBeagle on Monday October 19, 2015 @07:27PM (#10416483)
It's still hard to come to grips with even just as an exercise.

We had similar difficulties in the Pacific in WWII with the Bushido Code. The reaction there was, shall we say, less restrained. Grim business, founded in a vehement racism as a central operating principle.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by MichaelGG on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:25PM (#10415467)
It'd be even worse most likely, as US troops are gonna act much differently domestically and would almost certainly be much more reserved. Gonna be much harder to shoot potential enemies when they literally are your friends (taking a looser, FB-ish value of friendship).

Better for the world would just be splitting up the US, like AT&T was. Perhaps 3 or 4 ways? Then you'd have much smaller countries to deal with, easier to make changes and reflect citizens' desires. Plus it'd create some competition, for trade and so on.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by dragonwriter on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:55PM (#10415675)
> It'd be even worse most likely, as US troops are gonna act much differently domestically and would almost certainly be much more reserved.

That's highly optimistic. I would say that history does not generally support the idea that militaries in general, or the US military in particular, are more reserved when dealing with a perceived internal existential threat than they are fighting overseas.

> Gonna be much harder to shoot potential enemies when they literally are your friends (taking a looser, FB-ish value of friendship).

That's one view. Another view is that its a lot easier to see the enemy as an intolerable foe against whom any means are justified when you don't see them as "loyally fighting for their country" the same as you, just on a different side, but instead as potentially fatally betraying your country.

I'd say the history of domestic armed conflicts (including the US Civil War) suggests that the latter effect is often at least as strong as the former.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Thimothy on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:52AM (#10419522)
>That's highly optimistic. I would say that history does not generally support the idea that militaries in general, or the US military in particular, are more reserved when dealing with a perceived internal existential threat than they are fighting overseas.

That's... Not exactly true. History has actually shown the contrary, WASP are usually very soft on other WASP while bloody on everybody else. Examples:

-The US civil war is a perfect sample. I don't think you could find another battle in history but Gettysburg were opposing armies of many tens of thousands fought with just one civil casualty (and an accident, this one). Usually, after a battle is won there is this period of pillaging, raping and general dead and destruction. If you want to see how a real after-civil-war-repression looks like, look at what Cromwell did in Ireland, it's the stuff of nightmares. (Which also supports my argument, because he was very soft on his British opponents).

-There is also the anglo-american war of 1812. The British "sacked" Washington, with, again, only 1 (ONE!) casualty. I mean, come on, it's like they weren't even trying. For contrast, look at what a real British occupation looked like at the time with the suppression of the rebellion of the Sinhalese in Sri Lanka in 1818.

My point: If the US start killing each other seriously, that would be a new in history.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @09:55AM (#10419115)
be much harder to shoot potential enemies when they literally are your friends

If this were the case, the US wouldn't be notorious for high numbers of police shootings. It's far more likely that if there is some kind of US civil war it would be race-based, like the previous civil war and the Indian wars.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:51AM (#10419519)
You're assuming the police and the military attract the same sort of people, keep them under the same sort of discipline (or lack thereof for the police), etc. That's not my impression at all.

In fact, there tend to be two different types of militaries, the expeditionary type, which is ours, and the internally focused type, which our increasingly paramilitarized police seem to be becoming. The latter suck when they're asked to fight a "real war", and one advantage we in the US have right now is that their numbers are quite small compared to the size of the nation or our formal military, something less than a million total.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by raddad on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:34PM (#10415948)
They would simply bring in UN "peacekeeping" force. Problem solve. Foreign military on US soil shooting citizens. I don't know if you have seen UN vehicles staged at various bases around the US, I've seen them at a National Guard staging area. The system is already in place. There have been sightings of UN troop movements along the US/Canada border.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:39PM (#10415983)
That would just make target identification utterly trivial. And the UN finds it very difficult to find competent troops for much less hostile environments, what country would sign up for this sort of debacle?
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hoorayimhelping on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:29PM (#10415498)
>Even if the lack of anti-military hardware makes the second amendment almost pointless.

The British military thought the same about a bunch of hicks with a few rifles living on the east coast of America. America's military thought the same thing about a bunch of tribal shepherds in Afghanistan. The point is, you don't need to match a military on hardware to defeat them.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:44PM (#10415590)
Read some history. I would suggest starting with US civil war which notably failed.

The 'US' revolution was losing the war prior to significant aid from France. And this was vs. an oversea enemy using 1700's era weapons and armaments. Vietnam involved some direct military engagements vs. jets and other modern weaponry.

There are a few successful uprising in modern history, and lots of crushed attempts vs. far worse military's than the modern US war machine.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by 15155 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:05AM (#10417364)
The US Civil War didn't fail due to a lack of equivalent armaments, just to make that very clear.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by Retric on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:49AM (#10418592)
Depends on what you mean by equivalent. Honestly, if the south had the technology and manufacturing advantage it probably would have won as the overall military's started out fairly equivalent.

The most famous of these guns, the Spencer carbine, could fire seven shots in 30 seconds.

Like many other Civil War technologies, these weapons were available to Northern troops but not Southern ones: Southern factories had neither the equipment nor the know-how to produce them.

http://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/civil-war-t...

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by rcurry on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:36PM (#10415137)
I just have never seen this - the NRA arguing that full automatic weapons should not be licensed. Do you have a citation? I'd be genuinely interested to read up on it.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by hga on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:12PM (#10415375)
I'm not aware they argued that even in 1934, when they were focused on removing handguns from the NFA's licencing and prohibitive tax, $3,500 in 2015 dollars (and that in a period where the Depression had gotten truly Great).
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by 15155 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:05AM (#10417368)
I am amazed that this hasn't been successfully challenged via the "poll tax" argument.
Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by ArkyBeagle on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:47PM (#10416324)
I think there is a sign bit inverted here - the NRA would be in the position of opposing "gun prohibition". Volstead-Act style prohibition of guns would result in gunrunning, which is arguably the nastiest form of organized crime.

I am sure that propaganda tropes would be highly common between the Wayne Wheeler continuum and the NRA - there are not that many forms of propaganda.

Re:Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group by scrollaway on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:07PM (#10414897)
Do you think that is a good tactic (both on effectiveness and on a moral level)? If so, why?