News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:04PM (#10397085)
I feel like you are making the complete opposite argument from the linked article: "We should have a BI because it will reduce consumption by the rich and increase savings by the poor, thereby increasing investment."

Is that a fair statement?

Also, given that you believe the rich and poor have equal propensity to spend, I assume you have no objection to Keynesian stimulus targeting the rich during times of recession?

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by djrobstep on Friday October 16, 2015 @12:55AM (#10397539)
I see you've given up on responding to my points so you're making up strawmen you think you can knock down instead.

I didn't claim that a BI will increase investment.

I didn't claim that believe the rich and poor have equal propensity to spend.

I said that if you want to increase investment (with or without a BI) there are plenty of ways to do that.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Friday October 16, 2015 @07:38AM (#10398641)
...only shifted consumption from the rich to the poor...

I didn't claim that believe the rich and poor have equal propensity to spend.

The former implies the latter.

I didn't claim that a BI will increase investment.

... if poor and middle class folks have a higher and more reliable income, they are more likely to save.

Now you seem to be agreeing with me that the article is wrong, and that a BI would increase real consumption and reduce real investment?

Could you state clearly what you think will happen to real (not nominal) consumption/investment under a BI and what the mechanism for that is?