Re:Freakonomics: Quantifying Teacher Effectiveness?
by ams6110 on Friday January 08, 2010 @07:20PM
(#1040778)
Honestly, the really big factor in teaching effectiveness is the parents. If a kid is living in a household with dysfunctional or drug-addicted parents who don't give a damn about school, then with rare exceptions it doesn't matter how good the teachers are.
Re:Freakonomics: Quantifying Teacher Effectiveness?
by julius_geezer on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:53AM
(#1041505)
Apparently one can overcome some of that with sufficient resources.
But in general you make a good point The main thing is probably not that the parents help with all those "science" projects the pranksters inflict in the primary grades, rather that the parents back the school and convey the message that school is important. A woman I know well remarks that she taught O- and A-level chemistry to girls from villages barely out of the stone age in east Africa 50 years ago.
Re:Freakonomics: Quantifying Teacher Effectiveness?
by epistemenical on Sunday January 10, 2010 @08:15PM
(#1044054)
Family involvement helps children get ready to enter school, promotes their school success, and prepares youth for college.
That's a very different thing from what you claimed (which is that family involvement is the end-all of education). Clearly families make a difference, but they're far from the only factor, and the summary there certainly doesn't support the claim that it's impossible to succeed without good familial support. Education is a complicated thing where a lot of things matter.
Re:Freakonomics: Quantifying Teacher Effectiveness?
by pmichaud on Friday January 08, 2010 @02:22PM
(#1040199)
The interesting part isn't what makes a great teacher, which is largely intuitive. The part I want to know about is how to produce and reward those effective teachers systematically.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1036509
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WwslBPj8GgI
titled: Confessions of a converted lecturer.
But in general you make a good point The main thing is probably not that the parents help with all those "science" projects the pranksters inflict in the primary grades, rather that the parents back the school and convey the message that school is important. A woman I know well remarks that she taught O- and A-level chemistry to girls from villages barely out of the stone age in east Africa 50 years ago.
That's a very different thing from what you claimed (which is that family involvement is the end-all of education). Clearly families make a difference, but they're far from the only factor, and the summary there certainly doesn't support the claim that it's impossible to succeed without good familial support. Education is a complicated thing where a lot of things matter.