Sounds like it would pretty much legitimise the problems with the current system. Or maybe I'm missing some key part here?
I don't.
I think you forget how Proof of Work works. Candidates can just buy more and more mining power to put their opponents out of the race.
It sounds like the problem you're trading for is the one that Bitcoin solved in the first place: No need for a central database of users. How do you decentralize authentication of one-person-one vote? I'm not sure it's even possible
Sort of forming a web of trust, but with negative incentives against signing for anyone trying to double vote?
Or maybe it is impossible.
It seems there would be a problem if the web of trust was fragmented, because for anyone not in a particular region of the wot, they would be unable to tell if it was a real wot, or only a fake one.
So any voting that occurred would have to only apply within a contiguous wot, and anyone in a different region would have to not have that vote count for them.
So, in a limited form like that, it could maybe be possible, but I don't know what it would be worth, because I don't know what sorts of things would be worth voting on, if the result of the vote can only apply to the identities used in the vote, because anyone could make another identity not part of the wot if they did not like the vote outcome. And a number of other similar problems.
notto take away from your main point, but money is a social convention, too....
Lets see hackers invent decentralized currency, hackers invent decentralized government democracy 2.0, people encrypt all their data and decentralize communications.
reboot