Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee. Parent comment
I didn't claim that believe the rich and poor have equal propensity to spend.
The former implies the latter.
I didn't claim that a BI will increase investment.
... if poor and middle class folks have a higher and more reliable income, they are more likely to save.
Now you seem to be agreeing with me that the article is wrong, and that a BI would increase real consumption and reduce real investment?
Could you state clearly what you think will happen to real (not nominal) consumption/investment under a BI and what the mechanism for that is?
There are no comments on this comment yet.
I didn't claim that believe the rich and poor have equal propensity to spend.
The former implies the latter.
I didn't claim that a BI will increase investment.
... if poor and middle class folks have a higher and more reliable income, they are more likely to save.
Now you seem to be agreeing with me that the article is wrong, and that a BI would increase real consumption and reduce real investment?
Could you state clearly what you think will happen to real (not nominal) consumption/investment under a BI and what the mechanism for that is?