News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by jpatokal on Sunday October 18, 2015 @06:48PM (#10410189)
The same question is being asked about the Airbus A380, and the A350 is also way over budget and behind schedule. I suspect it's a matter of time until a Chinese manufacturer ramps up and stomps all over the current airplane market with cheap yet perfectly serviceable planes.

Anecdote: A few years back, I flew on a Xian MA60, a perfectly serviceable commuter turboprop that's technically a descendant of the venerable Soviet Antonov An-24 but in practice competes agains the ATR-42. A small detail that weirded me out is how the garish livery on the seats inside looks exactly like the one used in Chinese buses... which have also essentially obliterated Western companies' bus sales in large swathes of Asia.

http://www.patokallio.name/photo/travel/Laos/LaoAirlines/Lao...

http://www.patokallio.name/photo/travel/Laos/LaoAirlines/Lao...

The MA60's current customer list is a wacky but wide collection of obscure outfits (Air Burundi, Lao Airlines, Boliviana...):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xian_MA60#Customer_summary

So what's the market going to look like when planes like the 737 clone Comac C919 start ramping up?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comac_C919

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by notahacker on Sunday October 18, 2015 @07:18PM (#10410277)
I'm not sure that Airbus and Boeing have much to fear from the C919, though I'm sure it'll sell well enough in China.

Aircraft purchasers are conservative, and they're much more concerned about operating costs, reliability, availability of third party maintenance and type-rated pilots and residual values than they are about acquisition costs, with the 737 and A320 enjoying massive brand and network effects. You only have to look at the struggles of the Sukhoi Superjet to find buyers outside Russia for what is reportedly a very decent modern aircraft. It's also a racing certainty that COMAC will suffer similar if not worse problems with delays and complications to the programme. Launching all-new aircraft is hard even when you have substantial expertise in doing it.

The A380 is failing for a different reason: there just isn't the level of demand for an aircraft of that size to make the programme viable.

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by ubernostrum on Sunday October 18, 2015 @07:58PM (#10410372)
Another important point is how many airlines have standardized their narrow-body fleets. Maintaining a single type/family is simpler and often cheaper than having trained crew, mechanics and parts available for multiple types of aircraft.

In the US, for example, Southwest and (mainline) Alaska are both pure-737 fleets. Virgin America, Frontier and Spirit are all A320-family, with JetBlue operating only A320 family and the E190. US Airways, prior to its merger with American, was moving toward an all-A320-family narrow-body fleet and was nearly there (only a few 757s were left, and US Airways was looking to replace them with a long-range variant of the A321 once it became available).

So a new narrow-body type -- whether it's COMAC's C919 or Bombardier's C-Series -- probably will never make it into those carriers' fleets, which in turn makes it that much harder to break into the market.

Added to that, the existing manufacturers (Airbus and Boeing) are established enough and have the resources to be able to offer significant discounts to an airline which commits to a large fleet overhaul. New entrants likely are not financially able to do that, putting them at more of a disadvantage in trying to place their first aircraft with the airlines.

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by caf on Sunday October 18, 2015 @08:38PM (#10410470)
The C-Series isn't supposed to compete with the B737 or A320 - it's a smaller aircraft, intended to replace aging B717s and the like.
Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by ubernostrum on Sunday October 18, 2015 @09:01PM (#10410521)
In terms of passenger capacity and range, the CS300 falls somewhere in between the current 737-700 and 737-800, or current A319 and A320.

The CS100 is more of a 717/E-190 competitor, but the CS300 is absolutely aimed at the types of roles 737s and A319s/A320s are currently deployed in.

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by christoph on Sunday October 18, 2015 @07:00PM (#10410229)
Hopefully a bit less accident prone...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xian_MA60#Accidents_and_incide...

Not sure of it's current state, but it was denied UK & US certification on the basis of technical flaws last I heard.

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by ams6110 on Sunday October 18, 2015 @08:49PM (#10410499)
To be fair, most of those accidents seem to be pilot error of one sort or another, perhaps more a critique of airline competency in that part of the world, rather than the aircraft itself.
Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by yread on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:07AM (#10411874)
Well on other planes a pilot error causing a hard landing usually doesn't end up with the wings falling off. Extended list of accidents and incidents:

http://www.avherald.com/h?search_term=ma60&opt=0&dosearch=1&...

Re:Will 787 program ever show an overall profit? Analysts gr... by caf on Sunday October 18, 2015 @08:36PM (#10410461)
There's talk that the Bombardier CSeries program is in trouble, too.